Systematic review of clinical trials of cervical manipulation: control group procedures and pain outcomes

Vernon, Howard; Puhl, Aaron; Reinhart, Christine
January 2011
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies;Jan2011, Vol. 19, p1
Academic Journal
Objective: To characterize the types of control procedures used in controlled clinical trials of cervical spine manipulation and to evaluate the outcomes obtained by subjects in control groups so as to improve the quality of future clinical trials Methods: A search of relevant clinical trials was performed in PubMed 1966-May 2010 with the following key words: "Chiropractic"[Mesh] OR "Manipulation, Spinal"[Mesh]) AND "Clinical Trial "[Publication Type]. Reference lists from these trials were searched for any additional trials. The reference lists of two prior studies, one review and one original study were also searched. Accepted reports were then rated for quality by 2 reviewers using the PEDro scale. Studies achieving a score of >50% were included for data extraction and analysis. Intra-group change scores on pain outcomes were obtained. For determining clinically important outcomes, a threshold of 20% improvement was used where continuous data were available; otherwise, an effect size of 0.30 was employed Results: The PubMed search yielded 753 citations of which 13 were selected. Eight (8) other studies were identified by reviewing two systematic reviews and through reference searches. All studies scored >50% on the PEDro scale. There were 9 multi-session studies and 12 single-session studies. The most commonly used control procedure was "manual contact/no thrust". Four (4) studies used a placebo-control (patient blinded). For two of these studies with VAS data, the average change reported was 4.5 mm. For the other control procedures, variable results were obtained. No clinically important changes were reported in 57% of the paired comparisons, while, in 43% of these, changes which would be considered clinically important were obtained in the control groups. Only 15% of trials reported on post-intervention group registration. Conclusions: Most control procedures in cervical manipulation trials result in small clinical changes, although larger changes are observed in 47% of paired comparisons. The vast majority of studies do not result in subject blinding; the effect of unmasking of control subjects in these studies makes the interpretation of the existing clinical trials challenging. The greatest majority of trials do not report on post-intervention blinding. A small number of candidate procedures for effective control interventions exist. Much more research is required to improve this important aspect of clinical trial methodology in cervical manipulation studies.


Related Articles

  • Peripheral response to cervical or thoracic spinal manual therapy: an evidence-based review with meta analysis. Chu, Jennifer; Allen, Diane D.; Pawlowsky, Sarah; Smoot, Betty // Journal of Manual & Manipulative Therapy (Maney Publishing);Nov2014, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p220 

    Objectives: Spinal manual therapy (SMT) is commonly used for treatment of musculoskeletal pain in the neck, upper back, or upper extremity. Some authors report a multi-system effect of SMT, including peripheral alterations in skin conductance and skin temperature, suggesting that SMT may...

  • Efficacy of Acupuncture in Itch: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Clinical Randomized Controlled Trials. Chi Yu; Pei Zhang; Zheng-Tao Lv; Jing-Jing Li; Hong-Ping Li; Cai-Hua Wu; Fang Gao; Xiao-Cui Yuan; Jing Zhang; Wei He; Xiang-Hong Jing; Man Li // Evidence-based Complementary & Alternative Medicine (eCAM);2015, p1 

    Background. Itch (pruritus) is a sensitive state that provokes the desire to scratch. It is not only a common symptom of skin diseases but it also occurs in some systemic diseases. Clinical studies on the efficacy of the acupuncture therapy in alleviating itch are increasing, while systematic...

  • Measurement of thirst in chronic heart failure - A review. Allida, Sabine M; Inglis, Sally C; Davidson, Patricia M; Hayward, Christopher S; Newton, Phillip J // Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profess;Aug2014, Vol. 48 Issue 1, p2 

    Background: Thirst is a bothersome symptom of chronic heart failure (CHF) which impacts adversely on quality of life. Despite this, limited work has been done to investigate thirst as a symptom or to develop reliable and valid measures of thirst in CHF. The purpose of this manuscript is to...

  • Traditional Chinese Medicine for Neck Pain and Low Back Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Yuan, Qi-ling; Guo, Tuan-mao; Liu, Liang; Sun, Fu; Zhang, Yin-gang // PLoS ONE;Feb2015, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p1 

    Background: Neck pain (NP) and low back pain (LBP) are common symptoms bothering people in daily life. Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has been used to treat various symptoms and diseases in China and has been demonstrated to be effective. The objective of the present study was to review and...

  • Manual therapies for cervicogenic headache: a systematic review. Chaibi, Aleksander; Russell, Michael // Journal of Headache & Pain;Jul2012, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p351 

    This paper systematically reviewed randomized clinical trials (RCT) assessing the efficacy of manual therapies for cervicogenic headache (CEH). A total of seven RCTs were identified, i.e. one study applied physiotherapy ± temporomadibular mobilization techniques and six studies applied...

  • A Meta-analysis of Clinical Effects of Low-level Laser Therapy on Temporomandibular Joint Pain. WEN-DIEN CHANG; CHIA-LUN LEE; HUNG-YU LIN; YUNG-CHUN HSU; CHUNG-JIEH WANG; PING-TUNG LAI // Journal of Physical Therapy Science;2014, Vol. 26 Issue 8, p1297 

    [Purpose] Temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain is a symptom of TMJ disease. Low-level laser therapy (LLLT) is often used in the clinical treatment of TMJ pain. The aim of this study was to review the effective parameters of LLLT for TMJ pain. [Methods] This study was a systematic review in which...

  • A meta-analysis on pain sensitivity in self-injury. Koenig, J.; Thayer, J. F.; Kaess, M. // Psychological Medicine;Jun2016, Vol. 46 Issue 8, p1597 

    Individuals engaging in self-injurious behavior (SIB) frequently report absence of pain during acts of SIB. While altered pain sensitivity is discussed as a risk factor for the engagement in SIB, results have been mixed with considerable variance across reported effect sizes, in particular with...

  • Is manipulative therapy more effective than sham manipulation in adults?: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Scholten-Peeters, Gwendolijne G. M.; Thoomes, Erik; Konings, Sophie; Beijer, Michelle; Verkerk, Karin; Koes, Bart W.; Verhagen, Arianne P. // Chiropractic & Manual Therapies;2013, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p34 

    Background: Manipulative therapy is widely used in the treatment of spinal disorders. Manipulative techniques are under debate because of the possibility of adverse events. To date, the efficacy of manipulations compared to sham manipulations is unclear. The purpose of the study is: to assess...

  • Chinese Herbal Bath Therapy for the Treatment of Knee Osteoarthritis: Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Chen, Bo; Zhan, Hongsheng; Chung, Mei; Lin, Xun; Zhang, Min; Pang, Jian; Wang, Chenchen // Evidence-based Complementary & Alternative Medicine (eCAM);9/21/2015, Vol. 2015, p1 

    Objective. Chinese herbal bath therapy (CHBT) has traditionally been considered to have analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects. We conducted the first meta-analysis evaluating its benefits for patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA). Methods. We searched three English and four Chinese databases...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics