Wildland Fire Management: A Cohesive Strategy and Clear Cost-Containment Goals Are Needed for Federal Agencies to Manage Wildland Fire Activities Effectively: GAO-07-1017T

Nazzaro, Robin M.
June 2007
GAO Reports;6/19/2007, p1
Government Document
Increasing wildland fire threats to communities and ecosystems, combined with rising costs of addressing those threats--trends that GAO and others have reported on for many years--have not abated. On average, the acreage burned annually by wildland fires from 2000 to 2005 was 70 percent greater than the acreage burned annually during the 1990s. Annual appropriations to prepare for and respond to wildland fires have also increased substantially over the past decade, totaling about $3 billion in recent years. The Forest Service within the Department of Agriculture and four agencies within the Department of the Interior (Interior) are responsible for responding to wildland fires on federal lands. This testimony summarizes several key actions that federal agencies need to complete or take to strengthen their management of the wildland fire program, including the need to (1) develop a long-term, cohesive strategy to reduce fuels and address wildland fire problems and (2) improve the management of their efforts to contain the costs of preparing for and responding to wildland fires. The testimony is based on several previous GAO reports and testimonies addressing wildland fire issues. The Forest Service and Interior agencies need to complete several actions to strengthen their overall management of the wildland fire program. First, because a substantial investment and decades of work will be required to address wildland fire problems that have been decades in the making, the agencies need a cohesive strategy that addresses the full range of wildland fire management activities. Such a strategy should identify the available long-term options and associated funding for reducing excess vegetation and responding to wildland fires if the agencies and the Congress are to make informed decisions about an effective and affordable long-term approach for addressing wildland fire problems. GAO first recommended in 1999 that such a strategy be developed to address the problem of excess fuels and their potential to increase the severity of wildland fires and cost of suppression efforts. By 2005, the agencies had yet to develop such a strategy, and GAO reiterated the need for a cohesive strategy and broadened the recommendation's focus to better address the interrelated nature of fuel reduction efforts and wildland fire response. Further, because the agencies said they would be unable to develop a cohesive strategy until they have completed certain key tasks, GAO recommended that the agencies develop a tactical plan outlining these tasks and the time frames needed for completing each task and a cohesive strategy. Although the agencies concurred with GAO's recommendations, as of April 2007, they had yet to develop a tactical plan. Second, as GAO testified before the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources in January 2007, the steps the Forest Service and Interior agencies have taken to date to contain wildland fire costs lack several key...


Related Articles

  • The Event Book System: A Community-based Natural Resource Monitoring System from Namibia. Greg Stuart-Hill; Richard Diggle; Bevan Munali; Jo Tagg; David Ward // Biodiversity & Conservation;Oct2005, Vol. 14 Issue 11, p2611 

    Namibia's Community Based Natural Resource Management program is a joint venture between government, national non-governmental organisations and rural communities. A component of the program involves communities in monitoring various aspects of their conservancy, ranging from wildlife numbers,...

  • Why not use niche modelling for computing risk of wildfires ignition and spreading? Ferrarini, Alessandro // Environmental Skeptics & Critics;12/1/2012, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p56 

    A forest fire can be a true ecological calamity, regardless of whether it is caused by natural forces or human actions. Although it is impossible to control nature, it is possible to map wildfire risk zones, and thence minimize the frequency of wildfires and prevent damages. Wildfire risk zones...

  • GAO releases new report on wildfire management.  // Fire Engineering;Apr2005, Vol. 158 Issue 4, p76 

    This article focuses on a new report on wildfire management. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) has recommended that the Secretaries of Agriculture and Interior provide Congress with a cohesive strategy for developing wildland fire policies. The report was produced for the Subcommittee...

  • EFICIÊNCIA DE UM RETARDANTE DE FOGO DE LONGA DURAÇÃO UTILIZADO EM INCÊNDIOS FLORESTAIS. Filho, Cláudio Machado; Martins, Maria Cristina; Ribeiro, Guido Assunção; Lima, Gumercindo Souza; Cardoso, Marco Túlio; Torres, Carlos Moreira Miquelino Eleto; Pinto, Flavia Barreto // Ciência Florestal (01039954);2012, Vol. 22 Issue 2, p365 

    The objective of this work was lo evaluate the efficiency of fire retardant in relation to the applied volume and the application period. The experiment has been realized on the Forest Fire and Nature Conservation Laboratory of the Federal University of Vicosa (UFV), in Minas Gerais, Brazil....

  • Fire danger assessment with remote sensing: a case study in Northern China. Wang, Litao; Zhou, Yi; Zhou, Weiqi; Wang, Shixing // Natural Hazards;Jan2013, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p819 

    Every year several million hectares of forest and grassland in China are affected by wildfires. The majority of wildfires occur in the northern part of China, where grasslands and forests are ubiquitous. A critical step toward the protection of life, property, and natural resources from...

  • The Rhetoric of Opposition Anticonservation and the Early Forest Reserves. Graves, G. R. // Journal of the West;Fall2005, Vol. 44 Issue 4, p11 

    The article discusses the origins of anti-conservation ideology in the West U.S. The earliest anti-conservation activity in the West centered on the establishment of the federal forest reserves. Tree-cutting, wildfires and destructive mining practices proliferated in the 1800s. The anti-forest...

  • Creating Defensible Space in the Wildland–Urban Interface: The Influence of Values on Perceptions and Behavior. Bright, Alan D.; Burtz, Randall T. // Environmental Management;Feb2006, Vol. 37 Issue 2, p170 

    We examined the effect that value orientation to forests and wildland fire management has on an individual’s decision to create defensible space around his or her residence in the wildland–urban interface. Using data from a mail-back questionnaire, respondents in north central...

  • Study sees $2B wildfire loss. Hays, Daniel // National Underwriter / Property & Casualty Risk & Benefits Manag;02/02/98, Vol. 102 Issue 5, p28 

    Focuses on a study entitled `The Wildland/Urban Fire Hazard, highlighting that insurers can expect wildfires that cause approximately $2 billion in losses as the population moves into wooded areas and fire suppression efforts creating denser forests. Recommended solutions for the fire danger;...

  • Natural Resource Stocks: Cyclical or Secular? Sehgal, Rohit // Equities;Jun2007, Vol. 55 Issue 3, p88 

    The article focuses on the current debate surrounding natural resources stocks. Past economic cycles reveal that resources tend to follow a cyclical pattern, they generate very high returns for short periods of time and underperform the market until the next commodity run. According to the...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics