The Effectiveness of Neurofeedback and Stimulant Drugs in Treating AD/HD: Part I. Review of Methodological Issues

Rossiter, Thomas
June 2004
Applied Psychophysiology & Biofeedback;Jun2004, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p95
Academic Journal
The paper examines major criticisms of AD/HD (Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder) neurofeedback research using T. R. Rossiter and T. J. La Vaque (1995) as an exemplar and discusses relevant aspects of research methodology. J. Lohr, S. Meunier, L. Parker, and J. P. Kline (2001), D. A. Waschbusch and G. P. Hill (2001), and J. P. Kline, C. N. Brann, and B. R. Loney (2002) criticized Rossiter and La Vaque for (1) using an active treatment control; (2) nonrandom assignment of patients; (3) provision of collateral treatments; (4) using nonstandardized and invalid assessment instruments; (5) providing artifact contaminated EEG feedback; and (6) conducting multiple non-alpha protected t tests. The criticisms, except those related to statistical analysis, are invalid or are not supported as presented by the authors. They are based on the critics' unsubstantiated opinions; require redefining Rossiter and La Vaque as an efficacy rather than an effectiveness study; or reflect a lack of familiarity with the research literature. However, there are broader issues to be considered. Specifically, what research methodology is appropriate for studies evaluating the effectiveness of neurofeedback and who should make that determination? The uncritical acceptance and implementation of models developed for psychotherapy, pharmacology, or medical research is premature and ill-advised. Neurofeedback researchers should develop models that are appropriate to the technology, treatment paradigms, and goals of neurofeedback outcome studies. They need to explain the rationale for their research methodology and defend their choices.


Related Articles

  • Zinc sulfate as an adjunct to methylphenidate for the treatment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in children: A double blind and randomized trial [ISRCTN64132371]. Akhondzadeh, Shahin; Mohammadi, Mohammad-Reza; Khademi, Mojgan // BMC Psychiatry;2004, Vol. 4, p9 

    Background: Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder is an early-onset, clinically heterogenous disorder of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsiveness. The diagnosis and treatment of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder continues to raise controversy, and, there is also an increase in...

  • Engaging Families into Child Mental Health Treatment: Updates and Special Considerations. Gopalan, Geetha; Goldstein, Leah; Klingenstein, Kathryn; Sicher, Carolyn; Blake, Clair; McKay, Mary M. // Journal of the Canadian Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p182 

    Objective: The current paper reviews recent findings regarding how to conceptualize engagement and factors influencing engagement, treatment attendance rates, and interventions that work. Method: Research related to the definition of engagement, predictors of engagement and treatment...

  • Role of zinc in maternal and child mental health.  // American Journal of Clinical Nutrition;Mar2009, Vol. 89 Issue 3, p940S 

    The article presents a study which reviews the evidence on the association between zinc and mental health disorders. The role of zinc in the development of depression and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) among women and children is outlined. The benefits of combined treatment for...

  • Finding Guidance Amid Uncertainty of ADHD Diagnosis. Shakil, Amer // American Family Physician;5/1/2001, Vol. 63 Issue 9, p1694 

    Editorial. Focuses on issues related to the management of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) among children. Establishment of criteria for ADHD; Recommendations for the management of ADHD; Importance of screening the school performance of children.

  • The New Pharmacopoeia. Schlozman, Steven // Newsweek (Pacific Edition);5/16/2005 (Pacific Edition), Vol. 145 Issue 20, p39 

    This article explores the dangers of some psychoactive drugs commonly prescribed to children. Psychiatric drugs seem to offer a modern devil's bargain: your child's happiness, comfort and success in exchange for potentially dangerous side effects and an unpredictable future for his or her...

  • Evaluating the effectiveness of interventions in child psychiatry. Fonagy, Peter; Fonagy, P // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Aug1997 Supplement, Vol. 42 Issue 6, p584 

    Objective: To review the nature of outcome measures used to evaluate psychosocial treatment in children.Method: Recent research findings that highlight the importance of outcome data and justify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are reviewed.Results:...

  • Wraparound. Eber, Lucille; Breen, Kimberli; Rose, Jennifer; Unizycki, Renee M.; London, Tasha H. // Teaching Exceptional Children;Jul/Aug2008, Vol. 40 Issue 6, p16 

    The article discusses the wraparound process as an intervention for students with emotional and behavioral needs. The wraparound process is defined as a comprehensive intervention specifically designed for students with the absolute highest level of emotional and behavioral need. It is the most...

  • Eyelash Pulling: A Rare Symptom of Anxiety. Stephenson, P. S. // Clinical Pediatrics;Feb1974, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p147 

    Eyelash pulling, a rare symptom, is described in a multiply placed foster child whose anxieties about death and separation were aroused by two specific events.

  • Therapeutic Management of a Pubescent Boy's Prolonged Episode of Hostile Acting Out. Doten, David R.; Rosenthal, Maurice J. // Child Welfare;Jun1967, Vol. 46 Issue 6, p326 

    A placed child reacts to his mother's rejection with behavior likely to cause further rejection by hit peers, caretakers, and therapist. The psychodynamics of the acting out and of the therapist's activity are examined, with an analysis of factors that contributed to the successful resolution of...

  • The Effectiveness of Social Stories on Decreasing Disruptive Behaviors of Children with Autism: Three Case Studies. Ozdemir, Selda // Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders;Oct2008, Vol. 38 Issue 9, p1689 

    The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of social stories on decreasing the disruptive behaviors of children with autism. Social stories were created for three participants, ages 7 and 9, to decrease three target disruptive behaviors, using a loud voice in class, chair...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics