Nationalism, Patriotism, and New Subjects of Ideological Hegemony

Murray, John
January 2011
Journal of Philosophy: A Cross-Disciplinary Inquiry;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 14, p30
Academic Journal
This essay traces threads of nationalist sentiment from three different historical periods of 19th Century Britain, to pre-World War II Germany, to the United States of post- 9/11, and evidences how even most noble expressions of nationalism and patriotism might be corrupted by the dominant cultural hegemonies. The term "nationalism" is frequently considered a synonym of "patriotism." Although the terms emphasize the value of selfdetermination and solidarity among members of nation-states, nationalism is the governing principle that unifies disparate social entities through a common national identity that is made accessible to many but not all members of the public. Patriotism is the attitudes and behaviors we exhibit within a public forum to validate our placement within national discourse. How we synchronize nationalist agendas with patriotic fervor determines our success in nation-building and in the creation of a global community responsive to needs and interests of our human condition, a condition that dwarfs and precedes all other ideologies and modes of classification. The prefigurations of culture and society predispose us toward assuming a normalized subjectivity that predicts potential patterns of behavior and attitudes in response to hegemonic domination. In seeking to refine and preserve national identity, each of these societies has embraced the replication of hegemony and situated oppositional narratives within coercive doctrines of patriotism and national unity.


Related Articles

  • PATRIOTISM AND MILITARY VALUES. Ilisoi, Diana; Nagy, Daniela // Review of the Air Force Academy;Dec2011, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p121 

    Patriotism may be generated by the formation of active and informed citizens and by the development of civic conscience, compassion and tolerance in a world of multiple diversities, which coexist and impose tight observation on extremes. The patriotic behavior, reflected by solidarity,...

  • The violence of remembering and forgetting: gender, nation and narration in the aesthetic reception of Dido/Elissa. Zayzafoon, Lamia Ben Youssef // International Journal of Francophone Studies;2005, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p71 

    This article examines the representation of Dido/Elissa in Tunisian literature and nationalism and the literary, visual and performing arts of the West. This study has three central arguments. The first holds that the myth of Dido has served in these various discourses as an aesthetic tool to...

  • The Problem of National Solidarity in Interwar Germany. Föllmer, Moritz // German History;May2005, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p202 

    The article focuses on the problem of national solidarity in interwar Germany. Many historians see german nationalism as a crucial factor in the rise and establishment of National Socialism. The article focuses on German nationalism between 1918 and 1939, which was not only hugely influential,...

  • Cursed with Patriotism. The Educational Potential of Enslavement (Polish Society in the Russian Partition of Poland in the First Half of the 19th Century). Jędrychowska, Barbara // Czech-Polish Historical & Pedagogical Journal;2014, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p40 

    The paper presents the educational space of Polish homes and schools during the Partitions of Poland, with emphasis on its crucial role in the process of integration of the young generation, the birth of solidarity among them, and shaping their national and civic identity. Especially the...

  • When talk turns to patriotism. Newcomb, Amelia // Christian Science Monitor;11/20/2001, Vol. 93 Issue 250, p11 

    Considers different forms of patriotism in the United States, the view that the American flag may be seen as a sign of solidarity, and problems which have been created by patriotic gestures.

  • Particular Features of the Intellectual Patriotic Discourse in Germany of the 1990s. Korotetskaya, L. V. // Polis: Journal of Political Studies;2012, Issue 1, p92 

    The article presents analysis of the themes, related with questions of self- determination and patriotism, and topical for the scientific-humanitarian discourse of Germany in the 1990s. An attempt has been made to single out the fundamental thematical dominants and to confront particular...

  • UNITY SPELLS VICTORY. Seramur, Clare // Education;Sep1943, Vol. 64 Issue 1, p46 

    The article stresses the significance of unity among Americans in bringing freedom and peace. It references the heroic deeds of its patriots just to achieve peace and lasting freedom. Among the notable contributors in the quest of American dream for peace was Morton Davis, a navy captain who...

  • Indian Multiculturalism: Living together Separately. Chaskar, Ashok // Literary Insight;Jan2011, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p19 

    Multiculturalism is one of the most contested issues in the post- modern world. It has several meanings and connotations. But there is no monistic view on multiculturalism, as there are different multicultural societies, so there are different multiculturalisms. Though the term `culture' is...

  • HELP ME I'M THE PRISONER, WON'T YOU HEAR MY PLEA? CHAMAS, SOPHIE // Kalimat Magazine;Autumn2011, Vol. 1 Issue 3, p27 

    The article discusses Tadamon, a collective which works in solidarity with struggles for self-determination, equality and justice in the Middle East and in Diaspora communities in Montreal, Quebec and beyond. It informs that Tadamon was founded in 2005 by activists from the Lebanon community in...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics