Selecting the Best Flood Flow Frequency Model Using Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making

Mohammadpour, Osman; Hassanzadeh, Yousef; Khodadadi, Ahmad; Saghafian, Bahram
September 2014
Water Resources Management;Sep2014, Vol. 28 Issue 12, p3957
Academic Journal
Several criteria should be considered when selecting a probability distribution to describe hydrological data. This study examines how multiple criteria can be combined to make the best selection. Selection becomes more difficult and subjective when more than two criteria are used to determine the best distribution. Under these conditions, multi-criteria decision-making is necessary. In this study, 12 distributions were tested and compared for flood frequency analysis based on five selection criteria: root mean square error, Kolmogorov-Smirnov test statistic, relative average bias, modified Anderson-Darling test, and deviation in skewness and kurtosis. The comparisons are made using a multi-criteria group decision-making ( MCGDM) based on ordered weighted averaging ( OWA). Two preemptive goal programming models based on variance and entropy methods for a predetermined level of optimism by a group of decision-makers, determined the weight of the OWA operator. The model was applied to a case study of Mahabad River, a major river flowing into Lake Urmia in northwestern Iran. A sensitivity analysis of the results of MCGDM was done by changing the degree of optimism of the decision-makers. The results of sensitivity analysis showed the dependence of the rankings to the optimism degrees of the decision-makers. The 3-parameter Weibull ( WBL3) and Pearson type 3 ( PE3) distributions had the best results for Mahabad River flood data. A Monte Carlo simulation was conducted to test the ability of the models. It was concluded from the findings of the simulation that the PE3 distribution is the most appropriate for short sample sizes, while WBL3 is preferable for larger sample sizes.


Related Articles

  • Sensitivity Analysis in Radiological Risk Assessment using Double Monte Carlo Method. Boruah, Hrishikesh; Ali, Tazid; Dutta, Palash // International Journal of Computer Applications;May2012, Vol. 46, p16 

    Sensitivity analysis is a study of how changes in the inputs to a model influence the results of the model. Many techniques are available when the model is probabilistic. In this paper we consider a related problem of sensitivity analysis when the model includes uncertain variable that can...

  • Modelling gross primary production in the Heihe river basin and uncertainty analysis. Li, Shihua; Xiao, Jiangtao; Xu, Wenbo; Yan, Huimin // International Journal of Remote Sensing;Feb2012, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p836 

    Accurate and timely monitoring of gross primary production (GPP) at regional and global scales is necessary for understanding the terrestrial biosphere carbon balance. In this article, 8-day composite GPP is estimated using the region production efficiency model (REG-PEM) in the Heihe river...

  • AN ASYMPTOTICALLY UNBIASED MOMENT ESTIMATOR OF A NEGATIVE EXTREME VALUE INDEX. Caeiro, Frederico; Gom, M. Ivette // Discussiones Mathematicae: Probability & Statistics;2010, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p5 

    In this paper we consider a new class of consistent semi-parametric estimators of a negative extreme value index, based on the set of the k largest observations. This class of estimators depends on a control or tuning parameter, which enables us to have access to an estimator with a null...

  • On Using an Approximate Noncentral t-Distribution in Determining a One-Side Upper Limit for Future Sample Relative Reproducibility Standard Deviations. McClure, Foster D.; Lee, Jung K. // Journal of AOAC International;Mar/Apr2007, Vol. 90 Issue 2, p575 

    The article describes the use of an approximate noncentral t-distribution in determining a one-side upper limit for future sample relative reproducibility standard deviations. The accuracy of the formula with respect to the computed upper limit and probability was compared to limit values and...

  • Estimating a nonlinear function of a normal mean. Stefanski, Leonard A.; Novick, Steven J.; Devanarayan, Viswanath // Biometrika;Sep2005, Vol. 92 Issue 3, p732 

    We derive a Monte-Carlo-amenable, minimum variance unbiased estimator of a nonlinear function of a normal mean and the variance of the estimator. Applications to problems arising in the analysis of data measured with error are described.

  • A network with tunable clustering, degree correlation and degree distribution, and an epidemic thereon. Ball, Frank; Britton, Tom; Sirl, David // Journal of Mathematical Biology;Mar2013, Vol. 66 Issue 4/5, p979 

    A random network model which allows for tunable, quite general forms of clustering, degree correlation and degree distribution is defined. The model is an extension of the configuration model, in which stubs (half-edges) are paired to form a network. Clustering is obtained by forming small...

  • Enhancement, evaluation and implementation of a load forecasting method. Qader, M. R.; Qamber, I. // Journal of the Association of Arab Universities for Basic & Appl;Apr2012, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1 

    The effect of load forecast uncertainty may be well-defined if some of the spinning reserve capacity is needed to supply the load in excess of the amount predicted and, thereby the spinning reserve is reduced. The model was developed for load estimation of Kingdom of Bahrain. The calculation...

  • Monte Carlo Simulation: Still Stuck in Low Gear. McCarthy, Ed // Journal of Financial Planning;Jan2000, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p54 

    This article examines the reasons for financial planners' slow adaptation of Monte Carlo simulation (MCS). Spreadsheet mastery is the first requirement for working with add-ins; a solid grasp of statistics is the second. MCS add-ins rely on the user to supply the statistical distribution and its...

  • CONFIDENCE INTERVALS FOR THE RATIO OF TWO INDEPENDENT COEFFICIENTS OF VARIATION OF NORMAL DISTRIBUTION. Wongkhao, Arunee; Niwitpong, Sa-aat; Niwitpong, Suparat // Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences;Nov2015, Vol. 98 Issue 6, p741 

    This paper proposes two new confidence intervals for the ratio of two independent coefficients of variation of normal distribution based on the concept of the general confidence interval (GCI) and the method of variance estimates recovery (MOVER). A Monte Carlo simulation study was conducted to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics