Two Stages of Transition from a Region of War to a Region of Peace: Realist Transition and Liberal Endurance

Ripsman, Norrin M.
December 2005
International Studies Quarterly;Dec2005, Vol. 49 Issue 4, p669
Academic Journal
How do war-prone regions stabilize? This article tests realist, liberal, and constructivist hypotheses against the paradigmatic case of regional peacemaking, Western Europe after World War II. It concludes that none of the three theories perfectly explains the process of Franco-German reconciliation after 75 years of bitter conflict. Instead, the transition to stability occurred in two stages. The first stage, the transition, was driven by realist factors, principally the existence of a common Soviet threat and active American hegemonic participation. In the second stage, however, stability and cooperation were entrenched by liberal mechanisms, notably the institution of democratic political regimes and cooperative international institutions. I thus inductively arrive at the novel theoretical position that realist mechanisms may initially be required to compel regional rivals to put aside their differences, at least temporarily, and cooperate on the grounds of realpolitik, but liberal mechanisms are ultimately useful to sustain and deepen regional peace.


Related Articles

  • Reconciliation of Nations for the Survival of Humankind. Moltmann, Jürgen // Korea Observer;Summer2019, Vol. 50 Issue 2, p261 

    The paper explores the history and the reality of reconciliation of nations, which is inevitable and vital for the survival of human kind. It first emphasizes the very need for the peace and reconciliation through three examples of national reconciliation both internal and external:...

  • Red "Peace Offensive" is a Military Weapon. Strausz-Hupé, Robert // Saturday Evening Post;7/31/1948, Vol. 221 Issue 5, p96 

    The article comments on the peace offensive launched by Russians after World War II. It argues that the military operation had a relaxing effect on U.S. opinion. It claims that the offensive proves nothing as to the international state of affairs. It emphasizes that the Soviet strategy has taken...

  • Reconciliation and Transformation: Lessons from South Africa? Sitas, Ari // Cyprus Review;Spring2007, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p171 

    In this article, the author discusses his paper "Beyond Racism: The Ethics of Reconciliation and the Reality of Reconciling. The author tried to reflect on what lessons could be gleaned from the South African processes of transformation that might assist in the post-Annan Plan period. He argued...

  • U.S.-MOZAMBICAN RELATIONS.  // Background Notes on Countries of the World: Republic of Mozambiq;Dec2007, p7 

    The article presents information on the U.S.-Mozambican relations. The relations between the two countries are good and steadily improving. U.S. aid to Mozambique became prominent in 1993 due in part to significant emergency food assistance in the wake of the 1991-1993 southern African drought...

  • Roadmap for Afghan Peace.  // Defence Journal;2011, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p83 

    The article focuses on roadmap for peace in Afghanistan. The concept for reconciliation in Afghanistan proposed by Pakistan was accepted by the U.S. with some caveats. The roadmap how to operationalise the agreed plan envisaged the final decision about the reconciliation would remain with the...

  • "We Refuse to Be Enemies". King, Sarah Withrow // PRISM Magazine;May/Jun2012, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p45 

    The article focuses on the peacemaking process in Israel and Palestine. It is noted that peace needs to grow like the olive tree and cannot come from up to down. It is stated that peacemakers in Israel and Palestine only request visitors to remember the land and its people in prayers, despite...

  • BOOK REVIEWS Power Transition Extended. Packer, Robert // International Studies Review;Summer2003, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p278 

    Reviews the book "Regions of War and Peace," by Douglas Lemke.

  • The allies plan the postwar world. Harsch, Joseph C. // Christian Science Monitor;2/13/95, Vol. 87 Issue 54, p9 

    Part II. Analyzes the post World War II scenario and the background of the Yalta conference. Details about the American position at Yalta; Stand of Russia and Stalin; Attempts of United States President Franklin Delano Roosevelt to bring Russia into the Pacific war; Assessment of Roosevelt's...

  • Accepting the Unacceptable: Lessons from West Germany's Changing Border Politics. ATZILI, BOAZ; KANTEL, ANNE // International Studies Review;Dec2015, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p588 

    During the past two decades, scholars have critically examined the political role of space and territory and advanced our understanding of borders with dynamic concepts based on identities and narratives. The literature, though, is divided between works that emphasize domestic politics and those...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics