Interspinous Spacer versus Traditional Decompressive Surgery for Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Wu, Ai-Min; Zhou, Yong; Li, Qing-Long; Wu, Xin-Lei; Jin, Yong-Long; Luo, Peng; Chi, Yong-Long; Wang, Xiang-Yang
May 2014
PLoS ONE;May2014, Vol. 9 Issue 5, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Dynamic interspinous spacers, such as X-stop, Coflex, DIAM, and Aperius, are widely used for the treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis. However, controversy remains as to whether dynamic interspinous spacer use is superior to traditional decompressive surgery. Methods: Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library, and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register were searched during August 2013. A track search was performed on February 27, 2014. Study was included in this review if it was: (1) a randomized controlled trial (RCT) or non-randomized prospective comparison study, (2) comparing the clinical outcomes for interspinous spacer use versus traditional decompressive surgery, (3) in a minimum of 30 patients, (4) with a follow-up duration of at least 12 months. Results: Two RCTs and three non-randomized prospective studies were included, with 204 patients in the interspinous spacer (IS) group and 217 patients in the traditional decompressive surgery (TDS) group. Pooled analysis showed no significant difference between the IS and TDS groups for low back pain (WMD: 1.2; 95% CI: −10.12, 12.53; P = 0.03; I2 = 66%), leg pain (WMD: 7.12; 95% CI: −3.88, 18.12; P = 0.02; I2 = 70%), ODI (WMD: 6.88; 95% CI: −14.92, 28.68; P = 0.03; I2 = 79%), RDQ (WMD: −1.30, 95% CI: −3.07, 0.47; P = 0.00; I2 = 0%), or complications (RR: 1.39; 95% CI: 0.61, 3.14; P = 0.23; I2 = 28%). The TDS group had a significantly lower incidence of reoperation (RR: 3.34; 95% CI: 1.77, 6.31; P = 0.60; I2 = 0%). Conclusion: Although patients may obtain some benefits from interspinous spacers implanted through a minimally invasive technique, interspinous spacer use is associated with a higher incidence of reoperation and higher cost. The indications, risks, and benefits of using an interspinous process device should be carefully considered before surgery.


Related Articles

  • Effectiveness of Surgery for Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Machado, Gustavo C.; Ferreira, Paulo H.; Harris, Ian A.; Pinheiro, Marina B.; Koes, Bart W.; van Tulder, Maurits; Rzewuska, Magdalena; Maher, Chris G.; Ferreira, Manuela L. // PLoS ONE;Mar2015, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p1 

    Background: The management of spinal stenosis by surgery has increased rapidly in the past two decades, however, there is still controversy regarding the efficacy of surgery for this condition. Our aim was to investigate the efficacy and comparative effectiveness of surgery in the management of...

  • Comparative Efficacy of Lamivudine and Emtricitabine: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Trials. Ford, Nathan; Shubber, Zara; Hill, Andrew; Vitoria, Marco; Doherty, Meg; Mills, Edward J.; Gray, Andy // PLoS ONE;Nov2013, Vol. 8 Issue 11, p1 

    Introduction: Lamivudine and emtricitabine are considered equivalent by several guidelines, but evidence of comparable efficacy is conflicting. Methods: We searched two databases up to June 30 2013 to identify randomized and quasi-randomized trials in which lamivudine and emtricitabine were used...

  • Submucous Cleft Palate: A Systematic Review of Surgical Management Based on Perceptual and Instrumental Analysis. Gilleard, Onur; Sell, Debbie; Ghanem, Ali; Tavsanoglu, Yasemin; Birch, Malcolm; Sommerlad, Brian // Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal;Nov2014, Vol. 51 Issue 6, p686 

    Objective: Submucous cleft palate (SMCP) is a congenital condition associated with abnormal development of the soft palate musculature. In a proportion of cases, this results in velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI), the treatment for which includes pharyngeal flap surgery, pharyngoplasty, and...

  • Comparative Outcomes of Minimally Invasive Surgery for Posterior Lumbar Fusion: A Systematic Review. Goldstein, Christina; Macwan, Kevin; Sundararajan, Kala; Rampersaud, Y. // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Jun2014, Vol. 472 Issue 6, p1727 

    Background: Although minimally invasive surgical (MIS) approaches to the lumbar spine for posterior fusion are increasingly being utilized, the comparative outcomes of MIS and open posterior lumbar fusion remain unclear. Questions/purposes: In this systematic review, we compared MIS and open...

  • Systematic review and meta-analysis on heavy and lightweight polypropylene mesh in Lichtenstein inguinal hernioplasty. Śmietański, M.; Śmietańska, I.; Modrzejewski, A.; Simons, M.; Aufenacker, T. // Hernia;Oct2012, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p519 

    Background: Recurrence and pain are the two most important outcomes after inguinal hernia surgery. The concept of lightweight or partially absorbable macroporous meshes was developed under the assumption that the observed pain rate could be decreased without increasing the number of recurrences....

  • The role of laparoscopic surgery for ulcerative colitis: systematic review with meta-analysis. Xiao-Jian Wu; Xiao-Sheng He; Xu-Yu Zhou; Jia Ke; Ping Lan // International Journal of Colorectal Disease;Aug2010, Vol. 25 Issue 8, p949 

    Crohn’s disease is established in laparoscopic surgery due to partial bowel dissection and low postoperative complication rate. However, laparoscopic surgery for ulcerative colitis remains further discussed even if the trend of minimally invasive technique exists. This study is to figure...

  • Pancreaticogastrostomy Versus Pancreaticojejunostomy After Pancreaticoduodenectomy: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Clerveus, Michael; Morandeira-Rivas, Antonio; Picazo-Yeste, Joaquín; Moreno-Sanz, Carlos // Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery;Sep2014, Vol. 18 Issue 9, p1693 

    Background: The aim of this systematic review was to compare postoperative outcomes between pancreaticogastrostomy and pancreaticojejunostomy after pancreaticoduodenectomy. Methods: Six databases were systematically reviewed to identify randomized controlled trials comparing...

  • The effect of hinge location on corneal sensation and dry eye after LASIK: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Feng, Yi-fan; Yu, Ji-guo; Wang, Dan-dan; Li, Jun-hua; Huang, Jin-hai; Shi, Jie-liang; Ye, Ting; Wang, Qin-mei; Zhao, Yun-e // Graefe's Archive of Clinical & Experimental Ophthalmology;Jan2013, Vol. 251 Issue 1, p357 

    Background: The aim of this meta-analysis is to investigate the possible effect of hinge location on corneal sensation and dry eye syndrome after laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK). Methods: A comprehensive literature search was conducted in the PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Controlled...

  • Pharmacologic Interventions for Painful Diabetic Neuropathy: An Umbrella Systematic Review and Comparative Effectiveness Network Meta-analysis. Griebeler, Marcio L.; Morey-Vargas, Oscar L.; Brito, Juan P.; Tsapas, Apostolos; Zhen Wang; Carranza Leon, Barbara G.; Phung, Olivia J.; Montori, Victor M.; Murad, M. Hassan // Annals of Internal Medicine;11/4/2014, Vol. 161 Issue 9, p639 

    Background; Multiple treatments for painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy are available. Purpose: To evaluate the comparative effectiveness of oral and topical analgesics for diabetic neuropathy. Data Sources: Multiple electronic databases between January 2007 and April 2014, without language...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics