Covert observation in practice: lessons from the evaluation of the prohibition of smoking in public places in Scotland

Petticrew, Mark; Semple, Sean; Hilton, Shona; Creely, Kaen S.; Eadie, Douglas; Ritchi, Deborah; Ferrell, Catherine; Christopher, Yvette; Hurley, Fintan
January 2007
BMC Public Health;2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p204
Academic Journal
Background: A ban on smoking in wholly or substantially enclosed public places has been in place in Scotland since 26th March 2006. The impact of this legislation is currently being evaluated in seven studies, three of which involve direct observation of smoking in bars and other enclosed public places. While the ethical issues around covert observation have been widely discussed there is little practical guidance on the conduct of such research. A workshop was therefore convened to identify practical lessons learned so far from the Scottish evaluation. Methods: We convened a workshop involving researchers from the three studies which used direct observation. In addition, one of the fieldwork managers collected written feedback on the fieldwork, identifying problems that arose in the field and some solutions. Results: There were four main themes identified: (i) the difficulty of achieving and maintaining concealment; (ii) the experience of being an observer; (iii) the risk of bias in the observations and (iv) issues around training and recruitment. These are discussed. Conclusion: Collecting covert observational data poses unique practical challenges, in particular in relation to the health and safety of the researcher. The findings and solutions presented in this paper will be of value to researchers designing similar studies.


Related Articles

  • Up In Smoke.  // Foodservice & Hospitality;Jan2006, Vol. 38 Issue 11, p8 

    The article reports on the plan of Vancouver Coastal Health Authority (VCHA) to ban smoking in public areas to prepare for the 2010 Olympics, in British Columbia. The proposal of VCHA was due to the purpose of lifting the grey haze that is over the city by banning smoking on patios, beaches,...

  • Fitch, RBS explore outcome of likely smoking ban in U.K. N. C. // Asset Securitization Report;1/16/2006, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p17 

    The article reports on the proposal of a Health Bill on October 2005, which bans smoking in public places in Great Britain. The Health Bill also changed the date of introducing the ban to summer 2007 instead of 2008. But before it can be implemented, the Health Bill is expected to enter the...

  • Health benefits justify smoking ban job losses. Millar, Michael // Personnel Today;1/18/2005, p1 

    This article reports that the risk of widespread job losses if there is a ban on smoking in public places is justified by the health benefits, according to an MP pushing for a ban in Wales. Julie Morgan, MP for Cardiff North, has introduced a Private Members' Bill that would give the Welsh...

  • Optimizing on smoke free legislation making the most of the opportunity. Croghan, Emma // British Journal of Community Nursing;Aug2007, Vol. 12 Issue 8, p334 

    Stop smoking service provision faces significant challenges in optmizing the opportunities raised through the smoke free legislation, which prohibits smoking in a public place. There are a numebr of innovations in service provision allowing a more tailored and flexible approach to stopping...

  • Legislator: Statewide smoking ban could pass in 2011. Dieter, Mary // Indianapolis Business Journal;11/22/2010, Vol. 31 Issue 38, p4A 

    The article reports on the statewide smoking ban bill which could pass in 2011 in Indiana. It mentions that the plan of Representative Charlie Brown to offer a bill that would ban public smoking without exemption for any establishment will likely to pass because Republicans, who already...

  • Wales looks towards public smoking ban. Betts, Clive; Harris, David // Caterer & Hotelkeeper;1/30/2003, Vol. 192 Issue 4258, p8 

    Reports on the legislative step taken in Wales to ban smoking in public buildings in January 2003. Details of the two-stage ban called for by Alun Pugh, the Labour member proposing the all-party motion; Impact of the implementation of the law on the country; Aim of the Public Places Charter.

  • State smoking ban catching fire. Clement, Douglas // Fedgazette;May2002, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p12 

    Reports on the adoption of a legislative bill banning smoking in public places in South Dakota. Reactions to the ban; Economic advantage for restaurants that serve liquor.

  • Big Tobacco escapes from now. Fitzgerald, Nora // Adweek Eastern Edition;6/22/1998, Vol. 39 Issue 25, p4 

    Reports that the tobacco bill and the regulations restricting cigarette advertising passed by Grand Old Party member Senator John McCain is rejected in the Senate through a technicality. Impact on cigarette manufacturer Big Tobacco; Pledge to reintroduce the McCain bill; Provision of the...

  • New York City mayor pursues public indoor smoking ban. Arias, Donya Currie // Nation's Health;Oct2002, Vol. 32 Issue 8, p6 

    Reports on the introduction of the New York City Indoor Smoke-Free Air Act of 2002 by Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg. Provisions of the legislation; Information on smoking restrictions being implemented in the city; Importance of the ban according to New York City Health Commissioner Thomas Frieden.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics