A systematic review of the sleep, sleepiness, and performance implications of limited wake shift work schedules

Short, Michelle A.; Agostini, Alexandra; Lushington, Kurt; Dorrian, Jillian
September 2015
Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health;2015, Vol. 41 Issue 5, p425
Academic Journal
Objectives The aim of this review was to identify which limited wake shift work schedules (LWSW) best promote sleep, alertness, and performance. LWSW are fixed work/rest cycles where the time-at-work does is =8 hours and there is >1 rest period per day, on average, for =2 consecutive days. These schedules are commonly used in safety-critical industries such as transport and maritime industries. Methods Literature was sourced using PubMed, Embase, PsycInfo, Scopus, and Google Scholar databases. We identified 20 independent studies (plus a further 2 overlapping studies), including 5 laboratory and 17 field-based studies focused on maritime watch keepers, ship bridge officers, and long-haul train drivers. The measurement of outcome measures was varied, incorporating subjective and objective measures of sleep: sleep diaries (N=5), actigraphy (N=4), and polysomnography, (N=3); sleepiness: Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (N=5), visual analog scale (VAS) alertness (N=2) and author-derived measures (N=2); and performance: Psychomotor Vigilance Test (PVT) (N=5), Reaction Time or Vigilance tasks (N=4), Vector and Letter Cancellation Test (N=1), and subjective performance (N=2). Results Of the three primary rosters examined (6 hours-on/6 hours-off, 8 hours-on/8 hours-off and 4 hourson/ 8 hours-off), the 4 hours-on/8 hours-off roster was associated with better sleep and lower levels of sleepiness. Individuals working 4 hours-on/8 hours-off rosters averaged 1 hour more sleep per night than those working 6 hours-on/6 hours-off and 1.3 hours more sleep than those working 8 hours-on/8 hours-off (P<0.01). More broadly, findings indicate that LWSW schedules were associated with better sleep and lower sleepines in the case of (i) shorter time-at-work, (ii) more frequent rest breaks, (iii) shifts that start and end at the same clock time every 24 hours, and (iv) work shifts commencing in the daytime (as opposed to night). The findings for performance remain incomplete due to the small number of studies containing a performance measure and the heterogeneity of performance measures within those that did. Conclusion The literature supports the utility of LWSW in industries where individuals sleep at or near the workplace as they facilitate at least some sleep during the biological night and minimize deficits associated with time-on-shift with shorter shifts. Overall, the 4 hour-on/8 hour-off roster best promoted sleep and minimized sleepiness compared to other LWSW schedules. Nevertheless, and considering the safety-critical nature of industries which employ LWSW, the limited literature needs to be greatly expanded with specific focus on the consequences for performance and comparison to mainstream rosters.


Related Articles

  • Citation searching: a systematic review case study of multiple risk behaviour interventions. Wright, Kath; Golder, Su; Rodriguez-Lopez, Rocio // BMC Medical Research Methodology;2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Background The value of citation searches as part of the systematic review process is currently unknown. While the major guides to conducting systematic reviews state that citation searching should be carried out in addition to searching bibliographic databases there are still few studies in the...

  • Retention of sealants during orthodontic treatment: An in vitro comparison of two etching protocols. Rossini, Gabriele; Parrini, Simone; Castroflorio, Tommaso; Deregibus, Andrea; Debernardi, Cesare L. // Angle Orthodontist;Sep2015, Vol. 85 Issue 5, p750 

    Objective: To test the retention of smooth-surface sealants bonded with different etching protocols against toothbrushing and, secondarily, to characterize the type and location of sealant loss. Materials and Methods: Eighty-nine extracted human teeth were randomly assigned one of two etching...

  • A review and update on the current status of retinal prostheses (bionic eye). Luo, Yvonne H.-L.; da Cruz, Lyndon // British Medical Bulletin;Mar2014, Vol. 109 Issue 1, p31 

    Introduction/background The Argus® II is the first retinal prosthesis approved for the treatment of patients blind from retinitis pigmentosa (RP), receiving CE (Conformité Européenne) marking in March 2011 and FDA approval in February 2013. Alpha-IMS followed closely and obtained CE...

  • Does it Matter Which Citation Tool is Used to Compare the h-index of a Group of Highly Cited Researchers? Farhadi, Hadi; Salehi, Hadi; Md Yunus, Melor; Chadegani, Arezoo Aghaei; Farhadi, Maryam; Fooladi, Masood; Ale Ebrahim, Nader // Australian Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences;Apr2013, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p198 

    h-index retrieved by citation indexes (Scopus, Google scholar, and Web of Science) is used to measure the scientific performance and the research impact studies based on the number of publications and citations of a scientist. It also is easily available and may be used for performance measures...

  • EFFECTS OF AQUATIC PROGRAMS IN CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS WITH CEREBRAL PALSY: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW. Jorgić, Bojan; Dimitrijević, Lidija; Lambeck, Johan; Aleksandrović, Marko; Okičić, Tomislav; Madić, Dejan // Sport Science;2012, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p49 

    Cerebral palsy is the most common cause of serious physical disability in childhood. Inadequate physical fitness is one of the major problems in children with cerebral palsy. Various aquatic activities and exercises can improve fitness levels in children with cerebral palsy. The aim of this...

  • Mental Health Response to Community Disasters A Systematic Review. North, Carol S.; Pfefferbaum, Betty // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;8/7/2013, Vol. 310 Issue 5, p507 

    IMPORTANCE Exposure to a disaster is common, and one-third or more of individuals severely exposed may develop posttraumatic stress disorder or other disorders. A systematic approach to the delivery of timely and appropriate disaster mental health services may facilitate their integration into...

  • What to Do When Everyone Wants You to Collaborate: Managing the Demand for Library Support in Systematic Review Searching. Campbell, Sandy; Dorgan, Marlene // Journal of the Canadian Health Libraries Association (JCHLA);avr2015, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p11 

    The demand for systematic review support in academic health sciences libraries is increasing. To manage the demand, the John W. Scott Health Sciences Library at the University of Alberta has created an action plan consisting of eight strategies. The results of implementing these strategies have...

  • Sources for Scientific Frustrations: Productivity and Citation Data. Zauder, KreŠimir; Pečarić, Đilda; Tuđman, Miroslav // Central European Conference on Information & Intelligent Systems;9/21/2011, p235 

    The paper discusses usage of citation indices and similar databases as the source of data for determining scientific professional advancement. A short study on per-author basis, using Web of Science, Scopus, Google Scholar, Croatian scientific bibliography and online catalogue of the National...

  • La producción científica iberoamericana en ciencias de la nutrición: La indización en PubMed y Google Scholar. Franco-Pérez, Alvaro Moisés; Sanz-Valero, Javier; Wanden-Berghe, Carmina; Melian-Fleitas, Liliana // Nutricion Hospitalaria;nov2014, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p1165 

    Objective: Analyze by bibliometric technique, the Iberoamerican scientific literature related to the nutritional sciences and retrieved on main search engines with free access through Internet (PubMed and Google Scholar). Method: Bibliometric analysis of scientific production recovered in the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics