Some Difficult Intuitions for the Principle of Universality

Kershnar, Stephen
December 2009
Utilitas;Dec2009, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p478
Academic Journal
The Principle of Universality asserts that a part retains its intrinsic value regardless of the whole in which it is a part or even whether it is part of a whole. The idea underlying this principle is that the intrinsic value of a thing supervenes on its intrinsic properties. Since the intrinsic properties remain unchanged so does the thing's intrinsic value. In this article, I argue that, properly understood, the Principle of Universality can handle seemingly troublesome intuitions about the relative intrinsic value of a vicious person having pain and his having pleasure. I specifically argue that the intuition that the former state is better is explained by the nature of the basic intrinsic-value states, which involve a person having a level of well-being and desert at a time. One implication of this is that given the nature of such basic intrinsic-value states, pleasure and pain are not value-bearing parts of virtuous and vicious attitudes.


Related Articles

  • INTUITION AND PERCEPTION IN THE SIXTH LOGICAL INVESTIGATION OF EDMUND HUSSERL. Ferrarello, Susi // Revista de Filosofía UIS;2010, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p117 

    In this paper I would like to focus on the phenomenological definition of perception and on its relationship with intuition. Insofar these two ideas seem to play a pivotal role in the process of knowledge, we wonder if intuition has its own property or if it is a part of perception. In short we...

  • Analyzing Double Image Illusion through Double Indiscernibility and Lattice Theory. Sonoda, Kohei; Kitamura, Eugene S.; Tani, Iori; Shirakawa, Tomohiro; Gunji, Yukio-Pegio // TripleC (Cognition, Communication, Co-Operation): Open Access Jo;Jul2011, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p510 

    The figure-ground division plays a fundamental role in all image perceptions. Although there are a lot of studies about extraction of a figure such as detection of edges or grouping of texture, there are few discussions about a relationship between obtained figure and ground. We focused on...

  • Simultaneous changes in length and direction as a cue for perceived depth. Brigner, Willard L.; Deni, James R. // Perceptual & Motor Skills;Jun94, Vol. 78 Issue 3, p1385 

    Examines simultaneous changes in length and direction of a configuration's elements as a cue for perceived depth of the kinetic depth effect. Study of responses by 12 undergraduate volunteers from classes in general psychology who perceived a computer-generated configuration of three lines...

  • GESTALT CONCEPT OF CLOSURE A CONSTRUCT WITHOUT CLOSURE. Wasserstein, Jeannette // Perceptual & Motor Skills;Dec2002, Vol. 95 Issue 3, p963 

    This comment reviews the original Gestalt literature which introduced the concept of 'closure'. It is argued that the meaning of 'closure' was confounded in the source literature and, thus, the term connotes more than it denotes. Research based on different measures of this ambiguous construct...

  • IS FEELING PAIN THE PERCEPTION OF SOMETHING? Aydede, Murat // Journal of Philosophy;Oct2009, Vol. 106 Issue 10, p531 

    The article focuses on the perceptual and representational accounts of feeling pain. Through understanding the sensory perception and its integration with conceptual systems, it criticizes the claim that pain in a body region is perceiving a nonmetal property. It argues that feeling pain is not...

  • Violence as intentionality for survival and power in two Yoruba films. Wale Ojoniyi, Olabode // Journal of African Cinemas;Apr2015, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p31 

    This article explores how violence is motivated by different levels of apprehension in man's consciousness to provoke him/her to certain vicious actions. It builds on the hypothetical suggestion of Nietzsche that men interpret the world through their fears and project their fears into the nature...

  • Ethical Intuitionism and the Emotions: Toward an Empirically Adequate Moral Sense Theory. Sias, James // Journal of Value Inquiry;Sep2014, Vol. 48 Issue 3, p533 

    In this article, the author reflects on ethical intuitionism, moral sense theory, and emotions. It discusses role and significance of emotions in moral judgment. Psychological sentimentalism, Nicomachean ethics and construals, such as fear, anger, and grief involved in emotions, are also discussed.

  • The Intellectual Given. BENGSON, JOHN // Mind;Jul2015, Vol. 124 Issue 495, p707 

    The author presents a quasi-perceptualist view of intuition. Topics covered include a non-metaphorical explication of the nature of intuition, the similarities and differences between intuition and perceptual experience, the types of contentful state, the difference in the usage of the terms...

  • STRUCTURAL UNIVERSALS AND THE PRINCIPLE OF UNIQUENESS OF COMPOSITION. Kalhat, Javier // Grazer Philosophische Studien;2008, Vol. 76 Issue 1, p57 

    Lewis has objected to Armstrong's notion of a structural universal on the grounds that it violates the Principle of Uniqueness of Composition (PUC), which says that given some parts, there is only one whole that they compose. This paper reviews Armstrong's case for structural universals, and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics