Environmental impacts of decommissioning nuclear power plants: methodical challenges, case study, and implications

Seier, Maximilian; Zimmermann, Till
December 2014
International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment;Dec2014, Vol. 19 Issue 12, p1919
Academic Journal
Purpose: Environmental impacts of the decommissioning of nuclear power plants are brought into focus by the nuclear phase-out in Germany and a worldwide growing number of decommissioning projects. So far, life cycle assessments of decommissioning nuclear power plants have been conducted very rarely or are based on rather uncertain assumptions. Against this background, environmental impacts of the ongoing decommissioning of the nuclear power plant in Lubmin (KGR), Germany are examined. Methodological aspects like transferability to other decommissioning projects as well as influence of assumptions about the lifespan of a power plant are discussed. Methods: A life cycle assessment of the decommissioning according to ISO 14040/44 is conducted. The decommissioning of one power plant (of the assessed KGR) is chosen as functional unit. The system boundaries include removal and demolition of plant components and buildings as well as decontamination, conditioning, interim storage, and final repository of low-level and interim-level nuclear waste together with disposal and recycling of conventional waste. Interim storage and final repository of high-level nuclear waste such as fuel rods are excluded from the system boundaries as they are assigned to the use phase of the plant. Primary data was obtained from the plant decommissioning firm (Energiewerke Nord GmbH, EWN) in Lubmin. The GaBi database was used to model background processes. Environmental impacts are estimated using the CML2001 methodology. Results and discussion: Environmental impacts are mainly caused by on-site energetic demands of component removal and peripheral tasks. Further significant impacts are caused by the handling, storage, and final repository of low-level and intermediate-level nuclear waste. Recycling conventional, nonradioactive metallic waste has the potential to unburden the process in a significant scale, depending on recycling rates. Conclusions: The dismantling of nuclear power plants shows a relevant environmental impact. Regarding the environmental impacts per kilowatt-hour assumptions concerning the plant' lifespan are a crucial factor. Comparing the result from this study to recent datasets for nuclear power poses the question if LCA datasets represent environmental burdens of nuclear power accurately. The transferability of LCA results to other studies using one parameter for scaling is problematic and needs further research.


Related Articles

  • Feasibility Analysis of Alternative Electricity Systems by 2030 in the Post-Fukushima Era. Nyun-Bae Park; Sanghoon Lee; Jin-Yi Han Eui; Chan Jeon // Asian Journal of Atmospheric Environment (AJAE);2014, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p59 

    The Fukushima nuclear accident in 2011 had an extensive impact on the national electricity plans. This paper outlines alternative electricity scenarios that meet the goals of nuclear phase-out and greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction. This paper also analyzes the results of each scenario in...

  • It's Always Too Soon for Nuclear Power--and Already Too Late. Cox, Stan // Synthesis-Regeneration: A Magazine of Green Social Thought;Fall2011, Issue 56, p14 

    Having positioned itself in recent years for a comeback, the nuclear power industry is now, once again, on the defensive. Its promoters are arguing that nothing has changed, because this year’s nuclear disaster in Japan occurred under exceptional circumstances (as if the only catastrophes...

  • Germany’s merger of energy and climate change policy. Mez, Lutz // Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists;Nov2012, Vol. 68 Issue 6, p22 

    Nuclear exit has been on the German policy agenda for more than three decades. After the Chernobyl accident in 1986, a majority of the public and relevant stakeholders opposed nuclear power and strove for renewable energy alternatives. At the same time, climate change policy gained the attention...

  • International team review nuclear regulation.  // RoSPA Occupational Safety & Health Journal;Nov2013, Vol. 43 Issue 11, p3 

    The article reports on the progress of the nuclear regulatory system in Great Britain. An international team of nuclear experts said that Great Britain has effectively responded to Fukushima Nuclear Accident in Japan. However, the team has identified various areas that need attention or...

  • Will Japan's nuclear restart restore global confidence in atomic energy. Excell, Jon // Engineer (Online Edition);8/12/2015, p4 

    The article presents insights on the restart of nuclear reactor in Japan and the possible restoration of global confidence in atomic energy. Topics covered include the decline in confidence in nuclear energy in the wake of Fukushima crisis in 2011, the opposition by majority of Japanese citizens...

  • German Power Unleashed. King, Wyatt C. // Green Builder Magazine;Sep2012, Vol. 7 Issue 9, p62 

    The article reports on the commitment of Germany to phase out its nuclear power plants following the Fukushima disaster and its goal to become the first industrial country that relies on renewable energy. It explores the deployment of smart technologies to ensure a stable supply of power, the...

  • The UnAtomic Age. HARRIS, JIM // Alternatives Journal (AJ) - Canada's Environmental Voice;Jul/Aug2014, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p55 

    The article focuses on the Fukushima Nuclear Accident in Fukushima, Japan, in 2011 and cost of refurbishment of nuclear power plants in Ontario, Canada. Topics discussed include decommissioning the Darlington nuclear reactors in southeastern Ontario, a study on value proposition of expansion in...

  • Fukushima and Risk Analysis. BEASLEY, RON // Moderate Voice;10/9/2013, p7 

    The article reports on the challenges in analyzing the intensity of risk associated with Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant disaster in Japan, which is the worst nuclear power plant disaster in the world. The building of the power plant which was damaged by the earthquake and tsunami that hit...

  • Fukushima effect rolls on. pearce, fred // New Scientist;4/7/2012, Vol. 214 Issue 2859, p4 

    The article looks at changes to nuclear power plants in reaction to public safety concerns following the 2011 Fukushima Daiichi nuclear accident in Japan. Projects to build new reactors were halted in countries including Switzerland, Italy, and China, but several new plants are planned for Great...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics