Silliman, Scott L.
September 2009
Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law;2009, Vol. 42 Issue 1/2, p289
Academic Journal
President Obama has announced that the detention facility at Guantánamo Bay will be closed by January 22, 2010. He has also said that at least some of the detainees facing criminal prosecution will be tried in military commissions. The system of military commissions established by President Bush after the 9/11 attacks, as well as the one which Congress enacted in 2006 following the Supreme Court's Hamdan decision, were widely criticized as being unproductive and not meeting international legal standards. The Congress has, very recently, revised the rules and procedures for military commissions to make them fair, effective and much more like those used for courts-martial. This article compares and contrasts trials in revised military commissions with trials in federal district courts. It concludes that a combination of both forums would best serve the President, and that military commissions are still a prudent option for prosecuting some detainees where there are security and admissibility of evidence concerns.


Related Articles

  • 'FULL STEAM AHEAD' AT GUANTÁNAMO. Isikoff, Michael // Newsweek;4/5/2010, Vol. 155 Issue 14, p14 

    This article discusses the reversal of the 2009 halt on U.S. military-commission legal cases in 2010, with mention of concerns about holding the trials at the Guantánamo Bay U.S. military detention camp in Cuba and the expressed intent of U.S. President Barack Obama to close the camp.

  • World Report. Kingsbury, Alex; Rettig, Jessica // U.S. News Digital Weekly;3/11/2011, Vol. 3 Issue 10, p8 

    This section offers news briefs related to politics from around the world. The resumption of military trials for prisoners at Guantanamo Bay was ordered by U.S. President Barack Obama. The reluctance of the U.S. Finance Committee toward free trade deals with South Korea, Panama and Comobia has...

  • Leave Gitmo Prisoners Where They Are. Cucullu, Gordon // Human Events;11/2/2009, Vol. 65 Issue 38, p22 

    The author focuses on the opposition to the decision of U.S. President Barack Obama to close the Guantanamo detention facility in Cuba and relocate the prisoners to the U.S. He claims that the closure of the facility poses dangers to U.S. citizens as the prisoners are terrorists. He cites the...

  • Dangerous Decision: Terrorists should be treated as enemy combatants, not criminal defendants. King, Peter // Ripon Forum;Winter2010, Vol. 44 Issue 1, p8 

    The article discusses the reasons why the U.S. government should treat captured terrorists as enemy combatants and not as criminal defendants. It states that terrorists should be put in military commissions to protect the Americans against terrorism. The author also criticizes the decision of...

  • Closing Gitmo Doesn't Make America Safer. Maginnis, Robert // Human Events;2/2/2009, Vol. 65 Issue 5, p1 

    The author criticizes the claim of U.S. President Barack Obama that closing the terrorist detention camp in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba (Gitmo) will make the U.S. safer. He opposes the myths that Gitmo encourages terrorism and that closing Gitmo will defuse Muslim alienation toward U.S. which will...

  • Guantanamo Is a Little Emptier These Days, But When Will it Finally Be Closed? Sprusansky, Dale // Washington Report on Middle East Affairs;Mar/Apr2015, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p34 

    In this article the author asks when will the Guantanamo Bay detention facility (Gitmo) in Cuba be finally closed as U.S. President Barack Obama does not offer a clear timeline for its closing. Topics discussed include the increase in the number of prisoners being released and the introduction...

  • TWO SPEECHES. Toobin, Jeffrey // New Yorker;6/1/2009, Vol. 85 Issue 16, p27 

    The author comments on speeches that have been delivered by U.S. President Barack Obama and former U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney on the closing of the prison at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. Obama's attempts to close the prison with the help of the U.S. Congress are discussed. Obama's plans to...

  • Now, Obama is releasing drug dealers as well as terrorists. ANDREW MALCOLM // Investors Business Daily;12/21/2015, p1 

    Given all the holiday hoopla and the president's own news conference Friday, you probably missed the news about his latest prisoner releases.

  • Putting Terrorist Boots On The Ground. Investor's Business Daily // Investors Business Daily;12/21/2015, pA18 

    The article reports on the rationale of Pentagon to clear the release of 17 more terrorist detainees from Guantanamo Bay prison. The move is in line with U.S. President Barack Obama to put jihadist boots on the ground before mobilizing U.S. troops in the Middle East. The White House's strategy...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics