Practicing provider-initiated HIV testing in high prevalence settings: consent concerns and missed preventive opportunities

Njeru, Mercy K.; Blystad, Astrid; Shayo, Elizabeth H.; Nyamongo, Isaac K.; Fylkesnes, Knut
January 2011
BMC Health Services Research;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p87
Academic Journal
Background: Counselling is considered a prerequisite for the proper handling of testing and for ensuring effective HIV preventive efforts. HIV testing services have recently been scaled up substantially with a particular focus on provider-initiated models. Increasing HIV test rates have been attributed to the rapid scale-up of the providerinitiated testing model, but there is limited documentation of experiences with this new service model. The aim of this study was to determine the use of different types of HIV testing services and to investigate perceptions and experiences of these services with a particular emphasis on the provider initiated testing in three selected districts in Kenya, Tanzania, and, Zambia. Methods: A concurrent triangulation mixed methods design was applied using quantitative and qualitative approaches. A population-based survey was conducted among adults in the three study districts, and qualitative data were obtained from 34 focus group discussions and 18 in-depth interviews. The data originates from the ongoing EU funded research project "REsponse to ACountable Priority Setting for Trust in Health Systems" (REACT) implemented in the three countries which has a research component linked to HIV and testing, and from an additional study focusing on HIV testing, counselling perceptions and experiences in Kenya. Results: Proportions of the population formerly tested for HIV differed sharply between the study districts and particularly among women (54% Malindi, 34% Kapiri Mposhi and 27% Mbarali) (p < 0.001). Women were much more likely to be tested than men in the districts that had scaled-up programmes for preventing mother to child transmission of HIV (PMTCT). Only minor gender differences appeared for voluntary counselling and testing. In places where, the provider-initiated model in PMTCT programmes had been rolled out extensively testing was accompanied by very limited pre- and post-test counselling and by a related neglect of preventative measures. Informants expressed frustration related to their experienced inability to 'opt-out' or decline from the providerinitiated HIV testing services. Conclusion: Counselling emerged as a highly valued process during HIV testing. However, counselling efforts were limited in the implementation of the provider-initiated opt-out HIV testing model. The approach was moreover not perceived as voluntary. This raises serious ethical concerns and implies missed preventive opportunities inherent in the counselling concept. Moreover, implementation of the new testing approach seem to add a burden to pregnant women as disproportionate numbers of women get to know their HIV status, reveal their HIV status to their spouse and recruit their spouses to go for a test. We argue that there is an urgent need to reconsider the manner in which the provider initiated HIV testing model is implemented in order to protect the client's autonomy and to maximise access to HIV prevention.


Related Articles

  • HIV exceptionalism and ethical concerns surrounding HIV testing. O'HARA, KEVIN MICHAEL // JAAPA: Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants (;Apr2011, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p66 

    An essay is presented on the ethical concerns regarding consent for HIV antibody testing and introduces the concept of HIV exceptionalism. The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) changes the HIV testing policy to enhance the numbers tested. The author notes that mandatory counselling...

  • Assessment of HIV Testing of Urban Injection Drug Users: Implications for Expansion of HIV Testing and Prevention Efforts. Heimer, Robert; Grau, Lauretta E.; Khoshnood, Kaveh; Curtin, Erin; Singer, Merrill // American Journal of Public Health;Jan2007, Vol. 97 Issue 1, p110 

    Objectives. We sought to determine the extent of HIV testing among urban injection drug users (IDUs) to assess whether an expansion of targeted testing programs would be consistent with national goals to identify previously undetected infections. Methods. IDUs in 5 US cities (Oakland, Calif;...

  • Provider and practice characteristics associated with use of rapid HIV Testing by general internists. Bass, Michael; Korthuis, P.; Cofrancesco, Joseph; Berkenblit, Gail; Sullivan, Lynn; Asch, Steve; Bashook, Philip; Edison, Marcia; Sosman, James; Cook, Robert; Bass, Michael G; Korthuis, P Todd; Cofrancesco, Joseph Jr; Berkenblit, Gail V; Sullivan, Lynn E; Asch, Steve M; Bashook, Philip G; Sosman, James M; Cook, Robert L // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Nov2011, Vol. 26 Issue 11, p1258 

    Background: Rapid HIV testing could increase routine HIV testing. Most previous studies of rapid testing were conducted in acute care settings, and few described the primary care providers' perspective.Objective: To identify characteristics of general internal medicine...

  • Star POWER. Warren, Tammy // Marketing Health Services;Summer2010, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p16 

    The article features renowned basketball player Earvin "Magic" Johnson and his Magic Johnson Foundation that leverages celebrity appeal to fight HIV/AIDS. It relates that Magic Johnson was diagnosed with HIV in 1991 and from then on became active in an ongoing awareness campaign on behalf of his...

  • IN BRIEF.  // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;9/24/2011, Vol. 343 Issue 7824, p606 

    The article offers world news briefs highlighting issues such as human rights on violations in Yemen, HIV prevention trial in Africa, and the trial of health care professionals.

  • Identifying practices and strategies to increase HIV testing among Haitian migrant communities. Santiago, Jonathan; Adrien, A.; Spigner, C.; Katz, A. // Retrovirology;2010 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, p1 

    An abstract of the article "Identifying Practices and Strategies to Increase HIV Testing Among Haitian Migrant Communities," by Jonathan Santiago, A. Adrien, C. Spigner and A. Katz is presented.

  • An analysis of non response in HIV testing in India: evidences from National Family Health Survey-3. Singh, Shri Kant // Retrovirology;2010 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, p1 

    An abstract of the article " An analysis of non response in HIV testing in India: evidences from National Family Health Survey-3," by Kant Singh is presented.

  • Increased antenatal HIV testing among rural pregnant women: a community-based HIV prevention services program in rural Maharashtra, India. Dyalchand, Ashok; Sinha, Gita // Retrovirology;2010 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, p1 

    An abstract of the article "Increased Antenatal HIV Testing Among Rural Pregnant Women: A Community-Based HIV Prevention Services Program in Rural Maharashtra, India," by Ashok Dyalchand and Gita Sinha is presented.

  • Development of a test system for simultaneous detection of HIV RNA and Hepatitis C virus (HCV) and DNA of Hepatitis B virus (HBV) in blood samples. Shahrokhi, Nader; Hajia, Masoud; Shahrokhi, Maysam; Abbasi, Foroozan; Farzaneh-khah, Mohamad // Retrovirology;2010 Supplement 1, Vol. 7, p1 

    An abstract of the article "Development of a Test System for Simultaneous Detection of HIV RNA and Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) and DNA of Hepatitis B Virus (HBV) in Blood Samples," by Nader Shahrokhi, Masoud Hajia, Maysam Shahrokhi, Foroozan Abbasi and Mohamad Farzaneh-Khah is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics