When and Why Usury Should be Prohibited

Mayer, Robert
September 2013
Journal of Business Ethics;Sep2013, Vol. 116 Issue 3, p513
Academic Journal
Usury ceilings seem indefensible. Their opponents insist these caps harm the consumers they are intended to help. Low ceilings are said to prevent the least advantaged agents from accessing legal credit and drive them into the black market, where prices are higher and collection methods are harsher. But in this paper, I challenge these arguments and show that the benefits of interest-rate limitations in the most expensive credit markets clearly outweigh the costs. The test case is payday lending. Deregulated pricing in this market produces negative externalities that justify usury restrictions. Unless prices are capped, the more solvent majority of borrowers is compelled to cross-subsidize the least solvent debtors, who have a high rate of default. Rationing the riskiest debtors out of this market by means of a moderate usury cap puts an end to this unfairness and produces fewer bad consequences than the advocates of deregulated pricing recognize. I argue that only an extreme principle like maximizing the minimum could justify a free market in payday credit.


Related Articles

  • B&C Default Risks Are Still 'Elevated'  // National Mortgage News;9/16/2002, Vol. 26 Issue 50, p37 

    Reports the heightened risk of default on nonprime credit quality loans in the U.S. Influence of economic condition on the increased risk; Disparity between the default risk index of 2001 and 2002; Deterioration in the credit quality of loans insured by the government.

  • Payday loans help to make ends meet. Compton, Ken // New Hampshire Business Review;7/6/2007, Vol. 29 Issue 14, p20 

    The author reflects on the use of payday loans to help make ends meet in the U.S. According to the author, payday advances are a valuable tool in customers' financial tool belt. The author said that many Americans turn to payday advance centers for a budgeting solution which large banks, credit...

  • OFT warns lenders on APR.  // Credit Management;Jul2000, p12 

    Reports on guidelines issued by Great Britain's Office of Fair Trading (OFT) regarding lenders' adherence to annual percentage rates (APR) when advertising credit. Reflection of the cost of payment protection insurance in the APR when it is a condition of the loan; Prosecution under Consumer...

  • Let's rein in 21st century loan sharks. Baird, Jonathan P. // New Hampshire Business Review;12/21/2007, Vol. 29 Issue 28, p29 

    The article offers information on the concept of payday lending in New Hampshire. Salary lending or loan sharking are characterized by lenders collecting the most money and reducing only little debt of clients who focuses on married white class employee. In addition, the concerns regarding...

  • Utilitarian usurers. Rogers, David; Hope, Philip // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;02/22/99, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p14 

    Reports on a Supreme Court decision on the right to levy late-payment penalties by utility companies. Reaction of Alberta water providers EPCOR and Enmax; How Toronto, Ontario businessman Gordon Garland realized that late charges could be illegal in some cases under the Canadian Criminal Code's...

  • Libertarian Paternalism, Information Production, and Financial Decision Making. Carlin, Bruce Ian; Gervais, Simon; Manso, Gustavo // Review of Financial Studies;Sep2013, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p2204 

    We develop a theoretical model to analyze the effects of libertarian paternalism on information production and financial decision making. Individuals in our model appreciate the information content of the recommendations made by a social planner. This affects their incentive to gather...

  • savings and credit. Bigda, Carolyn // Money;Dec2006, Vol. 35 Issue 12, p116 

    The article discusses the situation with savings and credit in the U.S., making predictions about 2007. Federal interest increases have been good for those who have money in savings, but bad for those who are in debt. The author advises the reader to buy a long-term CD, pay off all credit card...

  • Black, white and grey are the three colours of a free market. Ritson, Mark // Marketing (00253650);6/13/2002, p18 

    Focuses on the remarkable ways in which free markets tend to evolve. Attempt of marketers to restrict the distribution of products; Differences in the distribution channels between black, white and grey markets; Beauty and complexity of markets.

  • Regulating the Price of Consumer Credit. Wheatley, John J.; Gordon, Guy G. // Journal of Marketing;Oct1971, Vol. 35 Issue 4, p21 

    Laws to limit the rate of interest or service charges on consumer credit are presented as consumer protection devices on the grounds that credit grantors have an advantage over their customers. Opponents of such laws argue that they Impair the free market process, that consumers will have to pay...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics