Reducing the incidence of early reading difficulties: Professional Development for classroom teachers versus direct interventions for children

Scanlon, Donna M.; Gelzheiser, Lynn M.; Vellutino, Frank R.; Schatschneider, Christopher; Sweeney, Joan M.
June 2008
Learning & Individual Differences;Jun2008, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p346
Academic Journal
Abstract: This study examined the effectiveness of two tiers of intervention for preventing early reading difficulties among kindergarten children who qualified as at risk of experiencing difficulty in the early stages of learning to read. Participating schools were randomly assigned to one of three treatment conditions: Professional Development for classroom teachers which served as a Tier 1 intervention, small group supplemental Intervention for children which served as a Tier 2 intervention, or both Professional Development for teachers and direct intervention for children. Three cohorts of children were followed from the beginning of kindergarten to the beginning of first grade. The first cohort served as a Baseline Cohort. The experimental treatments were instituted for the second cohort (Implementation Cohort). The third cohort served as a Maintenance Cohort which allowed us to evaluate whether effects of PD were still evident in the year following the implementation of the PD program. Data were gathered on both student achievement and classroom language arts instruction for each cohort. Outcomes suggested that all three treatments were very effective in reducing the number of at risk kindergartners who remained at risk for reading difficulties at the end of the school year although differences in the effectiveness of classroom instruction observed for the Baseline Cohort made it difficult to confidently compare the relative effectiveness of the three treatment conditions. However, comparisons between the Baseline and Maintenance Cohorts clearly revealed characteristics of classroom instruction that were associated with reductions in the number of children who qualified as at risk for reading difficulties at the beginning of first grade.


Related Articles

  • Language skills, learning to read and reading intervention. Snowling, Margaret J.; Hulme, Charles // London Review of Education;Mar2006, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p63 

    The paper outlines a framework for the development of reading that shows it is heavily dependent upon spoken language processes. Within this view, reading difficulties can follow from difficulties with speech processing (decoding problems) or from broader language processing impairments...

  • Visual scanning and reading ability in normal and dyslexic children. Ferretti, G.; Mazzotti, S.; Brizzolara, D. // Behavioural Neurology;2008, Vol. 19 Issue 1/2, p87 

    Very few studies have investigated the development of visual search of aligned stimuli in relation to normal reading acquisition and in developmental dyslexia. In this study we used a new computerised experimental task which requires a visuo-motor response (RT) to a target appearing...

  • Long-term outcome of the early identification and intervention of reading disabilities. Partanen, Marita; Siegel, Linda // Reading & Writing;Apr2014, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p665 

    This study examined the longitudinal effects of an early literacy intervention in Kindergarten. A group of children completed reading and cognitive measures between Kindergarten (5-6 years old) and Grade 7 (12-13 years old). Our results showed that 22 % of children were identified as at-risk for...

  • Phonological Awareness: Effecting Change Through the Integration of Research Findings. Gillon, Gail T. // Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools;Oct2005, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p346 

    The article presents information about a clinical forum, in which speech-language pathologists were made aware of interesting new research. Caution was advised in the integrating of the new research into current practices until the strength of the new research could be determined. The first...

  • Schools and Classrooms as Caring Communities. Schaps, Eric; Solomon, Daniel // Educational Leadership;Nov90, Vol. 48 Issue 3, p38 

    The article describes a program in place in seven elementary schools in two California districts. This program, the Child Development Project (CDP), fosters the creation of a caring community within each school and each classroom. Although students spend their academic careers in groups, school...

  • Training Phonological Awareness: A Study with Inner-City Kindergarten Children. Brady, Susan; Fowler, Anne; Stone, Brenda; Winbury, Nancy // Annals of Dyslexia;1994, Vol. 44, p26 

    A small-scale, longitudinal, phonological awareness training study with inner-city kindergarten children was conducted in four classrooms. The central goalÅ› of the study were the creation and evaluation of a phonological awareness training program and a preliminary look at the consequence of...

  • Longitudinal Prediction and Prevention of Early Reading Difficulty. Mann, Virginia A. // Annals of Dyslexia;1984, Vol. 34, p117 

    The results of many studies suggest that early reading problems are associated with deficiencies in certain spoken language skills. Children who encounter reading difficulty tend to be deficient in the perception of spoken words, the ability to retain linguistic material in temporary memory, and...

  • Layers of Reading Intervention in Kindergarten Through Third Grade: Changes in Teaching and Student Outcomes. O'Connor, Rollanda E.; Fulmer, Deborah; Harty, Kristin R.; Bell, Kathryn M. // Journal of Learning Disabilities;Sep/Oct2005, Vol. 38 Issue 5, p440 

    In this study, students and their teachers participated in a layered approach to reading intervention in kindergarten through third grade that included professional development for teachers in scientifically based reading instruction, ongoing measurement of reading progress, and additional...

  • Response to Intervention as a Vehicle for Distinguishing Between Children With and Without Reading Disabilities: Evidence for the Role of Kindergarten and First-Grade Interventions. Vellutino, Frank R.; Scanlon, Donna M.; Small, Sheila; Fanuele, Diane P. // Journal of Learning Disabilities;Mar/Apr2006, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p157 

    Children at risk for early reading difficulties were identified on entry into kindergarten, and half of these children received small-group intervention two to three times a week during their kindergarten year. The other half received whatever remedial assistance was offered by their home...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics