Uncertainty, the problem of order, and markets: a critique of Beckert, Theory and Society, May 2009

Gemici, Kurtuluş
January 2012
Theory & Society;Jan2012, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p107
Academic Journal
Jens Beckert's 2009 article on the constitution and dynamics of markets is a bold attempt to define a novel research agenda. Deeming uncertainty and coordination essential for the constitution of social action in markets, Beckert proposes a framework centered on the resolution of three coordination problems: valuation, cooperation, and competition. The empirical study of these three coordination problems has the potential to contribute considerably to the sociological analysis of markets. However, the assertion that such a theoretical vantage point can explain the constitution and dynamics of markets is not compelling because it (1) conflates social interaction with social structures, (2) fails to address power relations, institutions, and macro-level structures, and (3) neglects the historically contingent and socially contested nature of markets themselves. The present article shows that these three pitfalls are the result of starting from the problem of order and building upon uncertainty as the basis of action in markets, lending the suggested framework a methodologically individualist bent. Therefore, Beckert's suggested framework is in danger of mystifying the very power relations, institutions, and macro-level structures that are at the heart of the constitution and dynamics of markets.


Related Articles

  • The 'social order of markets' approach: a reply to KurtuluÅŸ Gemici. Beckert, Jens // Theory & Society;Jan2012, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p119 

    This is a detailed reply to KurtuluÅŸ Gemici's article, in this issue of Theory and Society, 'Uncertainty, the problem of order, and markets: a critique of Beckert, Theory and Society, May 2009.'

  • Centralized power and divided space: 'Fractured regions' in the Israeli 'ethnocracy'. Yiftachel, Oren // GeoJournal;Mar2001, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p283 

    Uses a critical political-geographical perspective to account for the high centrality of power found in Israel. Territorial fracturing of the main social and ethnic groups in Israel/Palestine; Prevention of the emergence of sustained and effective inter-ethnic pressure for regional devolution;...

  • Distribution and Disruption. Jenkins, Davis // Basic Income Studies;Dec2015, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p257 

    Iris Marion Young accuses theories of justice within the distributive paradigm of attending exclusively to the question of the 'morally proper distribution of benefits and burdens among society's members'. This comes at the cost of a deeper analysis of politics, detracting from the workings of...

  • Introduction: Legitimating Ideologies. Tyler, Tom R. // Social Justice Research;Sep2005, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p211 

    This special issue focuses upon the creation, maintenance, and use of legitimating ideologies by authorities, institutions, and societies. Such ideologies provide normative justifications for existing policies and practices through which they are seen as appropriate, reasonable, and fair and...

  • Gender, Power, and Ancient Females in Hainan. HUANG Shuyao // Society: Chinese Journal of Sociology / Shehui;2012, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p204 

    Construction of social gender has become an important area in observing and analyzing social structure. From this perspective to review the interaction between Han people and Li people in the history of Hainan Island, we find that this interaction is in essence a collision of two different...

  • MASS MEDIA AND POST-MODERN SOCIETY. Dulčić, Dunja // Media, Culture & Public Relations;ozu2014, Vol. 5 Issue 1, pIV 

    All the way trough the history of pre modern and post modern society, the media has been communication tools which were adapting itselves to the social changes, but have always kept their function to maintain the given structure of social power. Nowadays when the society is in transition, media...

  • Communications.  // American Historical Review;Feb81, Vol. 86 Issue 1, p243 

    Presents letters to the editor published in the February 1981 issue of the journal 'American Historical Review.' Analysis of the social and political structure of the antebellum North and South; Discussion on politics and power of planters in the Southern U.S.

  • THE INEVITABILITY OF ENDURING HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL PATTERNS: THE PARADOX OF DECENTRALIZATION EFFORTS IN UKRAINE. Kovryga, Oleksandr V.; Nickel, Patricia Mooney // Administrative Theory & Praxis (Administrative Theory & Praxis);Dec2004, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p609 

    Since Ukraine's independence in 1991, Western governments, international tribunals, and global financial organizations have descended with billions of dollars and thousands of consultants, all directly or indirectly dedicated to decentralization efforts. These monies, as well as the benefits of...

  • STRUCTURE, ACTION, AND OUTCOMES: THE DYNAMICS OF POWER IN SOCIAL EXCHANGE. Molm, Linda D. // American Sociological Review;Jun90, Vol. 55 Issue 3, p427 

    Two levels of power -- the structure of power in exchange networks, and the strategic use of power resources by actors -- affect the frequency and distribution of exchange outcomes. Theories of power and exchange suggest alternative hypotheses about how structural power and strategic action are...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics