Between mind and trace - A research into the theories on Xin 心 (Mind) of early Song Confucianism and Buddhism

Xiang, Shiling
June 2011
Frontiers of Philosophy in China;Jun2011, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p173
Academic Journal
From Han Yu's yuan Dao 原道 (retracing the Dao) to Ouyang Xiu's lun ben 论本 (discussing the root), the conflicts arising from Confucianists' rejection of Buddhism were focused on one point, namely, the examination of zhongxin suo shou 中心所守 (something kept in mind). The attitude towards the distinction between mind and trace, and the proper approach to erase the gap between emptiness and being, as well as that between the expedient and the true, became the major concerns unavoidable for various thinkers to integrate the two teachings and to propel academic development. 'To understand by mind' and 'to blame for matter' were of crucial methodological significance for transcendence in both Confucianism and Buddhism. The arguments of Confucian scholars like Zhang Zai and the Cheng brothers on the identity of mind and trace and the unity of void and solid are mutually manifested. The same mind with the same principle means 'mind is principle.' The 'common axis of Confucianism and Buddhism' exists in the emphasis on mind beyond trace. The unification of mind and trace or the accordance of body and function has actually become the cardinal foundation for the possible mergence of the Three Teachings.


Related Articles

  • On the Classification of "Qixue". Rur-bin Yang // Hanxue Yanjiu (Chinese Studies);2007, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p247 

    Qixue ... is a school that can compete with Lixue ... and Xinxue ... in the works of modern historians of Chinese philosophy. Although neglected for a long time, it remains one of the few schools that can be connected to materialism. Qixue is a significant concept, but those who introduce it...

  • A reconsideration of the characteristics of Song-Ming Li Xue. Jin, Chunfeng // Frontiers of Philosophy in China;Sep2010, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p352 

    By analyzing Zhu Xi and Zhang Zai’s three representative explanatory paradigms—that of Feng Youlan, Mou Zongsan and Zhang Dainian, the paper tries to show that studying Chinese philosophy in a Western way and emphasizing logical consistency will unavoidably lead to the defects of...

  • M ou Zongsan and T ang Junyi on Z hang Zai's and W ang Fuzhi's Philosophies of Qi: A Critical Reflection. Chan, Wing-cheuk // Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy;Mar2011, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p85 

    the founders of Contemporary Neo-Confucianism, M ou Zongsan and T ang Junyi developed different interpretations of Z hang Zai's and W ang Fuzhi's philosophies of qi. In this essay, both the strength and weakness of their interpretations will be critically examined. As a contrast, an alternative...

  • Filial Piety, Vital Power, and a Moral Sense of Immortality in Z hang Zai's Philosophy. Patt-Shamir, Galia // Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy;Jun2012, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p223 

    The present article focuses on Z hang Zai's 張載 attitude toward death and its moral significance. It launches with the unusual link between the opening statement of the Western Inscription 西銘 regarding heaven and earth as parents and the conclusion that serving one's cosmic...

  • Zhou Dunyi's Diagram of the Supreme Ultimate Explained (Taijitu shuo): A Construction of the Confucian Metaphysics. Wang, Robin R. // Journal of the History of Ideas;Jul2005, Vol. 66 Issue 3, p307 

    Examines Zhou Dunyi's diagram of the Supreme Ultimate and his philosophical account of it. Forerunner of Neo-Confucianism and founder of Daoxue in the Song dynasty; Zhou Dunyi's distinctive approach to the yin-yang theory; Selective adaptation of certain elements of Confucian moral teaching into...

  • Yang, Lihua 楊立華, Qi-rooted and Shen-transformed: Commentary on Z hang Zai's Philosophy 氣本與神化:張載哲學述評. Woo Li, Elizabeth // Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy;Dec2010, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p487 

    The article reviews the book "Qi-Rooted and Shen-Transformed Commentary on Zhang Zai's Philosophy," by Yang Lihua.

  • Ancient Chinese philosophical advice: can it help us find happiness today? Zhang, Guoqing; Veenhoven, Ruut // Journal of Happiness Studies;Sep2008, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p425 

    Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism are three main classic Chinese philosophy schools, which all deal with the question of how one should live. In this paper, we first review these ancient recommendations and next consider whether they promise a happy life in present-day society. Recommended...

  • Heaven's partners or Nietzschean free spirits? Frisina, Warren G. // Philosophy East & West;Jan95, Vol. 45 Issue 1, p29 

    Presents a comparison between the Neo-Confucian struggle with Taoism and the contemporary struggles between Deweyan pragmatists and postmodern pragmatists like Richard Rorty. Argument that Deweyan pragmatists can learn from Rorty just as Neo-Confucians like Wang Yang-ming learned from Taoists;...

  • The Spirit of the School of Principles in Zhu Xi's Discussion of "Dreams"-And on "Confucius did not Dream of Duke Zhou". Chang Yu // Frontiers of Philosophy in China;Mar2010, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p94 

    Dreams were a topic of study even in ancient times, and they are a special spiritual phenomenon. Generations of literati have defined the meaning of dreams in their own way, while Zhu Xi was perhaps the most outstanding one among them. He made profound explanations of dreams from aspects such as...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics