The biomedical doctorate in the contemporary university: education or training and why it matters

Kemp, Matthew; Newnham, John; Chapman, Elaine
May 2012
Higher Education (00181560);May2012, Vol. 63 Issue 5, p631
Academic Journal
The form and function(s) of doctoral education continue to be a subject of much debate by stakeholders internal and external to the university. Notable concerns driving this debate derive from a seemingly discursive array of factors including increasing student numbers, increased understanding of the economic value of doctoral graduates, capitalisation of the academic market and a focus on allocating funding using ostensibly narrow, arbitrary measures of 'program success' such as completion rates/time to completion, all framed by a wider debate regarding precisely what constitutes valid knowledge in contemporary society. Within the university, the biomedical sciences are one area of scholarship undergoing rapid change in this respect. One of the salient outcomes of these internal and external dialogues is the apparent transition of biomedical doctoral education towards a 'training model' that places increasing emphasis on rapid completion and the generation of 'industry ready graduates'; a transition that is, potentially, occurring at the expense of the edifying and transformative aspects of biomedical doctoral education. Focusing on the effects of academic capitalisation, this paper draws on data from Australia and Europe to examine the drivers and potential effect(s) of this shift on contemporary doctoral education in the biomedical sciences. This paper acknowledges the potential benefit of contemporary developments whilst simultaneously concluding that by progressing too far towards a quantitatively assessed, industry-driven training model we risk eliminating the intellectual and societal transforming aspects of biomedical doctoral education that make graduates increasingly valuable to our economy and, just as importantly, to our society as a whole.


Related Articles

  • Education: The PhD factory. Cyranoski, David; Gilbert, Natasha; Ledford, Heidi; Nayar, Anjali; Yahia, Mohammed // Nature;4/21/2011, Vol. 472 Issue 7343, p276 

    The article offers the author's insights on the increase of numbers of science doctorates worldwide, in which it grew for about 40% of 34,000 within 1998 and 2008. The author states that the huge growth of doctoral degree shows no decelerating regardless of the little chance a graduate may get...

  • Doctoral Pedagogy: What Do International PhD Students in Australia Think About It? Cotterall, Sara // Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities;Sep2011, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p521 

    Despite recent research, doctoral pedagogy remains something of a 'black box'. This article explores the 'mysterious activity' (Green, 2005, p. 151) which transforms research apprentices into licensed scholars by drawing on longitudinal interviews with six graduate students who travelled to...

  • EL DOCTORADO EN EDUCACIÓN: UN EJEMPLO DE DESREGULACIÓN EN EL CAMPO DE LA EDUCACIÓN SUPERIOR EN CHILE. Corvalán, Javier; Falabella, Alejandra; Rojas, María Teresa // Calidad en la Educación;2011, Issue 34, p15 

    This paper presents the results of a study about the situation of the Doctoral Programs in Education in Chile. The study is aimed to characterize the provision of these Doctoral Programs and raise the main demands by employers, as well as doctoral students. It is based upon documents and online...

  • Connecting practice, theory and method: Supporting professional doctoral students in developing conceptual frameworks. Kumar, Swapna; Antonenko, Pavlo // TechTrends: Linking Research & Practice to Improve Learning;Jul2014, Vol. 58 Issue 4, p54 

    From an instrumental view, conceptual frameworks that are carefully assembled from existing literature in Educational Technology and related disciplines can help students structure all aspects of inquiry. In this article we detail how the development of a conceptual framework that connects...

  • Focus and Delivery of Doctoral Programs in Educational Leadership. Topolka-Jorissen, Kathleen; Yinying Wang // International Journal of Educational Reform;Summer2015, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p212 

    The purpose of this study was to present the current status of program focus and delivery of doctoral-level educational leadership programs in the United States. Drawing on a 2011 national survey of educational leadership doctoral programs in 103 institutions, this study describes the...

  • Examining the Status of Partnerships in University Educational Leadership Doctoral Programs. Reames, Ellen H.; Kochan, Frances // International Journal of Educational Reform;Summer2015, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p233 

    While there are consistent calls for educational leadership programs in higher education to develop partnerships with varied gro ups, a review of the educational leadership literature reveals a consistent lack of published manuscripts specifically focused on partnerships, particularly in...

  • Developing Researchers in Education through A Doctoral Programme: A Challenge in the Context of Pakistan. Halai, Nelofer // Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities;Sep2011, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p509 

    This is a reflective paper on the challenges of developing educational researchers through doctoral education in the context of Pakistan. These challenges are discussed from the perspective of the PhD programme in education offered by the Institute for Educational Development of the Aga Khan...

  • Perceptions of the Doctorate in Broad Education for Business. Martin, Ken // Insights to a Changing World Journal;2012, Issue 3, p141 

    This thought exchange drawn from qualitative research focuses on educators' important viewpoints concerning the nature and characteristics of graduate study for the doctoral degree. The variety of doctoral degrees and the special needs of the possessors of these are important. Satisfying the...

  • A Doctoral Student's Reflection on Education. Aleisa, Majed; Miller, Melinda // National Teacher Education Journal;Spring2015, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p39 

    A doctoral student from Saudi Arabia reflects on his education in Saudi Arabia and the information about education he has learned through his Doctorate in Literacy program in the United States. He describes what education was like for him as a youngster, and what he wants for his students. He...

  • The Doctorate in Physical Education Teacher Education in the 21st Century: Contexts and Challenges. Ward, Phillip; Sutherland, Sue; Woods, Marianne L.; Boyce, B. Ann; Karp, Grace Goc; Judd, Michael; Parker, Melissa; Rikard, G. Linda; Sinclair, Christina // Journal of Teaching in Physical Education;Apr2011, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p178 

    In this paper, we situate the findings from the studies in this thematic issue within the current policy environment that influences the status, rankings, and funding contexts for doctoral programs in Physical Education Teacher Education within and across institutions. We identify common...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics