Challenges in Combining Projections from Multiple Climate Models

Knutti, Reto; Furrer, Reinhard; Tebaldi, Claudia; Cermak, Jan; Meehl, Gerald A.
May 2010
Journal of Climate;May2010, Vol. 23 Issue 10, p2739
Academic Journal
Recent coordinated efforts, in which numerous general circulation climate models have been run for a common set of experiments, have produced large datasets of projections of future climate for various scenarios. Those multimodel ensembles sample initial conditions, parameters, and structural uncertainties in the model design, and they have prompted a variety of approaches to quantifying uncertainty in future climate change. International climate change assessments also rely heavily on these models. These assessments often provide equal-weighted averages as best-guess results, assuming that individual model biases will at least partly cancel and that a model average prediction is more likely to be correct than a prediction from a single model based on the result that a multimodel average of present-day climate generally outperforms any individual model. This study outlines the motivation for using multimodel ensembles and discusses various challenges in interpreting them. Among these challenges are that the number of models in these ensembles is usually small, their distribution in the model or parameter space is unclear, and that extreme behavior is often not sampled. Model skill in simulating present-day climate conditions is shown to relate only weakly to the magnitude of predicted change. It is thus unclear by how much the confidence in future projections should increase based on improvements in simulating present-day conditions, a reduction of intermodel spread, or a larger number of models. Averaging model output may further lead to a loss of signal—for example, for precipitation change where the predicted changes are spatially heterogeneous, such that the true expected change is very likely to be larger than suggested by a model average. Last, there is little agreement on metrics to separate “good” and “bad” models, and there is concern that model development, evaluation, and posterior weighting or ranking are all using the same datasets. While the multimodel average appears to still be useful in some situations, these results show that more quantitative methods to evaluate model performance are critical to maximize the value of climate change projections from global models.


Related Articles

  • Incorporating climate change impacts and adaptation in environmental impact assessments: Opportunities and challenges. Agrawala, Shardul; Matus Kramer, Arnoldo; Prudent-Richard, Guillaume; Sainsbury, Marcus; Schreitter, Victoria // Climate & Development;2012, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p26 

    National governments and international donors have put considerable effort in developing methodologies and tools to screen projects for risks posed by climate change. However, the application of such tools within actual project settings remains limited. An alternate approach would be to examine...

  • A Better Climate Change Agreement. Stavins, Robert N. // Environmental Forum;Jan/Feb2005, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p12 

    States that an economic perspective can provide useful insights into sensible solutions on the causes and consequences of environmental problems. Information on the Kyoto Protocol to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change; Suggestions to address the global problem, including the need for...

  • Ground force. Firth, Niall // Engineer (00137758);12/12/2005, Vol. 293 Issue 7690, p16 

    The article presents information on the project called Bionics based on the impact of climate change on the transport industry in Great Britain. The project investigates the possible effects that a drastically changed weather system could have on the transport network. Bionics will look at the...

  • The Climate Sensitivity and Its Components Diagnosed from Earth Radiation Budget Data. Forster, Piers M. de F.; Gregory, Jonathan M. // Journal of Climate;Jan2006, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p39 

    One of the major uncertainties in the ability to predict future climate change, and hence its impacts, is the lack of knowledge of the earth’s climate sensitivity. Here, data are combined from the 1985–96 Earth Radiation Budget Experiment (ERBE) with surface temperature change...

  • The Sensitivity of Mountain Snowpack Accumulation to Climate Warming. Minder, Justin R. // Journal of Climate;May2010, Vol. 23 Issue 10, p2634 

    Controls on the sensitivity of mountain snowpack accumulation to climate warming ( λS) are investigated. This is accomplished using two idealized, physically based models of mountain snowfall to simulate snowpack accumulation for the Cascade Mountains under current and warmed climates. Both...

  • Evaluating the Response of Cladocera to Recent Environmental Changes in Lakes from the Central Canadian Arctic Treeline Region. Sweetman, Jon N.; LaFace, Elyse; Rühland, Kathleen M.; Smol, John P. // Arctic, Antarctic & Alpine Research;Aug2008, Vol. 40 Issue 3, p584 

    Arctic and subarctic ecosystems have undergone considerable environmental changes in recent years as the result of climate warming. Fossil records of freshwater diatoms in lakes throughout the circumpolar Arctic, including the central Canadian Arctic treeline region, have revealed marked...

  • Plant phenology networks of citizen scientists: recommendations from two decades of experience in Canada. Beaubien, Elisabeth; Hamann, Andreas // International Journal of Biometeorology;Nov2011, Vol. 55 Issue 6, p833 

    Plant phenology networks of citizen scientists have a long history and have recently contributed to our understanding of climate change effects on ecosystems. This paper describes the development of the Alberta and Canada PlantWatch programs, which coordinate networks of citizen scientists who...

  • Study Examines Climate Change's Impacts on Health, Environment, Economy; Research Led by Harvard Medical School's Center for Health and the Global Environment With Sponsorship From Swiss Re, United Nations Development Programme.  // Ascribe Newswire: Medicine;10/25/2005, p6 

    This article reports that the Center for Health and the Global Environment at Harvard Medical School, along with co-sponsors Swiss Re and the United Nations Development Programme, will hold a news conference and teleconference to release findings of a study on climate change and its relationship...

  • Climate change in the Tahoe basin: regional trends, impacts and drivers. Coats, Robert // Climatic Change;Oct2010, Vol. 102 Issue 3/4, p435 

    The purpose of this study was to quantify the decadal-scale time trends in air temperature, precipitation phase and intensity, spring snowmelt timing, and lake temperature in the Tahoe basin, and to relate the trends to large-scale regional climatic trends in the western USA. Temperature data...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics