TITLE

The Right to an Impartial Hearing Trumps the Social Imperative of Bringing Accused to Trial Even 'Down Under'

AUTHOR(S)
Bagaric, Mirko
PUB. DATE
October 2010
SOURCE
Criminal Law & Philosophy;Oct2010, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p321
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
used persons who are subjected to a saturation level of negative media coverage may be denied an impartial hearing, which is perhaps the most important aspect of the right to a fair hearing. Despite this, the courts have generally held that the social imperative of prosecuting accused trumps the interests of the accused. The justification for an impartial hearing stems from the repugnance of convicting the innocent. Viewed dispassionately, this imperative is not absolute, given that every legal system condones procedures which result in the conviction of some innocent people. While the importance of guarding against wrongful convictions has been overstated, the imperative to bring to trial all accused has been even more exaggerated. The legal system has displayed a capacity to deal with cases where the guilty walk free. The institutional integrity of the criminal justice system would be significantly compromised by convictions that are tarnished by pre-judgment. Confidence in the criminal justice system is more important than individual criminal accountability. The inability to receive an impartial hearing should result in a permanent stay. The only exception is where the alleged crime has the capacity to cause widespread fear or social unrest. This only applies in relation to serious acts of terrorism. This article focuses on recent legal fair trial developments in Australia, however, the analysis, reasoning and conclusion applies in relation to all jurisdictions where juries determine guilt and innocence.
ACCESSION #
53873721

 

Related Articles

  • Transnational Cooperation in Criminal Matters and the Guarantee of a Fair Trial: Approaches to a General Principle. Gless, Sabine // Utrecht Law Review;Sep2013, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p90 

    The article highlights the general principle of fair trial which leads through transnational criminal justice. It explores the inclusion of acts of cooperation, evidentiary matters and investigative measures in "equality of arms" and "fair trial" in transnational criminal cases. It discusses the...

  • LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS DE LAS VÍCTIMAS: APUNTES PARA LA REFORMULACIÓN DEL SISTEMA PENAL. SAMPEDRO-ARRUBLA, JULIO ANDRÉS // International Law;oct2008, Issue 12, p353 

    This article is the result of a study of victimology by the research team "Estudios de Derecho Público" (acknowledged by Colciencias as category "A"). It reflects, in its first part, on the historic negligence of victims as well as on the change in perspective regarding victims' rights needed...

  • Justice against terrorism: What should Britain learn from French techniques? Northam, Gerry // International Journal of Police Science & Management;Autumn2003, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p155 

    Explore the justice system against terrorism in France. Human rights dimension; Minimum prison terms; Allegations of physical ill-treatment of people in police custody; Criticism of trial process.

  • Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999: Special Measures Directions�Compliance with Article 6. Hoyano, Laura // Journal of Criminal Law;Dec2005, Vol. 69 Issue 6, p488 

    The article focuses on the requirement for cases from the youth courts in Great Britain, to comply with Article Six of the European Convention on Human Rights. The witnesses in trials involving charges of sex, violence, neglect or kidnapping are deemed in need of special protection. It is apt...

  • Making the Lithuanian Justice System Worthy of Trust. STREETER, PATRICIA A. // Lituanus;2009, Vol. 55 Issue 2, p82 

    The article looks at the justice system of Lithuania. During the Soviet occupation of Lithuania the protection of human rights suffered greatly, and as a result public confidence in the Lithuanian government, police, and court system have been low following the country's independence in 1991....

  • Was the Dujail Trial Fair? Sissons, Miranda; Bassin, Ari S. // Journal of International Criminal Justice;May2007, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p272 

    The Dujail trial against eight persons accused of crimes against humanity was intended as the first of fourteen trials; it was seen as a quick and simple case that would enable the Tribunal to develop its skills outside the limelight. The trial was in fact a missed opportunity in the search for...

  • THE POLICE-HEALTH PROFESSIONS' PROTOCOL: A REVIEW. HESKETH, WENDY // Police Journal;Sep2012, Vol. 85 Issue 3, p203 

    A protocol for liaison between the police and the medical profession in dealing with crime committed by health professionals was implemented after being proposed in this journal in 2003. However, rather than using their diverse skills to scrupulously investigate allegations of medico-crime, the...

  • Unlawful Sexual Intercourse: Compatibility with Articles 6, 8 and 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Roberts, Andrew // Journal of Criminal Law;Aug2005, Vol. 69 Issue 4, p292 

    This article focuses on a court case indicating the violation of Articles 6, 8 and 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which deal with laws governing unlawful sexual intercourse. In December 2002, the appellant, when aged 15 years, engaged in consensual sexual intercourse with a...

  • ENGLISH CRIMINAL PROCEDURE UNDER ARTICLE 6 OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS: IMPLICATIONS FOR CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION PRACTICES. Toney, Raymond J. // Houston Journal of International Law;Spring2002, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p411 

    Discusses criminal procedure in England under Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights, which provides for fair trial guarantees. Nature and importance of police interrogation in the English criminal process; Disclosure and equality of arms; Article 6(3)(c) requirements for effective...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics