An Exploration of Upper-intermediate Iranian EFL learners' Perception of Politeness Strategies and Power Relation in Disagreement

Niroomand, Masoumeh
October 2012
English Language Teaching;Oct2012, Vol. 5 Issue 10, p180
Academic Journal
The present study was designed to examine the ways power relations influence politeness strategies in disagreement. The study was an attempt to find out whether different power status of people influence the the choice of appropriate politeness strategies and speech act of disagreement by Iranian EFL learners, in a university setting. A Discourse Completion Test (DCT) was utilized to elicit the required data. The sample included 20 Iranian upper-intermediate EFL learners who were selected based on their scores on a proficiency test. The DTC consists of five scenarios in which the subjects are expected to disagree with two higher statuses and two with peers and one with a lower status. Selection of disagreement situations in DCT was based on relative power and status of people. The main frameworks used for analyzing data were the taxonomy from Muntigl and Turnbull (1995) for counting and analyzing the utterances of disagreement and Brown and Levinson' (1987) theory of politeness. It was found that EFL learners employ different kind of politeness strategies in performing this face threatening speech act. When performing the speech act of disagreement, they used more direct and bald on record strategies. The findings of this study provide some evidences for the relation between the type and frequency of disagreement and choice of politeness strategies associated with people with different power status. It concludes by arguing that the results can be closely related with learning contexts and textbook contents and some suggestions were put forward regarding the issue. It is also hoped that the findings of this study will provide some worthwhile knowledge into the teaching and training of communication skills in EFL courses. Furthermore, this study may reveal some cultural differences between Iranian societies and others.


Related Articles

  • A Study of the effects of explicit and implicit teachings on developing Chinese EFL learners' pragmatic competence. Jiemin Bu // International Journal of Language Studies;Jul2012, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p57 

    The role of teaching to develop learners' pragmatic competence in both second and foreign language contexts has recently motivated a great deal of research. This paper aims to show whether learners' pragmatic competence of 'suggesting speech act' improves after pragmatic language teaching, and...

  • The Impact of Instruction on Iranian Intermediate EFL Learners' Productvion of Requests in English. Dastjerdi, Hossein Vahid; Rezvani, Ehsan // Journal of Language Teaching & Research;Nov2010, Vol. 1 Issue 6, p782 

    The present study investigated the extent to which two instructional paradigms—explicit vs. implicit instruction—affect learners’ ability to use the speech act of request in English. Ninety homogenous adult Iranian intermediate EFL learners attending a language school in...

  • The Effects of Explicit/Implicit Instruction and Feedback on the Development of Persian EFL Learners' Pragmatic Competence in Suggestion Structures. Salemi, Azin; Rabiee, Mitra; Ketabi, Saeed // Journal of Language Teaching & Research;Jan2012, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p188 

    To date, a number of studies have investigated the speech act of suggestion. However, most of these studies have focused on the production - a sociolinguistic perspective - rather than the acquisition of this speech act. The study reported in this article aimed to compare the effects of implicit...

  • TEACHERS' CRITERIA VERSUS STUDENTS' CRITERIA IN SPEECH ACT RATING. Fat'hi, Jalil; Parsa, Katayoun; Shahmirzadi, Niloufar // Modern Journal of Language Teaching Methods;Sep2015, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p147 

    Testing and assessment issues concerning second language pragmatic competence are unchartered territories in the world of interlanguage pragmatics. However, tests which have been employed to explore learners' sociopragmatic and pragmalinguistic abilities have overwhelmingly drawn upon the speech...

  • English Speech Act Realization of "Refusals" Among Iranian EFL Learners. Sahragard, Rahman; Javanmardi, Fatemeh // Cross-Cultural Communication;2011, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p181 

    Speech act of refusal has been one of the important topics in the discourse pragmatic research over the past few decades. In fact, pragmatics plays a very important role in the process of communication and the action of refusal is performed in our daily lives and in a variety of situations....

  • Pragmatic Development of Chinese EFL LearnersßœA Study on FL Suggestions. Tongqing Gu // English Language Teaching;Apr2014, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p147 

    While the number of studies on the pragmatic development of nonnative English speakers has been increasing, surprisingly little research has been conducted on the development of the ability of foreign language learners to perform the suggestion speech act, with even less taking Chinese EFL...

  • The Effect of Meta pragmatic Instructions on the Interpretation and Use of Apology Speech Acts of English as a Foreign Language Learner (EFL) at Intermediate Level. Bagheri, Morteza; Hamrang, Atefeh // International Journal of Social Sciences & Education;2013, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p964 

    This study dealt with the application of the pragmatics research to EFL teaching. The study explored the effect of explicit metapragmatic instructions on the interpretation and use of apology speech acts of intermediate EFL students. The speech act of apologizing was selected as the focus of...

  • Adolescent pragmatic skills: A comparison of Latino students in English as a second language... Brice, Alejandro; Montgomery, Judy // Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools;Jan96, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p68 

    Compares the pragmatic performance of students from students receiving English as a second language instruction versus bilingual students receiving speech-language therapy. Definition of pragmatics; Relationship between linguistic knowledge and principles of governing language use; Classroom...

  • Developing a Pragmatics Test for Arabic ESL Learners. Matsugu, Sawako // Arab World English Journal;2014, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p1 

    The present study replicated Liu's (2007) study on validating a multiple-choice discourse completion test (MCDCT) for measuring second language (L2) pragmatics. In order to investigate whether his validation methods can be applied to a different speech act with learners from a different...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics