The Proof of the Pudding?: A Case Study of an “At-Risk” Design-Based Inquiry Science Curriculum

Chue, Shien; Lee, Yew-Jin
December 2013
Research in Science Education;Dec2013, Vol. 43 Issue 6, p2431
Academic Journal
When students collaboratively design and build artifacts that require relevant understanding and application of science, many aspects of scientific literacy are developed. Design-based inquiry (DBI) is one such pedagogy that can serve these desired goals of science education well. Focusing on a Projectile Science curriculum previously found to be implemented with satisfactory fidelity, we investigate the many hidden challenges when using DBI with Grade 8 students from one school in Singapore. A case study method was used to analyze video recordings of DBI lessons conducted over 10 weeks, project presentations, and interviews to ascertain the opportunities for developing scientific literacy among participants. One critical factor that hindered learning was task selection by teachers, which emphasized generic scientific process skills over more important cognitive and epistemic learning goals. Teachers and students were also jointly engaged in forms of inquiry that underscored artifact completion over deeper conceptual and epistemic understanding of science. Our research surfaced two other confounding factors that undermined the curriculum; unanticipated teacher effects and the underestimation of the complexity of DBI and of inquiry science in general. Thus, even though motivated or experienced teachers can implement an inquiry science curriculum with good fidelity and enjoy school-wide support, these by themselves will not guarantee deep learning of scientific literacy in DBI. Recommendations are made for navigating the hands- and minds-on aspects of learning science that is an asset as well as inherent danger during DBI teaching.


Related Articles

  • Using Writing for Alternative Audiences in a College Integrated Science Course. McDermott, Mark; Kuhn, Mason // Journal of College Science Teaching;Sep/Oct2011, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p40 

    Two separate writing-to-learn activities in which students wrote to authentic audiences outside of the instructor were used in a college integrated science course, Science of Water For the first task, students were asked to write to fourth-grade students, and for the second, students were asked...

  • A Collaborative Approach for Elementary Science. Nelson, George D.; Landel, Carolyn C. // Educational Leadership;Dec2006/Jan2007, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p72 

    The article discusses methods to improve the instruction of science in elementary schools. The poor performance of U.S. students in science and mathematics illustrates the need to build a foundation of scientific learning in elementary school, which often greatly affects a student's academic...

  • changes in 2008.  // New Zealand Science Teacher;2008, Issue 117, p3 

    The article discusses the changes within the New Zealand Association of Science Educators (NZASE), particularly the instructional system of science education, in 2008. The implementation of the new science curriculum is one of the changes in NZASE that challenges science teachers on how to...

  • Better Late than Never. Bottinelli, Charles // Science & Children;Apr1999, Vol. 36 Issue 7, p8 

    This article presents the author's experience of teaching sixth-grade science students. One day, one of the students complained that the author made a mistake in grading his paper. In response he told a story regarding how a professor deducted three points from his score during a thermodynamics...

  • Message From the Executive Director: Working Toward the Next Generation of Science Standards. Eberle, Francis // NSTA Reports!;Mar2010, Vol. 21 Issue 7, p12 

    The article focuses on the effort of the National Science Teacher Association (NSTA) in working with science standards to address the challenges faced by states, school districts and teachers in the U.S. He cites NSTA's Science Anchors which provide answers to various questions regarding the...

  • IN PRAISE OF PERFORMANCE-BASED ASSESSMENTS: A teacher's outlook on testing is changed after students are assessed through hands-on tasks. Flynn, Lee-Ann // Science & Children;Apr/May2008, Vol. 45 Issue 8, p32 

    The article discusses the performance-based assessments that the author developed for second graders in the U.S. These assessments help students demonstrate what they know about a given topic and to give them an opportunity to better communicate with what they have learned. In addition, the...

  • AN INQUIRY SAFARI. Thomson, Norman; Chapman, Seri // Science Teacher;Dec2004, Vol. 71 Issue 10, p20 

    Provides details on the Virtual Gorilla Modeling Project that provides science teachers with the necessary knowledge and tools to help students gain an understanding of gorillas. Participation of teachers in a 10-day professional development workshop in which they explore the world of gorilla...

  • Reading Questions in Large-Lecture Courses. Offerdahl, Erika; Baldwin, Thomas; Elfring, Lisa; Vierling, Elizabeth; Ziegler, Miriam // Journal of College Science Teaching;Mar/Apr2008, Vol. 37 Issue 4, p43 

    In an effort to encourages students to read prior coming to class, instructors experiment with new instructional strategies. It is sometimes difficult to anticipate limitations of a strategy within particular classroom environments, or to predict positive side effects for students. This paper...

  • Editor's Note. Ohana, Chris // Science & Children;Oct2003, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p6 

    The article focuses on the exploration of different ways to integrate reading and literature with teaching science. Science can be inspiring and motivating. It takes advantage of natural curiosity and channels that curiosity into logical habits of mind that can transcend science. Science is used...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics