Cognitive Architecture and the Epistemic Gap: Defending Physicalism without Phenomenal Concepts

Fazekas, Peter
March 2011
Philosophia;Mar2011, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p21
Academic Journal
The novel approach presented in this paper accounts for the occurrence of the epistemic gap and defends physicalism against anti-physicalist arguments without relying on so-called phenomenal concepts. Instead of concentrating on conceptual features, the focus is shifted to the special characteristics of experiences themselves. To this extent, the account provided is an alternative to the Phenomenal Concept Strategy. It is argued that certain sensory representations, as accessed by higher cognition, lack constituent structure. Unstructured representations could freely exchange their causal roles within a given system which entails their functional unanalysability. These features together with the encapsulated nature of low level complex processes giving rise to unstructured sensory representations readily explain those peculiarities of phenomenal consciousness which are usually taken to pose a serious problem for contemporary physicalism. I conclude that if those concepts which are related to the phenomenal character of conscious experience are special in any way, their characteristics are derivative of and can be accounted for in terms of the cognitive and representational features introduced in the present paper.


Related Articles

  • Having it Both Ways: Consciousness, Unique Not Otherworldly. Elpidorou, Andreas // Philosophia;Dec2013, Vol. 41 Issue 4, p1181 

    I respond to Chalmers’ ( 2006 , 2010 ) objection to the Phenomenal Concept Strategy (PCS) by showing that his objection is faced with a dilemma that ultimately undercuts its force. Chalmers argues that no version of PCS can posit psychological features that are both physically explicable...

  • Consciousness and Conceivability. Hunter, David A. // Canadian Journal of Philosophy;Jun2003, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p285 

    Interprets the thesis 'Knowledge, Possibility and Consciousness,' by John Perry. Nature of conceivability of arguments; Qualitative aspects of conscious experiences; Concept of Antecedent Physicalism; Physicalist conception of qualia; Concept of epiphenomenalism; Interpretation of anti-physical...

  • The cognitive significance of phenomenal knowledge. Veillet, Bénédicte // Philosophical Studies;Nov2015, Vol. 172 Issue 11, p2955 

    Knowledge of what it's like to have perceptual experiences, e.g. of what it's like to see red or taste Turkish coffee, is phenomenal knowledge; and it is knowledge the substantial or significant nature of which is widely assumed to pose a challenge for physicalism. Call this the New Challenge to...

  • Ecological economics and the politics of knowledge: the debate between Hayek and Neurath. O'Neill, John // Cambridge Journal of Economics;May2004, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p431 

    Hayek's epistemic arguments against planning were aimed not just against socialism but also the tradition of ecological economics. The concern with the physical pit- conditions of economic activity and defence of non-monetary measures in economic choice were expressions of the same rationalist...

  • Physicalism and the Intrinsic Nature of Consciousness. LEWTAS, PATRICK // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Jun2014, Vol. 53 Issue 2, p203 

    This paper presents a metaphysical argument against physicalism based on the distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic properties. It argues that the physical, as physicalism must understand it, consists entirely of extrinsic properties, whereas consciousness involves at least some intrinsic...

  • Physicalism and Phenomenal Consciousness. Kirk, Robert // Teorema;2008, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p71 

    An influential argument against physicalism goes: (1) If physicalism is true, transposed and absent qualia are impossible; (2) Transposed and absent qualia are possible; (3) Therefore physicalism is false. I argue that physicalism commits you to the 'strict implication thesis', hence to a strong...

  • We are living in a material world (and I am a material girl). Díaz-León, E. // Teorema;2008, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p85 

    In this paper I examine the question of whether the characterization of physicalism that is presupposed by some influential anti-physicalist arguments, namely conceivability arguments, is a good characterization of physicalism or not. I compare this characterization with some alternatives,...

  • Conciencia y dualismo. Pineda, David // Teorema;2008, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p131 

    In this paper I present an objection to the Kripke-Chalmers version of the conceivability argument against physicalism. I also assess the prospects of this physicalist response in the light of two further difficulties: the epistemology of modality and the property dualism argument.

  • Critical reflection: an alleged epistemic duty. Tidman, Paul // Analysis;1996, Vol. 56 Issue 4, p268 

    The article discusses the attempt of Kihyeon Kim to rescue the conception of epistemic justification from William Alston's advanced criticism. The conception suggests that justification is understood as a matter of being epistemically responsible. An overview of Alston's argument is given. Kim's...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics