Between Individual Decisions and Collegiate Deliberations: Deciding How To Decide, Influencing the Outcome

Gomes Neto, José Mário Wanderley; Lima, Flávia Danielle Santiago; de Oliveira, Tassiana Moura
April 2019
Revista Seqüência;abr2019, Vol. 40 Issue 81, p10
Academic Journal
How does the institutional design of the Brazilian Supreme Court (STF) interfere in the decision-making process of the conflicts that are submitted to it? STF's Justices, as individually responsible of each proceeding in progress, can strategically decide through available procedural resources what and when to bring them to trial individually or collectively. This article inserts itself in this debate to question the independence of its Justices before the other political actors, but also before (or against) their peers, considering the possibilities of interaction of strategic models to the Brazilian case, before the constitutional, legal and regimental rules that establish the performance of the members of the Court. The general hypothesis is that the normative design of the Court assures multiple options for magistrates in the conduct of judicial proceedings, promoting strategies aimed at maximizing the winning chances of their preferences, as well as reducing their respective decision costs.


Related Articles

  • U.S. Middle District needs a magistrate.  // Florida Bar News;12/15/2015, Vol. 42 Issue 24, p3 

    The article announces the opening of applications as of December 2015 for a full-time magistrate at the Middle District of Florida who will remain in the Tampa division for eight years.

  • U.S. Magistrate Judges: By the Numbers.  // Federal Lawyer;May/Jun2014, Vol. 61 Issue 4, p34 

    Several graphs are presented related to the U.S. magistrate judges including their total number, civil consent cases terminated by them, and matters disposed of by magistrate judges.

  • Fourth District Magistrate Judge appointed.  // Advocate (05154987);Aug2012, Vol. 55 Issue 8, p20 

    The article announces the appointment of Lynnette L. McHenry as Ada County magistrate judge by the Magistrate Commission for the Fourth Judicial District in Idaho.

  • Third District Magistrate Judge appointed.  // Advocate (05154987);Aug2012, Vol. 55 Issue 8, p20 

    The article announces the appointment of Jayme Beaber Sullivan as Canyon County magistrate judge in Idaho.

  • Here Come the Judge. GRIMM, JULIE ANN // Santa Fe Reporter;1/22/2014, Vol. 41 Issue 4, p11 

    No abstract available.

  • FORM GOV-1-A CERTIFICATE.  // State Court Forms (North Carolina);Jul2012, p1 

    A form showing a certificate from the Administrative Office of the Courts in North Carolina is presented. The required information includes county, date of issuing the warrant, and whether a proper official or magistrate.

  • THE OFFICE OF CHIEF JUSTICE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA UNDER LEN KING. Emerson, John // Adelaide Law Review;2011, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p177 

    The article presents information on the Chief Justice of South Australia L. J. King. It discusses King's view on the role of a Lieutenant Governor with respect to the acceptance of the office of Lieutenant Governor by Chief Justices. It further discusses King's practice in Whyalla and Adelaide...

  • The Benefits to New Lawyers of Practicing Before Magistrate Judges. Moschella, Matthew C. // Federal Lawyer;May/Jun2014, Vol. 61 Issue 4, p89 

    The article presents the benefits new lawyers practicing in Magistrate Courts of May-June 2014. The topic discussed include handling of discovery aspects of a case by lawyers, benefits of handling of pretrial issues by Magistrate Judges, and the advantage of having experience in appellate...

  • Legal Advice.  // Commercial Motor;6/21/2012, Vol. 217 Issue 5489, p28 

    The article offers information on the need for legal advice in the transport industry when dealing with infringements. It says that truck operators who appear in magistrate of crown court are at high risk, because magistrates, judges and the jury may have a little understanding on the industry....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics