Our Unsettled Ninth Amendment: An Essay on Unenumerated Rights and the Impossibility of Textualism

Seidman, Louis Michael
December 2010
California Law Review;Dec2010, Vol. 98 Issue 6, p2129
Academic Journal
The Ninth Amendment�our resident anarchic and sarcastic "constitutional jester"�mocks the effort of scholars and judges alike to tame and normalize constitutional law. The Amendment stubbornly resists control. It stands as a paradoxical, textual monument to the impossibility of textualism, an entrenched, settled instantiation of the inevitability of unsettlement. If it did not exist, constitutional skeptics would have had to invent it. Part I of this essay presents a new originalist account of the Ninth Amendment. It argues that the Amendment deliberately leaves unsettled the status of unenumerated rights. Because of the Ninth Amendment, the Constitution does not "deny" or "disparage" these rights, but neither does it embrace or imply them. The Amendment puts off to another day a final reckoning of the extent to which we are bound by constitutional text. Part II argues that the Ninth Amendment states a truth that we would have to deal with whether or not it was part of the original text: No matter how comprehensive, no text can control the force of ideas and commitments that lie outside the text. This simple truth leaves the status of liberal constitutionalism permanently and inevitably unsettled. The day of final reckoning will never arrive.


Related Articles

  • The Inescapable Federalism of the Ninth Amendment. Lash, Kurt T. // Iowa Law Review;3/1/2008, Vol. 93 Issue 3, p801 

    For the past several decades, the majority of courts and commentators have viewed the Ninth Amendment as a provision justifying judicial enforcement of unenumerated individual rights against state and federal abridgment. The most influential advocate of this libertarian reading of the Ninth...

  • Votes for Women.  // America;8/7/1920, Vol. 23 Issue 16, p375 

    The author reflects on the progress of the proposed Nineteenth Amendment that would give women the right to vote in the U.S. He asserts that with the passage of the Nineteenth Amendment, the transformation of the old American Republic will be fairly complete. He argues that it is useless to...

  • Constitution 101. Wilmore, Kathy // Junior Scholastic;2/7/2011, Vol. 113 Issue 10, p6 

    The article offers information on the most commonly cited constitutional amendments in the U.S., along with its meaning and usage including the 1st amendment on the free exchange of ideas particularly on religion, the 2nd amendment on the militia, and the 8th amendment on bails.

  • Just say no.  // Commonweal;2/28/97, Vol. 124 Issue 4, p5 

    Editorial. Presents the postponement of the Republican leadership in Congress in bringing the Balanced-budget Amendment to a vote in the Senate. Requirements for the ratification of the amendment; How the amendment stipulates that the majority in Congress should suspend the Balanced-budget...

  • Why the 9th Amendment? KUCHAR, FRANK // Ellis County Press;2/11/2016, Vol. 24 Issue 45, p3 

    The article offers the author's perspective on what differs the 9th Amendment from the 10th Amendment in the U.S. Constitution.

  • People v. Bennett: Analytic approaches to recognizing a fundamental parental right under the... Witte, Daniel E. // Brigham Young University Law Review;1996, Vol. 1996 Issue 1, p183 

    Analyzes the parental rights on the upbringing of a child under the Ninth Amendment of the United States Constitution based on the case of People v. Bennett. Facts of the case; Points of disagreement between majority and dissent; Teleological interpretation.

  • CONSTITUTIONAL DISUSE OR DESUETUDE: THE CASE OF ARTICLE V. ALBERT, RICHARD // Boston University Law Review;May2014, Vol. 94 Issue 3, p1029 

    Article V of the United States Constitution is in decline and disuse. Studies of comparative formal amendment difficulty, the decelerating pace of Article V amendments, and the relative infrequency of Article V amendments in the modern era - the most recent having been ratified roughly one...

  • The Case for New Textualism. Kendall, Doug; Ryan, Jim // Democracy: A Journal of Ideas;Summer2011, Issue 21, p66 

    The article presents an analysis of the flaws of applying the conservative account of constitutional interpretation in the U.S. According to the authors, the approach that considers the Constitution as open-textured is wrong since the U.S. Constitution contains concrete terms which dictate the...

  • A Dialogue on Statutory and Constitutional Interpretation. Scalia, Antonin; Manning, John F. // George Washington Law Review Arguendo;Nov2012, Vol. 80 Issue 6, p1610 

    The article focuses on several issues being raised concerning statutory and constitutional interpretation in the U.S. It mentions the use of legislative history as well as the legislators' purpose in passing a bill. It also mentions the difference between the absurdity doctrine and the doctrines...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics