The use of verbal protocols as data: An analysis of insight in the candle problem

Fleck, Jessica I.; Weisberg, Robert W.
September 2004
Memory & Cognition;Sep2004, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p990
Academic Journal
In the present study, we examined the use of verbal protocols as data in the study of the cognitive processes underlying insight Fifty-eight Temple University undergraduates attempted to solve Duncker's (1945) candle problem either silently or while thinking aloud. Solution rates, solving times, and solution types were comparable between conditions, suggesting that verbal overshadowing (Schooler, Ohlsson, & Brooks, 1993) did not occur when the participants attempted to solve the candle problem. Subsequent analysis of verbal protocols provided a catalogue of solutions generated by the participants, as well as empirical support for the occurrence of impasse and restructuring. Although restructuring was present in the majority of protocols, including those of the participants who later produced the box solution, the presence of impasse occurred with less frequency and was not associated with production of the box solution. These results provide information concerning how the candle problem is solved and suggest that verbalization can be used to examine how individuals solve insight problems and to evaluate existing theories of insight.


Related Articles

  • The time course of attentional deployment in contextual cueing. Jiang, Yuhong; Sigstad, Heather; Swallow, Khena // Psychonomic Bulletin & Review;Apr2013, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p282 

    The time course of attention is a major characteristic on which different types of attention diverge. In addition to explicit goals and salient stimuli, spatial attention is influenced by past experience. In contextual cueing, behaviorally relevant stimuli are more quickly found when they appear...

  • The distortion of spatial relationships between local elements in hierarchical patterns decreases the global advantage effect. Luna, Dolores; Montoro, Pedro R. // Psychological Research;Mar2008, Vol. 72 Issue 2, p168 

    The present study examined the influence of perceptual organization on the processing of global and local information in hierarchical patterns. In two experiments, we examined whether disturbing the spatial relationships between local elements by introducing between-element distance and size...

  • Temporal Cognition in Children with Autistic Spectrum Disorders: Tests of Diachronic Thinking. Boucher, Jill; Pons, Francisco; Lind, Sophie; Williams, David // Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders;Sep2007, Vol. 37 Issue 8, p1413 

    Impaired diachronic thinking—(the propensity and capacity to think about events spreading across time)—was demonstrated in a 2-Phase study in which children with autism were compared with age and ability matched controls. Identical tests of diachronic thinking were administered in...

  • CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT—WHERE WE WANT TO BE. Bennett, Kevin // Food Manufacture;Jun2006, Vol. 81 Issue 6, p81 

    The article offers insights on how improvement program succeed its aims. According to the author, one of the key initial activities for the program to succeed is to draw a clear vision of what an individual want to achieve. In return, the vision becomes the focus for all future actions,...

  • La transformación de la mente. Vicente, Agustín; Lafarga, Asier // Teorema;2013, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p173 

    This paper is a critical account of Antoni Gomila's book Verbal Minds (2012). Verbal Minds offers a complete exploration of contemporary theories about the cognitive role of language and the empirical evidence that refutes or supports them. The book has a descriptive and an evaluative element....

  • Predictability as an Index of Impaired Verbal Communication in Schizophrenic and Affective Disorders. Barnett Ragin, Ann; Oltmanns, Thomas F. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Dec83, Vol. 143, p578 

    The doze procedure was used to examine predictability in speech samples from schizophrenic, depressive, manic, schizoaffective and normal subjects. Each speech sample was also rated for particular indices of thought disorder using the Andreasen Scale for the Assessment of Thought, Language and...

  • USING DEVELOPMENTAL PPJNCIPLES TO ASSIST PRESCHOOLERS IN DEVELOPING NUMERACY AND LITERACY. Pasnak, Robert; Maccubbin, Elise; Ferral-Like, Melissa // Perceptual & Motor Skills;Aug2007, Vol. 105 Issue 1, p163 

    In a yoked control design, 4-yr.-olds (N=39) in a Head Start program played numerous structured games involving either the oddity principle or letter identification and letter sounds. The children's mean age was 53.2 mo.; SD=4.1 mo. Three were Middle Eastern, 14 were Latino, 7 were East African,...

  • What Makes an Insight Problem? The Roles of Heuristics, Goal Conception, and Solution Recoding in Knowledge-Lean Problems. Chronicle, Edward P.; MacGregor, James N.; Omerod, Thomas C. // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory & Cognition;Jan2004, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p14 

    Investigates transformation problems with insight characteristics. Description of each performances which include a 6-coin problem followed by a hill-climbing heuristic; Argument that the hill-climbing heuristics provide a common framework for understanding transformation and insight problem...

  • Age-differential effects on updating cue information: Evidence from event-related potentials. Schmitt, Hannah; Ferdinand, Nicola; Kray, Jutta // Cognitive, Affective & Behavioral Neuroscience;Sep2014, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p1115 

    Recent models on cognitive aging consider the ability to maintain and update context information to be a key source of age-related impairments in various cognitive tasks (Braver & Barch in Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 26: 809-817, ). Context updating has been investigated with a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics