Catching Up With the Vaughn Express: Six Years of Standards-Based Teacher Evaluation and Performance Pay

Kellor, Eileen M.
January 2005
Education Policy Analysis Archives;Jan2005, Vol. 13, p1
Academic Journal
Traditional methods of paying and evaluating teachers in the United States are longstanding, but discussions about changing these systems to support teacher quality and student achievement goals are becoming more common. Efforts to make significant changes to these programs can be difficult and take many years to design, gain approval, and implement; thus, few examples of alternative teacher compensation and evaluation systems exist. Relieved from many of the restrictions and requirements associated with most traditional public school systems, charter schools often are better positioned to implement changes more quickly than a traditional school, yet their experiences can provide useful information for others who are engaging in similar activities. Thus, the experience of a large urban charter school that designed and implemented an innovative teacher compensation system and standards-based teacher evaluation system that has been in place for six years offers important lessons in designing, implementing, evaluating and refining these systems.


Related Articles

  • SUMMATIVE EVALUATION OR FORMATIVE DEVELOPMENT? NIELS, GARY J. // Independent School;Fall2012, Vol. 72 Issue 1, p58 

    The author, head of Winchester Thurston School in Pennsylvania, discusses student achievement based on teacher quality, and describes programs for teacher development and evaluation at independent schools in the U.S. Standardized testing, pedagogy, and curriculum planning are discussed, as well...

  • PERFORMANCE PAY PATH TO IMPROVEMENT. Gratz, Donald B. // Kappa Delta Pi Record;Summer2011, Vol. 47 Issue 4, p156 

    The article focuses on the significance of performance pay as a path for the improvement of teachers in the U.S. It notes that the existing incentives for teachers whose students gain high test scores are attributed to the assumptions about the teachers' motivation. It points out that the...

  • Big-City District Scrap Reward-Based System Of Evaluating Teachers. Blair, Julie; Keller, Bess; Manzo, Kathleen Kennedy // Education Week;10/22/2003, Vol. 23 Issue 8, p15 

    It's an effective idea to reward teachers for their classroom performance, but in practice the idea can turn very, very ineffective. School officials in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and Baltimore, Maryland suggested different systems for evaluating teachers' work with students because, in both...

  • Rhetoric to Reality: Our Districts Focus on Individual Merit. Mohundro, Randy // School Administrator;Mar2010, Vol. 67 Issue 3, p18 

    The article discusses a performance pay system instituted in DeLeon, Texas over several years beginning in 2005. After experimenting with various plans, the district adopted a plan which rewards teachers for the improved performance of every student individually. Categories of success are...

  • The Question of Performance Pay. Guthrie, James W.; Schuermann, Patrick J. // Education Week;10/29/2008, Vol. 28 Issue 10, p24 

    The article discusses performance and merit pay for teachers and educators in the U.S. The article mentions the expansion of funding for merit pay by federal, state, and local initiatives, as well as by foundations. The article mentions performance measurement, incentive-program design,...

  • Fla. Teachers' Union To Offer Alternate Merit- Pay Plan to Council. Walton, Susan // Education Week;10/26/1983, Vol. 3 Issue 8, p8 

    The article reports that Florida Education Association/United (FEAU) has developed a plan to offer alternate merit-pay system. The FEAU's plan includes elements of other incentive plans for teachers' pay and is intended to improve conditions for both teachers and students. According to Richard...

  • A GROWING NUMBER OF SCHOOL SYSTEMS.  // Quality Progress;May2006, Vol. 39 Issue 5, p21 

    The article reports on the results of a Gannett News Service study which showed that an increasing number of school systems are financially rewarding teachers based on their students' test scores. According to the article, school systems in Minnesota, Florida, Texas and Colorado have established...

  • MEASURING GOOD TEACHING. RIX, KATE // Scholastic Administrator;Spring2013, Vol. 12 Issue 5, p42 

    The article discusses the methods adopted to evaluate the teaching skills of teachers in the U.S. It informs that members of teachers union of the Newark, New Jersey, approved a contract which includes a system that will assess the 5,000 teachers every year based on four measures, including...

  • Closing the Teacher quality Gap. Haycock, Kati; Crawford, Candace // Educational Leadership;Apr2008, Vol. 65 Issue 7, p14 

    The article discusses how teacher effectiveness can affect student achievement. The authors note research suggesting that students taught by proficient teachers show greater progress than students with ineffective teachers. They suggest that accurate methods to evaluate teaching quality are not...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics