TITLE

Is Corporate Governance a Structure, A Process, a Group of Policies, or Something Else?

AUTHOR(S)
Crow, Peter; Lockhart, James
PUB. DATE
January 2015
SOURCE
Proceedings of the European Conference on Management, Leadership;2015, p89
SOURCE TYPE
Conference Proceeding
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Over recent decades boards of directors and corporate governance have become the subjects of much research. Many definitions and concepts of corporate governance have appeared in the literature-more so as knowledge about companies; shareholdings; boards; management; board-management interactions; and, control has expanded. However, no singular concept of corporate governance appears to have been universally accepted. This deficiency is most likely because the ontological basis of the phenomenon/field is yet to be resolved. The empiricist concept in the literature, frequently cited in practice holds that corporate governance is a structure, a process, policy framework or some combination of all three. However, boards, board-management interaction and corporate governance seem to be "the product of a plurality of structures" (Bhaskar, 1989, p. 3) that can be associated hierarchically. Thus, the continued pursuit of a single immutable truth about boards; a one-size-fits-all theory of board-management interaction; an optimal board structure; or, a universal market-based or policy-based corporate governance system may be futile. Though the practitioner community has at various times embraced all such arguments, the socially dynamic nature of boards and the open system within which they operate must be accounted for if credible explanatory theories are to emerge. This conceptual paper comments on the various concepts/constructs of corporate governance that have been proposed in the literature. Informed by boardroom observations, it seeks to advance the preliminary work of Crow, Lockhart and Lewis (2014), by providing an alternative conceptualisation that seems better suited to corporate governance and how boards actually work.
ACCESSION #
111356820

 

Related Articles

  • The Structure of Board of Directors of Russian Companies in the Context of Corporate Governance. Plotnikov, Andrey Viktorovich; Zagorujko, Igor' Jur'evich; Cherdancev, Vadim Petrovich // World Applied Sciences Journal;2013, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p473 

    This article discusses distinctive characteristics of corporate governance in XXI century Russian companies and defines optimality conditions. We analyse the advantages and disadvantages of the inclusion of managing director in the board of directors, perform a comparative study of theoretical...

  • Be strategic about board composition. Crawford, Curtis J. // Directors & Boards;2008 1st Quarter, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p33 

    The article discusses the importance of board composition in corporate governance. The Board of directors should be composed of individuals with varying educational and leadership backgrounds, experiences and perspectives, as well as high competence. Further, a good board composition is...

  • BOARDS OF DIRECTORS AND FIRM PERFORMANCE: INTEGRATING AGENCY AND RESOURCE DEPENDENCE PERSPECTIVES. Hillman, Amy J.; Dalziel, Thomas // Academy of Management Review;Jul2003, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p383 

    Boards of directors serve two important functions for organizations: monitoring management on behalf of shareholders and providing resources. Agency theorists assert that effective monitoring is a function of a board's incentives, whereas resource dependence theorists contend that the provision...

  • YENÄ° TÃœRK TÄ°CARET KANUNUNA GÖRE ANONÄ°M ŞİRKET YÖNETÄ°M KURULUNUN YÖNETÄ°M VE TEMSÄ°L YETKÄ°SÄ°NÄ°N KAPSAMI VE DEVRÄ°. ALTAŞ, Soner // Mali Cozum Dergisi / Financial Analysis;2011, Issue 105, p91 

    No abstract available.

  • What is DLMA analysis? Tunjic, Peter // Governance Newsletter;Oct2015, Issue 256, p8 

    The article discusses DLMA analysis as a new way of analysing how well a company manages what are deemed potentially contradictory elements of assurance and management with directorship and leadership. It points out that DLMA analysis, which uses a quadrant-based matrix to categorize board and...

  • Directors: A Harsh New Reality. Charan, Ram; Colvin, Geoff // Fortune;10/18/2010, Vol. 162 Issue 6, p97 

    The article discusses the change that has occurred in relation to the part that board of directors (board) play in public companies. Topics discussed in the article include the impact that the financial crises had on the leadership role taken on by a company's board, rules that have been adopted...

  • Directors: A Harsh New Reality. Charan, Ram; Colvin, Geoff // Fortune International (Europe);10/18/2010, Vol. 162 Issue 6, p49 

    The article discusses the change that has occurred in relation to the part that board of directors (board) play in public companies. Topics discussed in the article include the impact that the financial crises had on the leadership role taken on by a company's board, rules that have been adopted...

  • Board Considers Governance Structure.  // Collector (0010082X);Nov2011, Vol. 77 Issue 4, p28 

    The article reports on the proposal of the ACA International Inc. Board of Directors for changes to the association's governance structure. It is expected that the proposed changes will decrease the size of the Board, establish a Council of Delegates, and eradicate the Executive Committee. Its...

  • Managerial dominance and audit committee independence in Spanish corporate governance. Ruiz-Barbadillo, Emiliano; Biedma-López, Estíbaliz; Gómez-Aguilar, Nieves // Journal of Management & Governance;Dec2007, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p311 

    The purpose of this paper is to analyse whether the independence of audit committees is affected by the degree of control exerted by managers over the board of directors. Results from a sample of 75 listed Spanish companies show that the majority of firms that voluntarily adopted an audit...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics