Faculty and student perceptions and behaviours related to information literacy: a pilot study using triangulation

Ganley, Barbara Jean; Gilbert, Amy; Rosario, Dianne
December 2013
Journal of Information Literacy;Dec2013, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p80
Academic Journal
This pilot study was developed to determine if the University's students were proficient in IL based on the requisite skills defined by ALA (2000), to define faculty and student perceptions and behaviours related to information literacy (IL) and to test an evaluation rubric using empirical inquiry and triangulated methods. Findings suggested that not all students (n=164) had satisfactory IL skills even at the senior student level. While 4th year college students (seniors n=91) fared better on an IL survey when compared to 1st year college students (freshmen n=53), analysis of the senior students' theses led researchers to believe that students were most likely not skilled in this area, and had an inflated opinion of their own IL abilities. Overall, students felt they were less IL challenged compared to the faculty's (n=55) observation of the IL challenges experienced by the students. Students' self-assessment of their literacy skills may have been coloured by the propensity of the faculty to over-edit students' papers rather than simply providing constructive feedback, thus altering the natural end result. These authors used a triangulated approach including thesis review, comparisons between student and faculty survey responses and comparison of findings from the theses and the student and faculty surveys. Findings and discussion of methodology will hopefully provide valuable lessons for those interested in assessing students' IL.


Related Articles

  • Faculty Perspectives on Information Literacy as a Student Learning Outcome. Saunders, Laura // Journal of Academic Librarianship;Jul2012, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p226 

    Information literacy is a popular and widely-written about topic in the literature of library information science, and is widely identified as an essential competency for college students. Nevertheless, recent research indicates that students largely lack the competencies associated with...

  • Those baffling Assignments. Badke, William // Online Searcher;May/Jun2014, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p71 

    The article presents a study that investigates the challenges and difficulties experienced by students in solving their school assignments in the U.S. Researchers found that 80% of students have trouble in determining what their teachers want when it comes to complying their research projects....

  • CHALLENGES IN SPREADING INFORMATION LITERACY AMONG STUDENTS. SHANTARAM, PRANESH // Indian Streams Research Journal;Dec2012, Vol. 2 Issue 11, Special section p1 

    Information unleashes our imagination and challenges our preconceptions and thereby provides us with a pathway to personal growth and fulfillment. In this information rich world, where the scope of available information appears limitless, there is a growing need for students to become critical...

  • University Education in Lithuania in the Context of Transformation. Andreev, D. A. // Russian Education & Society;Jun2008, Vol. 50 Issue 6, p67 

    The article discusses the context of transformation for university education in Lithuania. It states that, although the country is characterized by high indicators of formal education, it is ranked last place in terms of effectiveness from using education. The circumstance represents, for the...

  • Team Approach Boosts Research-Based Learning at UC Berkeley.  // Academic Leader;Oct2006, Vol. 22 Issue 10, p2 

    The article offers information about the Mellon Library/Faculty Fellows for Undergraduate Research, a four-year project at the University of California in Berkeley to incorporate research-based learning in undergraduate courses. The project uses a team approach to help faculty members each year...

  • infolit land. The Effect of Artificial Intelligence on the Future of Information Literacy. Badke, William // Online Searcher;Jul/Aug2015, Vol. 39 Issue 4, p71 

    The article discusses the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) and disintermediation on the future of information literacy. Topics discussed include disintermediation or abandonment of institutions with traditional structures bypassed for cheaper and faster access to information, reasons why...

  • What Students Should Know. Badke, William // Online;Mar/Apr2012, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p47 

    The article discusses the Ethnographic Research in Illinois Academic Libraries (ERIAL), a project which studied the library and research habits of higher education students in Chicago, Illinois. The results of the study revealed that only few students could create a good search. There is also a...

  • Untitled Image.  // Punch, or the London Charivari, Vol. 146, April 15, 1914;1/1/1914, p8 

    The article presents a statement from a professor to a newcomer in his class.

  • Dear Ms. CLIO.  // Clio;Feb75, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p295 

    The article presents answers to a question about the way by which a university teacher can address students and colleagues.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics