Martial Illusions: War and Disillusionment in Twentieth-Century and Renaissance Military Memoirs

Harari, Yuval Noah
January 2005
Journal of Military History;Jan2005, Vol. 69 Issue 1, p43
Academic Journal
The twentieth century has witnessed a revolution in the image of war and of soldiers. The age-old romantic image of war has been discredited; war has increasingly been interpreted as a disillusioning experience; and the soldier has been at least partly transformed from hero to victim. This article examines the roots of this revolution, by comparing twentieth-century and Renaissance military memoirs. It argues that this revolution did not result from twentieth-century military or technological changes in the nature of war, but rather from cultural and mental changes in soldiers' self-perception and in their expectations of life, that occurred between 1600 and 1900.


Related Articles

  • The scar that binds. Maher, Michael // Bulletin with Newsweek;04/25/2000, Vol. 118 Issue 6221, p38 

    Examines the impact of the fall of Saigon, Vietnam and the end of the Vietnam War on governments. History of the war; Unites States' withdrawal from Southeast Asia; Ethnic, religious and nationalist tensions in the Balkans and parts of the former Soviet Union.

  • Books Received.  // Journal of Military History;Oct2011, Vol. 75 Issue 4, p1362 

    A bibliography related to military history is presented including the books "Confronting Al Qaeda: New Strategies to Combat Terrorism," by Kevin McGrath, "Democracy's Arsenal: Creating a Twenty-First-Century Defense Industry," by Jacques S. Gansler and "The Politics of Space Security: Strategic...

  • Dogging the Wags. Grossberge, Lewis // MediaWeek;04/12/99, Vol. 9 Issue 15, p46 

    Ponders on the consequences and implication of wars on business and on mankind. Views of the author about war; Importance of learning the region's history and its military history in defending one's position.

  • Iraq: Staying Mission-Ready.  // Soldiers;Feb2004, Vol. 59 Issue 2, p14 

    Discusses the important missions of commanders supporting Operation Iraqi Freedom. Maintenance of a high-level of readiness; Role of the First Armored Division in maintaining the Army's skill and meeting the Army's weapons-qualification standards.

  • La revolución militar posindustrial. Colom Piella, Guillem // Revista de Estudios Sociales;sep-dic2014, Issue 50, p113 

    The article analyses the social, political, demographic, economic and technological changes that advanced societies have experienced and that have entailed the replacement of the modern military paradigm by a new post-industrial military model which reflects the current society. These changes...

  • New York Port of Embarkation: Regulations for Transporting Baggage Overseas, 1943. Sammis, Marc W. // Military Collector & Historian;Winter2015, Vol. 67 Issue 4, p313 

    The article discusses the New York Port of Embarkation's regulations for the overseas transport of the baggage of officers and enlisted soldiers in 1943. Topics cited include sorting and marking of the baggage prior to arrival at the port of embarkation, restrictions imposed by the War...

  • Needless Fear: The Compromise of U.S. Plans to Invade Japan in 1945. Coox, Alvin D. // Journal of Military History;Apr2000, Vol. 64 Issue 2, p411 

    Offers a look at the plan of American troops to invade Japan in 1945. Description of the Japanese homeland defense; Details on the United States (US) intelligence amendment of July 29, 1945; US intelligence estimates of the Japanese strength on Kyushu.

  • A Christmas Message to Our Troops in Harm's Way. De Wind, Dorian // Moderate Voice;12/19/2009, p1 

    The article features a message for U.S. soldiers who wish to celebrate Christmas with their family but choose to protect their country by involving war in Iraq and Afghanistan. It states that soldiers who choose to protect their country are heroes of the new generation. The author emphasizes...

  • A new editor. Moore, Mike // Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists;May/Jun2000, Vol. 56 Issue 3, p2 

    Explores the issues on civilian deaths due to wars. Results of the post-bombing investigation conducted on precision-guided munitions used against Yugoslavia in 1999; Comparison between post-modern and World War II wars; Moral implications of the deaths of civilians resulting from wars.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics