The Role of the Philadelphia Convention in Constitutional Adjudication

Manning, John F.
November 2012
George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1753
Academic Journal
Max Farrand's Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 shed light on the intricacies of the debates of the framers over the text of the Constitution. They do not, however, provide authoritative evidence of constitutional meaning. The Philadelphia Convention, after all, was conducted in secret, and the ratifiers, operating in thirteen distinct conventions in culturally and politically diverse states, had no access to its notes. Attempts to glean original intent or meaning from the Records face even greater challenges than attempts to discern a single, collective legislative intent from pieces of legislative history. Yet the Records are not entirely without value in constitutional interpretation. This Article suggests that Farrand's Records serve to confirm something fundamental about the nature of the original Constitution itself--that its text is the product of a hardscrabble compromise, rather than a statesmanlike articulation of broad principle. In contrast with the "living Constitution" theory that the Court has, at times, endorsed, the Records demonstrate that the Constitution's details are not mere placeholders for broader principles; they reflect bargained-for policy decisions. Accordingly, any theory of interpretation that treats textual detail as a marker for broader principle violates the terms of the bargain upon which the framers--who were a veto gate in the process--allowed the document to go forward.


Related Articles

  • A Concise Guide to the Records of the Federal Constitutional Convention of 1787 as a Source of the Original Meaning of the U.S. Constitution. Maggs, Gregory E. // George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1707 

    Judges, lawyers, scholars, and others often cite the records of the Federal Constitutional Convention of 1787 as a source of the original meaning of the Constitution. This Article provides guidance regarding this practice. The Article describes the Convention and the records of the proceedings....

  • The Case for Original Intent. Greene, Jamal // George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1683 

    This Article seeks to situate the constitutional culture's heavy reliance on the Convention debates within an academic environment that is generally hostile to original intent arguments. The Article argues that intentionalist-friendly sources like the Convention records and The Federalist remain...

  • How Bad Were the Official Records of the Federal Convention? Bilder, Mary Sarah // George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1620 

    The official records of the Constitutional Convention of 1787 have been neglected and dismissed by scholars for the last century, largely to due to Max Farrand's criticisms of both the records and the man responsible for keeping them--Secretary of the Convention William Jackson. This Article...

  • THE COMMITTEE OF DETAIL. Ewald, William // Constitutional Commentary;Fall2012, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p197 

    The article analyzes the work of the Committee of Detail of Madison, Wisconsin. It states that the committee has bookkeeping contributions wherein it writes up decisions of the U.S. Constitutional Conventions. It further states that the committee has prepared drafts for various plans including...

  • The Effect (or Non-Effect) of Founders on the Supreme Court Bench. Marcus, Maeva // George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1794 

    Eleven of the first twelve Justices to serve on the Supreme Court participated in the creation and ratification of the Constitution. Their active participation in the constitutional process shaped their perspectives of both federal law and the Constitution. Through a series of examples, this...

  • THE POLITICS OF PRUDENCE. R. V. Y. // Modern Age;Winter2014, Vol. 56 Issue 1, p3 

    An introduction is presented that discusses issue articles on topics including conservative aspects of the U.S. Constitutional Convention, the views of philosopher Jürgen Habermas on the role of religion in society, and journalist H. L. Mencken's views on philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche.


    The article discusses the potential reformation of the U.S. Electoral College using a District-Popular plan as of September 2012, focusing on campaign financing, presidential elections, and the U.S. Constitution. It states that there have been several Electoral College-related legislative...

  • The Patriot King's American Friends. Buckley, F. H. // National Affairs;Winter2016, Vol. 26, p123 

    This article discusses the Philadelphia Convention held in 1787 when 55 delegates from 12 U.S. states assembled to frame a new Constitution. Topics covered include the serious impasses reached by delegates at some points during the convention, the notes of the framers' debates on the structure...

  • The Legal Counterrevolution: The Jurisprudence of Constitutional Reform in 1787. Knapp, Aaron T. // U.C. Davis Law Review;Jun2014, Vol. 47 Issue 5, p1859 

    The article offers information on the historical significance of legal counterrevolution jurisprudence against movement for constitutional reform in the U.S. Constitution in 1787. It discusses the positional change from coercion of arms to the coercion of law in 1787 . Topics also discussed...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics