TITLE

The Overdetermination Argument Revisited

AUTHOR(S)
Vicente, Agustín
PUB. DATE
August 2004
SOURCE
Minds & Machines;Aug2004, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p331
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
In this paper I discuss a famous argument for physic alism - which some authors indeed regard as the only argument for it - the "overdetermination argument". In fact it is an argument that does not establish that all the entities in the world are physical, but that all those events that enter into causal transactions with the physical world are physical. As mental events seem to cause changes in the physical world, the mind is one of those things that fall within the scope of the argument. Here I analyze one response to the overdetermination argument that has acquired some popularity lately, and which consists in saying that what mental events cause are not physical effects. I try to show that recent attempts to develop this response are not successful, but that there may be a coherent way of doing so. I also try to show that there seems to be a philosophical "niche" in which this way might fit.
ACCESSION #
15104075

 

Related Articles

  • Mental Causation and Shoemaker-Realization. Brian McLaughlin // Erkenntnis;Sep2007, Vol. 67 Issue 2, p149 

    Abstract  Sydney Shoemaker has proposed a new definition of `realization’ and used it to try to explain how mental events can be causes within the framework of a non-reductive physicalism. I argue that it is not actually his notion of realization that is doing the...

  • A Nonreductivist Solution to Mental Causation. Thomasson, Amie // Philosophical Studies;Mar1998, Vol. 89 Issue 2/3, p181 

    Nonreductive physicalism provides an appealing solution to the nature of mental properties. But its success as a theory of mental properties has been called into doubt by claims that it cannot adequately handle the problems of mental causation, as it leads either to epiphenomenalism or to...

  • PHYSICALISM AND THE FALLACY OF COMPOSITION. Elder, Crawford L. // Philosophical Quarterly;Jul2000, Vol. 50 Issue 202, p332 

    Focuses on the concept of modest physicalism. Factors affecting the stability of modest physicalism; Account on the fallacy of composition; Assumptions about causation; Rationale for collecting microparticles realizing the event identified as cause; Importance of physicalism in understanding...

  • FILLING THE GAP, OR JUMPING OVER IT? EMERGENTISM AND NATURALISM. Di Francesco, Michele // Epistemologia;2005, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p93 

    This article contemplates on the existence of a version of emergentism that is compatible with naturalism and moderate physicalism. Naturalism is the view that everything is natural, that everything there is belongs to the world of nature, and so can be studied by the methods appropriated for...

  • logical empiricism Philosophy.  // Dictionary of Theories;2002, p319 

    A definition of the term "logical empiricism" is presented. It refers to the version of empiricism that applies to the meanings of words or sentences, whereby they have meaning only if there are rules involving sense-experience for applying or verifying them.

  • Physicalism, teleology and the miraculous coincidence problem. Knowles, Jonathan // Philosophical Quarterly;Apr99, Vol. 49 Issue 195, p164 

    Analyzes the relationship between basic and non-basic sciences from the perspective of anti-reductionist physicalism. Teleological solution to the relationship problem; Implausibility of supervening event to be realized in physical events; `Miraculous coincidence problem' in the relationship;...

  • LUCIAN BLAGA: APPROACHING SCIENCE FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE "UNITY OF CULTURE FORMS". PETRESCU, ALEXANDRU // Agathos: An International Review of the Humanities & Social Scie;2015, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p7 

    This study aims to investigate the approach of cognitive dimensions of science in the ontological, cultural and historical context as Lucian Blaga (1895-1961) has developed it through an interdisciplinary integration of philosophy of science and gnoseology within the philosophy of culture. Some...

  • Can determinable properties earn their keep? Schroer, Robert // Synthese;Nov2011, Vol. 183 Issue 2, p229 

    Sydney Shoemaker's 'Subset Account' offers a new take on determinable properties and the realization relation as well as a defense of non-reductive physicalism from the problem of mental causation. At the heart of this account are the claims that (1) mental properties are determinable properties...

  • Counterfactuals, Autonomy and Downward Causation: Reply to Zhong. Moore, Dwayne // Philosophia;Sep2013, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p831 

    In recent papers, Lei Zhong argues that the autonomy solution to the causal exclusion problem is unavailable to anyone that endorses the counterfactual model of causation. The linchpin of his argument is that the counterfactual theory entails the downward causation principle, which conflicts...

Share

Other Topics