Circularity in the conditional analysis of phenomenal concepts

Yetter-Chappell, Helen
September 2013
Philosophical Studies;Sep2013, Vol. 165 Issue 2, p553
Academic Journal
The conditional analysis of phenomenal concepts purports to give physicalists a way of understanding phenomenal concepts that will allow them to (1) accept the zombie intuition, (2) accept that conceivability is generally a good guide to possibility, and yet (3) reject the conclusion that zombies are metaphysically possible. It does this by positing that whether phenomenal concepts refer to physical or nonphysical states depends on what the actual world is like. In this paper, I offer support for the Chalmers/Alter objection that the conditional analysis fails to accommodate the true zombie intuition, and develop a new and far more powerful argument against the conditional analysis. I argue that, as stated, the conditional analysis is radically incomplete. But when fully fleshed out, the analysis becomes viciously circular. The only way to avoid this circularity is to adopt a species of analytic functionalism, on which it's a priori that phenomenal concepts refer to the state (perhaps physical, perhaps nonphysical) that actually plays so-and-so functional role. While this rigidified analytic functionalism is coherent, it is highly unattractive, running contrary to both the intuitions that motivate functionalism and the intuitions that motivated the conditional analysis.


Related Articles

  • Are (Some) Qualophiles Contradicting Themselves? Campbell, Neil // International Journal of the Humanities;2011, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p75 

    I explore three qualia-based objections to physicalism (spectrum inversion, the knowledge argument, and the appeal to the possibility of zombies) and argue that certain versions of these arguments are deeply inconsistent. The problem I identify is that in their attempt to address certain...

  • THE ANTI-ZOMBIE ARGUMENT. Frankish, Keith // Philosophical Quarterly;Oct2007, Vol. 57 Issue 229, p650 

    The zombie argument has come to occupy a central role in the case for a non-physicalist theory of consciousness. I seek to turn the tables on ‘zombists’ by showing that a parallel argument can be run for physicalism. This argument invokes anti-zombies, purely physical creatures...

  • The inconceivability of zombies. Kirk, Robert // Philosophical Studies;May2008, Vol. 139 Issue 1, p73 

    If zombies were conceivable in the sense relevant to the �conceivability argument� against physicalism, a certain epiphenomenalistic conception of consciousness�the �e-qualia story��would also be conceivable. But (it is argued) the e-qualia story is not conceivable...

  • Exemplarization: a solution to the problem of consciousness? Fürst, Martina // Philosophical Studies;Oct2012, Vol. 161 Issue 1, p141 

    In recent publications, Keith Lehrer developed the intriguing idea of a special mental process- exemplarization-and applied it in a sophisticated manner to different phenomena such as intentionality, representation of the self, the knowledge of ineffable content (of art works) and the problem of...

  • Conceivability, possibility and physicalism. Worley, S. // Analysis;Jan2003, Vol. 63 Issue 1, p15 

    Analyzes the conceivability of zombies and physicalism. Arguments for the conceivability of zombies; Comments on the non-conceivability of physicalism.

  • The Knowledge Intuition and the Ability Hypothesis. Ren, Huiming // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Jun2012, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p313 

    ABSTRACT: I argue that the Ability Hypothesis cannot really accommodate the knowledge intuition that drives the knowledge argument and therefore fails to defend physicalism. When the thought experiment is run with, instead of Mary, an advanced robot Rosemary, for whom there presumably is no...

  • Physicalism and phenomenal concepts. Demircioglu, Erhan // Philosophical Studies;Aug2013, Vol. 165 Issue 1, p257 

    Frank Jackson's famous Knowledge Argument moves from the premise that complete physical knowledge is not complete knowledge about experiences to the falsity of physicalism. In recent years, a consensus has emerged that the credibility of this and other well-known anti-physicalist arguments can...

  • Consciousness and Conceivability. Hunter, David A. // Canadian Journal of Philosophy;Jun2003, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p285 

    Interprets the thesis 'Knowledge, Possibility and Consciousness,' by John Perry. Nature of conceivability of arguments; Qualitative aspects of conscious experiences; Concept of Antecedent Physicalism; Physicalist conception of qualia; Concept of epiphenomenalism; Interpretation of anti-physical...

  • Enlightening the Fully Informed. Pelczar, Michael // Philosophical Studies;Oct2005, Vol. 126 Issue 1, p29 

    This paper develops a response to the knowledge argument against physicalism. The response is both austere, in that it does not concede the existence of non-physical information (much less non-physical facts), and natural, in that it acknowledges the alethic character of phenomenal knowledge and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics