TITLE

Probability Values and Human Values in Evaluating Single-Sex Education

AUTHOR(S)
Liben, Lynn
PUB. DATE
May 2015
SOURCE
Sex Roles;May2015, Vol. 72 Issue 9-10, p401
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Around the globe, educational opportunities and outcomes have long varied in relation to student gender. Within the United States, a particularly intense and growing controversy concerns whether education should be delivered in single-sex contexts. This paper offers a broad framework for approaching this controversy. I review arguments made by historical and contemporary proponents of gender-differentiated education, concluding that these reveal a foundational commitment to gender essentialism (rather than to gender constructivism more commonly embraced by critics of single-sex schooling). I suggest that different gender conceptualizations and different professional traditions affect the kind of data one collects, weighs, and reports. Gender conceptualizations also affect the valence assigned to the amplification or attenuation of gender differences in educational, career, or personal student outcomes. I then propose that other kinds of human values are also relevant to the controversy. Given that in justifying their position, advocates of single-sex public education have recently been focusing less on gendered brain differences and more on the expansion of educational choice, I focus especially on the value of choice. Using arguments paralleling those found in critiques of the U.S. charter-school movement, I suggest that decisions about school choice necessarily entail judgments about a range of goals and human priorities. I close by suggesting that a resolution of the controversy about single-sex education cannot be reached through empirical data alone, but will require discussions of gender conceptualizations, what constitutes evidence, ideal educational outcomes, and broader human values.
ACCESSION #
103365236

 

Related Articles

  • Thoughts on 'Probability Values and Human Values in Evaluating Single-Sex Education'. Huston, Aletha // Sex Roles;May2015, Vol. 72 Issue 9-10, p446 

    In her commentary on single-sex instruction in the United States, Liben () puts the research on gender-segregated instruction in the context of values and the larger social and political processes affecting decisions about schooling. In this paper, I elaborate on her history of the research and...

  • Challenges in Evaluating Single-Sex Education. Signorella, Margaret // Sex Roles;May2015, Vol. 72 Issue 9-10, p397 

    As a conclusion to the two-part special issue on single-sex education in Sex Roles (Signorella and Bigler 2011, 2013a), this Feminist Forum opens with a concluding commentary by Liben (2015), followed by commentaries on Liben's paper from three different perspectives. Liben provides an...

  • Anecdotal and Essentialist Arguments for Single-Sex Educational Programs Discussed by Liben: a Legal Analysis. Sherwin, Galen // Sex Roles;May2015, Vol. 72 Issue 9-10, p434 

    This commentary responds to Liben's () 'Probability Values and Human Values in Evaluating Single-Sex Education' by analyzing the values she discusses through a legal framework. As Liben correctly points out, many single-sex education programs are animated by claims regarding 'hard wired'...

  • Expanding the Role of Gender Essentialism in the Single-Sex Education Debate: A Commentary on Liben. Fine, C.; Duke, R. // Sex Roles;May2015, Vol. 72 Issue 9-10, p427 

    In this commentary we expand on Liben's exploration of the effects of differing gender conceptualizations - gender essentialism and gender constructivism - on the single-sex education debate within the United States. We examine these conceptualizations in the context of current behavioral and...

  • Know how to prep for potential changes in Title IX regs. McCarthy, Claudine // Campus Legal Advisor;Jul2019, Vol. 19 Issue 11, p4 

    Until the federal government announces new Title IX regulations, higher education administrators must go beyond taking a wait‐and‐see approach to take proactive preparation steps. But how exactly can you prepare for unspecified, unknown changes?

  • The Pros and Cons of Single-Gender Classrooms.  // Curriculum Review;Oct2010, Vol. 50 Issue 2, p9 

    The article discusses a dual academy at the Imagine Southeast Public Charter School in Washington, D.C. where boys and girls are placed in single-gender classrooms. The article describes the structure of the program and provides statistics for single-sex classes in public schools throughout the...

  • Single-Sex Classrooms. HERRON, ARIKA // Education Digest;May2014, Vol. 79 Issue 9, p49 

    A reprint of an article from the December 11, 2013 issue of publication the "Winston-Salem Journal" is presented, which focuses on the use of single-sex classrooms in at Winston-Salem Preparatory Academy in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. Topics discussed include the academic motivation that has...

  • Title IX: Guide to Critical Analysis.  // Points of View: Title IX;3/1/2016, p4 

    The article offers a critical guide to the controversial issue of Title IX, a U.S. law established to provide equal opportunities to female students. The article discusses criteria in understanding the issue, such as distinguishing between fact and opinion and recognizing point and counterpoint...

  • A Meta-Analytic Critique of Mael et al.'s (2005) Review of Single-Sex Schooling. Signorella, Margaret; Hayes, Amy; Li, Yidi // Sex Roles;Oct2013, Vol. 69 Issue 7-8, p423 

    Continued controversy in the United States over the relation of school gender composition to student outcomes is partially due to the failure to reach consensus on how to evaluate the research and the conclusions to be drawn from the research. In this review we examine major problems in the...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics