The Ethics of Moral Compromise for Stem Cell Research Policy

Master, Zubin; Crozier, G.
March 2012
Health Care Analysis;Mar2012, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p50
Academic Journal
In the US, stem cell research is at a moral impasse-many see this research as ethically mandated due to its potential for ameliorating major diseases, while others see this research as ethically impermissible because it typically involves the destruction of embryos and use of ova from women. Because their creation does not require embryos or ova, induced pluripotent stem cells offer the most promising path for addressing the main ethical objections to stem cell research; however, this technology is still in development. In order for scientists to advance induced pluripotent stem cell research to a point of translational readiness, they must continue to use ova and embryos in the interim. How then are we to ethically move forward with stem cell research? We argue that there is personal integrity and value in adopting a 'moral compromise' as a means for moving past the moral impasse in stem cell research. In a moral compromise, each party concedes part of their desired outcome in order to engage in a process that respects the values and desires of all parties equitably. Whereas some contend that moral compromise in stem cell research necessarily involves self-contradiction or loss of personal integrity, we argue that in the US context, stem cell research satisfies many of the key pre-conditions of an effective moral compromise. To illustrate our point, we offer a model solution wherein eggs and embryos are temporarily used until non-egg and non-embryonic sources of pluripotent stem cells are developed to a state of translational readiness.


Related Articles

  • Regulating stem cell research in Europe by the back door. Holm, S. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2003, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p203 

    Comments on the issue on regulating stem cell research in Europe. Draft directive on setting standards of quality and safety of the research prepared by the European Commission; Ethical status of human embryonic stem cells; Comparison of the European Commission and European Parliament texts. ...

  • What's in a name? Embryos, entities, and ANTities in the stem cell debate. Devolder, K. // Journal of Medical Ethics;Jan2006, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p43 

    This paper discusses two proposals to the US President's Council on Bioethics that try to overcome the issue of killing embryos in embryonic stem (ES) cell research and argues that neither of them can hold good as a compromise solution. The author argues that (1) the groups of people for which...

  • Stem-Cell Success.  // National Review;12/17/2007, Vol. 59 Issue 23, p14 

    An editorial is presented, commenting on developments in stem-cell biotechnology. Scientists succeeded in turning regular human skin cells into "pluripotent" stem cells, which can be turned into other types of cells and were previously only available in the form of embryonic stem cells. The...

  • Stem cells show their muscle.  // Nature Neuroscience;Oct2000, Vol. 3 Issue 10, p961 

    Editorial. Explores the medical ethics of human stem cell research. Guidelines that would permit research on human embryonic stem cells; Molecular identity of signals inducing muscle formation; Limits to stem cell plasticity.

  • A Review of the National Institute of Health's 'Guidelines for Research Using Human Pluripotent Stem Cells'  // Issues in Law & Medicine;Spring2002, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p293 

    Focuses on implications of the 'Guidelines for Research Using Human Pluripotent Stem Cell' for research ethics in the U.S. Location of adult stem cells; Reproduction of the cells; Effect of cell pluripotency on stem cell harvesting in human.

  • Stem cells rise in the East. Dennis, Carina // Nature;9/26/2002, Vol. 419 Issue 6905, p334 

    Reports on stem cell research in China. Government support for the research; Attempts to China to establish itself as a world-class presence in the field; Details of stem-cell research conducted by teams led by Guangxiu Lu and Huizhen Sheng; Ethical issues related to embryonic stem-cell research.

  • Stem cell research: The India perspective. Mittal, Sanjay // Perspectives in Clinical Research;Jan-Mar2013, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p105 

    The article explores stem cell research in India in relation to global interest in stem cell therapy. A background on the discovery of human stem cells and their potential for treating diseases is provided. India has drafted policies and guidelines to improve its global competitiveness in the...

  • Stem Cell Battles Are Far From Over. Cook, Michael // Australasian Science;Jul/Aug2011, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p48 

    The article enumerates the ethical issues associated with the use of induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells. According to the author, despite some scientists' claim that it is more ethical to conduct studies on iPS cells rather than human embryonic stem cells, the former still has some problematic...

  • Foresight, Insight, Oversight. White, Gladys B. // Hastings Center Report;Mar/Apr99, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p41 

    Focuses on the human stem cell research conducted in the United States. Ethical guidelines for all researchers in the area; How individual research protocols be reviewed and approved; Extent of the involvement of infertility treatment centers in human stem cell research.


Other Topics