Probabilistic Risk Assessment for Six Vapour Intrusion Algorithms

Provoost, Jeroen; Reijnders, Lucas; Bronders, Jan; Van Keer, Ilse; Govaerts, Steven
April 2014
Environment & Pollution;Apr2014, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p1
Academic Journal
A probabilistic assessment with sensitivity analysis using Monte Carlo simulation for six vapour intrusion algorithms, used in various regulatory frameworks for contaminated land management, is presented here. In addition a deterministic approach with default parameter sets is evaluated against observed concentrations for benzene, ethylbenzene and trichloroethylene. The screening-level algorithms are ranked according to accuracy and conservatism in predicting observed soil air and indoor air concentrations at two contaminated sites to determine their suitability for regulatory purposes and the possible occurrence of false-negative errors. Dominant parameters that drive the predictions are grouped by either physico-chemical, soil or building parameters, and also by parameters that are either uncertain or variable, to determine the prioritisation for further research actions such as additional measurements. The findings from this study suggest that the screening-level algorithms that have a higher degree of conservatism for their default parameter set are the Johnson and Ettinger model, Dilution Factor algorithm from Sweden, Vlier-Humaan and VolaSoil. From these four algorithms the Johnson and Ettinger model and VolaSoil have a relative high accuracy (discriminative power). For the latter two algorithms different parameters, that are variable and uncertain, contribute to the variation in indoor air concentration, and differences were observed between the aromatic and chlorinated hydrocarbons. For the chlorinated hydrocarbon trichloroethylene, the default parameter set of Vlier-Humaan, CSoil and Dilution Factor algorithm of Sweden might be adapted to arrive at a higher deterministically predicted indoor air concentration if more conservatism is required. The deterministically predicted air concentrations for aromatic hydrocarbons seem to be sufficiently conservative. It is shown that the probabilistic approach allows for an improved insight into the relative importance of parameters in the risk estimates.


Related Articles

  • Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis of coastal flood damage estimates in the west of the Netherlands. De Moel, H.; Asselman, N. E. M.; Aerts, J. C. J. H. // Natural Hazards & Earth System Sciences;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p1045 

    Uncertainty analyses of flood damage assessments generally require a large amount of model evaluations. This is often hampered by the high computational costs necessary to calculate flood extents and depths using 2-dimensional flow models. In this paper we developed a new approach to estimate...

  • Sensitivity Analysis in Radiological Risk Assessment using Double Monte Carlo Method. Boruah, Hrishikesh; Ali, Tazid; Dutta, Palash // International Journal of Computer Applications;May2012, Vol. 46, p16 

    Sensitivity analysis is a study of how changes in the inputs to a model influence the results of the model. Many techniques are available when the model is probabilistic. In this paper we consider a related problem of sensitivity analysis when the model includes uncertain variable that can...

  • Modeling the Human Kinetic Adjustment Factor for Inhaled Volatile Organic Chemicals:Whole Population Approach versus Distinct Subpopulation Approach. Valcke, M.; Nong, A.; Krishnan, K. // Journal of Toxicology;2012, p1 

    The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of whole- and sub-population-related variabilities on the determination of the human kinetic adjustment factor (HKAF) used in risk assessment of inhaled volatile organic chemicals (VOCs). Monte Carlo simulations were applied to a...

  • Automated estimation of rare event probabilities in biochemical systems. Daigle, Bernie J.; Roh, Min K.; Gillespie, Dan T.; Petzold, Linda R. // Journal of Chemical Physics;1/28/2011, Vol. 134 Issue 4, p044110 

    In biochemical systems, the occurrence of a rare event can be accompanied by catastrophic consequences. Precise characterization of these events using Monte Carlo simulation methods is often intractable, as the number of realizations needed to witness even a single rare event can be very large....

  • Transmission probability and active pumping ability of the channel with moving partition plane. Luo, X.; Day, Chr. // AIP Conference Proceedings;2016, Vol. 1786 Issue 1, p1 

    In this paper we present Test Particle Monte Carlo (TPMC) simulations of the transmission probability and the active pumping ability of a rectangular channel of different physical parameters. The novel feature of this problem is that the channel has a partition plane in the middle which is...

  • A MONTE CARLO METHOD FOR CALCULATING BAYESIAN UNCERTAINTIES IN INTERNAL DOSIMETRY. Puncher, M.; Birchall, A. // Radiation Protection Dosimetry;2008, Vol. 132 Issue 1, p1 

    This paper presents a novel Monte Carlo method (WeLMoS, Weighted Likelihood Monte-Carlo sampling method) that has been developed to perform Bayesian analyses of monitoring data. The WeLMoS method randomly samples parameters from continuous prior probability distributions and then weights each...

  • Two novel methods for estimating the compound K-clutter parameters in presence of thermal noise. Mezache, A.; Sahed, M.; Laroussi, T.; Chikouche, D. // IET Radar, Sonar & Navigation;Dec2011, Vol. 5 Issue 9, p934 

    In this study, the authors present two novel methods to estimate the parameters of the compound K-clutter in presence of additive thermal noise. Based on the parametric fitting to the tail of the clutter distribution, the first method estimates simultaneously the unknown parameters. This is...

  • Assessing traffic noise impact based on probabilistic and fuzzy approaches under uncertainty. Wei Peng; Mayorga, Rene V. // Stochastic Environmental Research & Risk Assessment;Jun2008, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p541 

    Traffic noise can cause severe sound pollution for human communities. This paper proposes a hybrid approach to assess traffic noise impact under uncertainty. There are many factors influencing traffic noise level, but only three traffic parameters, namely, traffic flow, traffic speed and traffic...

  • Self-avoiding walks on a simple cubic lattice. Eizenberg, N.; Klafter, J. // Journal of Chemical Physics;9/1/1993, Vol. 99 Issue 5, p3976 

    Dynamic Monte Carlo simulations, using the pivot algorithm, have been performed on a three-dimensional simple cubic lattice in order to study statistical properties of self-avoiding walks of lengths up to about 7200 steps. The scaling properties of the end-to-end distribution function and its...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics