How Effective are National and EU Policies in the Area of Forced Migration?

Thielemann, Eiko R.
December 2012
Refugee Survey Quarterly;Dec2012, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p21
Academic Journal
Large numbers of displaced persons and their highly unequal distribution constitute a significant challenge for policy-makers. Questions about the determinants of such flows and how governments can manage them have been a long-standing concern of the academic literature. It has sometimes been argued that if a State’s reception burden is large, then that country’s policies are overly generous relative to other destination countries. However, this article shows that this argument risks overestimating the link between the policies of destination countries and the direction and size of migration flows. It argues that the effectiveness of both unilateral and multilateral policies to regulate forced migration flows is limited. To support this argument, the article reviews the literature on the role of push–pull factors of international migration and provides both qualitative and quantitative empirical data to analyse the impact and effectiveness of national and international regulatory initiatives in this field. Particular attention will be placed on the role of regional cooperation in the context of the highly institutionalized asylum and refugee policy framework of the European Union.


Related Articles

  • VABATAHTLIK JA SUNNIVIISILINE RÄNNE EESTI MIGRATSIOONILOOS. Jürgenson, Aivar; Kumer-Haukanõmm, Kaja; Tuisk, Astrid // Acta Historica Tallinnensia;2011, Issue 17, p3 

    The present issue of Acta Historica Tallinnensia is a compilation of papers from historians, ethnologists and folklorists who presented their work at the conference "Voluntary and forced migration in the Estonian migration history" held in Tallinn University on 12-13 October 2010. At the...

  • Malaysia and forced migration. Idris, Arzura // Intellectual Discourse;2012, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p31 

    This paper analyzes the phenomenon of "forced migration" in Malaysia. It examines the nature of forced migration, the challenges faced by Malaysia, the policy responses and their impact on the country and upon the forced migrants. It considers forced migration as an event hosting multifaceted...

  • A new area classification for understanding internal migration in Britain. Dennett, Adam; Stillwell, John // Population Trends;Autumn2011, Vol. 145, p146 

    This article details the development of a new area classification for Britain based on internal migration variables taken from the 2001 Census. An explanation of why general-purpose area classifications already in existence are not ideal for internal migration analysis is provided, before an...

  • Refugiados y desplazados forzados. Categorías de la migración forzada creadas como medidas de contención a las migraciones no deseadas. Andrea Posada, Paola // Estudios Politicos (01215167);jul-dic2009, Issue 35, p131 

    This article aims to present the way in which the legal categories of "refugees" and "displaced persons" arise from the interest of the international community to control unwanted migration. In order to do so, an analytical argument is used based on the global system of migration proposed by...

  • Les dynamiques de la migration contrainte: suivons le troupeau! Kaizen, Julie // Journal of International Migration & Integration;Winter2005, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p29 

    This paper contributes to the existing literature on forced migration by presenting a dynamic model of factors influencing the choice of the destination country. The reasons usually presented (colonial bonds, geographical proximity) are in certain cases unable to provide a satisfactory...

  • Migration. Aleshkovsky, I. A.; Iontsev, V. A.; Ivakhnyuk, I. // Value Inquiry Book Series;2014, Vol. 276, p333 

    The article discusses the concept of migration which refers to the movement of people across boundaries of any territories. Topics discussed include the impact of internal migration and international migration on population, nonreturnable and returnable migration, factors that resulted to forced...

  • Rhetorical Dimensions of Forced Migration: Using Transnational Feminist Theory to Make Rhetoric Relevant. McKinnon, Sara // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    The paper offers rhetorical criticism as a useful method to study contexts and experiences of forced migration. Rhetorical research is often critiqued for being too disembodied, too bound in the text to be useful to examine the nuanced dynamics of forced migration contexts. And yet, I argue here...

  • Resisting Distalization? Malta and Cyprus’ influence on EU Migration and Asylum Policies. Mainwaring, Cetta // Refugee Survey Quarterly;Dec2012, Vol. 31 Issue 4, p38 

    This article examines the role that Malta and the Republic of Cyprus (RoC) have played within the European Union in developing regional responses to irregular migration since 2004. It briefly compares their responses to those of other, larger southern Member States and traces the instances where...

  • Globalization and Transnational Migration: The Malaysian State's Response to Voluntary and Forced Migration. Ramasamy, P. // Asian & Pacific Migration Journal (Scalabrini Migration Center);2006, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p137 

    The ability of nation-states to control the flow of transnational migrants has been affected by globalization. The imposition of strict immigration controls reflects the contradictory nature of states' responses to ad dress economic and social problems. Despite the rhetoric of strict immigration...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics