Harris, Brittany A.
June 2014
Pacific Rim Law & Policy Journal;Jun2014, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p755
Academic Journal
Carbon emissions trading, or cap-and-trade, is increasingly in vogue among Pacific Rim countries as a means of combating climate change. In theory, capand- trade promises to solve climate change by capping and gradually reducing the amount of carbon dioxide and greenhouse gas emissions, and to do so with maximum economic efficiency. In reality, environmentally effective and economically efficient carbon emission trading systems have eluded both the international community and the European Union, and in practice have arguably increased emissions by artificially prolonging and legitimizing reliance on fossil fuels. In spite of this poor track record, five countries on the Pacific Rim committed to reducing their carbon dioxide emissions through domestic trading systems: Australia, China, Japan, New Zealand, and South Korea. Although these countries' commitment to mitigating climate change is admirable, their domestic carbon emissions trading systems are characterized by the very same features that rendered the Kyoto Protocol's international carbon market and the European Union's Emissions Trading Scheme utterly ineffective. These countries are consciously repeating the same mistakes and expecting different results. Analyzing these five experiments, this comment identifies the features that will likely undermine the environmental and efficiency goals of these systems. This comment argues that due to these shortcomings, the emissions trading systems on the Pacific Rim will not lower carbon dioxide emissions to safe levels--instead, they will exacerbate climate change by artificially prolonging and legitimizing the use of fossil fuels. In addition, the reappearance on the Pacific Rim of these unsound design features lends credence to the theory that emissions trading is fundamentally unreliable as a means of regulating and reducing greenhouse gas emissions


Related Articles

  • Carbon Markets Gain Momentum, Despite Challenges. Chafe, Zoë // World Watch;May/Jun2008, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p30 

    The article focuses on the expansion of the global carbon market. Carbon markets are designed to combat climate change by putting a price on carbon dioxide (CO[sub 2]) and other greenhouse gases, and then allowing companies and other entities to trade the right to emit these gases through...

  • 10 years ago... Brazier, Chris // New Internationalist;Jul/Aug2016, Issue 494, p8 

    The article reflects on the report published in a 2006 issue of "New Internationalist" journal which focused on carbon offsetting, climate change and fossil fuel consumption.

  • AMAZONIA ON THE BRINK. Lovejoy, Thomas E. // Foreign Service Journal;Apr2008, Vol. 85 Issue 4, Special section p23 

    The article presents information on the role of the Amazon River Basin in bringing about climatic changes. It is stated that the basin is an important source of greenhouse gases, and also has a great ability to absorb these gases. Greenhouse gases are released from the combustion of fossil...

  • Drought, climate and policy. Smith, Dingle // Geodate;Aug2005, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p5 

    Discusses the environmental conditions in Australia in 2005. Impact of drought on the country; Link between greenhouse gas emissions and climate change; Government policy toward drought.

  • The next industrial revolution. Gottliebsen, Robert // BRW;02/09/98, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p6 

    Reports on the impact of the decision to raise Australia's carbon quota in the Kyoto agreement of 1998. Commercial advantage given to Australia over other developed nations; Value of energy assets influenced by carbon quotas; How uranium is seen as a big winner; Use of cement, a high-energy...

  • THE DURBAN DECLARATION ON CARBON TRADING.  // Rachel's Democracy & Health News;8/2/2007, Issue 918, p2 

    The article presents the Durban declaration on carbon trading, signed by various representatives of people's movements and independent organizations on October 10, 2004 in Durban, South Africa. The signatories reject the claim that carbon trading will halt the climate crisis. They argue that...

  • Steer clear of this climate 'Ponzi scheme'. Bond, Patrick; Dorsy, Michael // Foreign Policy in Focus;01/24/2012, p6 

    The article warns carbon buyers, sellers and investment speculators of yet another Ponzi scheme, the privatization of the air via the European Trading Scheme. Analysts forecast a decline in carbon prices and an oversupply due to huge flow of United Nations (UN) offsets. They see the...

  • Ready, Offset, Go! Luchessa, Scott // National Wetlands Newsletter;Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p12 

    The article focuses on the use of wetlands in developing carbon offsets and creating markets that would help in reducing greenhouse gases to mitigate climate change. It notes that wetlands are an important part of the global carbon balance because the global, organic, and terrestrial carbon...

  • An economic perspective on rock concerts and climate change: Should carbon offsets compensating emissions be included in the ticket price? Connolly, Marie; Dupras, Jérôme; Séguin, Charles // Journal of Cultural Economics;Feb2016, Vol. 40 Issue 1, p101 

    Musicians, singers and bands can use their popularity to promote various causes and products, either through endorsements or more individual initiatives. Environmental activism is becoming more widespread as humans are trying to tackle and mitigate climate change. In this paper, we ask how best...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics