Identity, Discourse, and Safety in a High School Discussion of Same-Sex Marriage

Beck, Terence A.
January 2013
Theory & Research in Social Education;2013, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Scholars have called for discussions of same-sex marriage in schools as one way of ending the curricular silence around lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and questioning (LGBTQ) people. Yet, concerns about how students might talk about LGBTQ people can contribute to teachers' reluctance to initiate such discussions. Queer theory suggests that discussions of same-sex marriage require students to negotiate high school cultures that often assume and enforce heterosexuality. Further, students are likely to draw on the larger societal debate, a debate that often characterizes LGBTQ people very differently (and often stereotypically). Informed by discourse analysis, the author examined one discussion of same-sex marriage in a high school classroom and considered the ways students managed both their arguments and their identities. He also examined students' arguments to see how they contest what it means to be LGBTQ. Results of the analysis suggest that the assumption of heterosexuality pervaded the same-sex marriage discussion and that student arguments tended to focus squarely on the nature of LGBTQ people. These findings suggest that romantic notions of classroom safety might be inadequate when discussing same-sex marriage and that teachers need to carefully consider issues of student identity and the discourses available to students before they introduce same-sex marriage as a controversial political issue discussion topic.


Related Articles

  • Local faith leaders speak out on marriage equality. Braatz, Rick // Gay & Lesbian Times;7/23/2009, Issue 1126, p10 

    The article reports on the discussion of the pro-GLBT faith leaders regarding their actions to support marriage equality during a religious-community forum at the Marriage of the Minds (MOM) building in Hillcrest, San Diego, California.

  • COMMUNITY FORUM TO TALK OF GAY MARRIAGE. Radosta, Jim; Krause, Timothy // Just Out;10/3/2003, Vol. 20 Issue 23, p8 

    Presents a forum about gay marriage at the First United Methodist Church in Portland, Oregon. Tactics planned by the gay community in addressing the issue.

  • Storm over Vermont.  // Advocate;02/29/2000, Issue 806, p16 

    Focuses on a forum on same-sex marriage in Vermont. State resident Lee Moffatt's support for same-sex marriage; Civil proceedings of the debate.

  • City hosts forum on domestic partner rights. Bajko, Matthew S. // Bay Area Reporter;2/5/2004, Vol. 34 Issue 6, p10 

    Reports on a forum sponsored by San Francisco, California, in February 2004 that invites domestic partners or same-sex couples thinking of entering into a domestic partnership to learn about new benefits the state and city will be offering to people in such relationships.

  • Conversation about equality. Colletta, Jen // Philadelphia Gay News;11/29/2013, Vol. 37 Issue 48, p12 

    The article offers information on a public forum that will held at the Greene Street Friends School (GSFS) on December 5, 2013 regarding Pennsylvania's ban on same-sex marriage.

  • Marriage forum.  // Bay Area Reporter;6/17/2004, Vol. 34 Issue 25, p4 

    Reports on the same-sex marriage forum participated in by gay people of color at the New College Theater in San Francisco, California.

  • HRC, GLAD and Bay Windows to stage forum on same-sex marriage. Epperly, Jeff // Bay Windows;2/17/2000, pN.PAG 

    Presents an overview of a public forum on same-sex marriage at the Boston Public Library in Massachusetts in February 2005. Participants in the event; Topics to be discussed.

  • Public Hearings Filled with Emotion.  // Just Out;4/2/2004, Vol. 21 Issue 11, p14 

    Reports that the Multnomah County Commission in Oregon held a series of public hearings to give citizens a chance to testify about same-sex marriage. Link between homosexually and AIDS; Marriage discrimination based on gender and sexual orientation; Charter amendment banning same-sex marriage.

  • Out of the Ordinary. Lewis, Helen // New Statesman;3/27/2015, Vol. 144 Issue 5255, p62 

    The author argues that it is important for college students and others to hear controversial ideas and the views of people who think differently from themselves, and expresses concern about efforts to prevent such exposure to a range of ideas, for example when student groups pressure a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics