Mini vs. Standard Implants for Mandibular Overdentures: A Randomized Trial

de Souza, R. F.; Ribeiro, A. B.; Della Vecchia, M. P.; Costa, L.; Cunha, T. R.; Reis, A. C.; Albuquerque, R. F.
October 2015
Journal of Dental Research;Oct2015, Vol. 94 Issue 10, p1376
Academic Journal
journal article
A mandibular implant-retained overdenture is considered a first-choice treatment for edentulism. However, some aspects limit the use of standard implants-for example, the width of edentulous ridges, chronic diseases, fear, or costs. This randomized trial compared mandibular overdentures retained by 2 or 4 mini-implants with standard implants, considering oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL), patient satisfaction, and complications such as lost implant. In sum, 120 edentulous men and women (mean age, 59.5 ± 8.5 y) randomly received 4 mini-implants, 2 mini-implants, or 2 standard implants. Participants provided data regarding OHRQoL and satisfaction until 12 mo. Clinical parameters, including implant survival rate, were also recorded. Both 2 and 4 mini-implants led to better OHRQoL, compared with 2 standard implants. Treatment with 4 mini-implants was more satisfying than 2 standard implants, with 2 mini-implants presenting intermediate results. Implant survival rate was 89%, 82%, and 99% for 4 mini-implants, 2 mini-implants, or 2 standard implants, respectively. Overdentures retained by 4 or 2 mini-implants can achieve OHRQoL and satisfaction at least comparable with that of 2 standard implants. However, the survival rate of mini implants is not as high as that of standard implants (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01411683).


Related Articles

  • An Eight-year Follow-up to a Randomized Clinical Trial of Participant Satisfaction with Three Types of Mandibular Implant-retained Overdentures. Timmerman, R.; Stoker, G. T.; Wismeijer, D.; Oosterveld, P.; Vermeeren, J. I. J. F.; van Waas, M. A. J. // Journal of Dental Research;Aug2004, Vol. 83 Issue 8, p630 

    Studies have shown that mandibular implant overdentures significantly increase satisfaction and quality of life of edentulous elders. Improved chewing ability appears to have a positive impact on nutritional state. Therefore, it is important to determine the best design of this prosthesis over...

  • A 5-Year Randomized Trial to Compare 1 or 2 Implants for Implant Overdentures. Bryant, S.R.; Walton, J.N.; MacEntee, M.I. // Journal of Dental Research;Jan2015, Vol. 94 Issue 1, p36 

    The hypothesis of this 5-y randomized clinical trial was that there would be no significant difference in the satisfaction of edentulous participants with removable complete overdentures attached to 1 or 2 mandibular implants. Secondary aims were to test changes in satisfaction between and...

  • Mandibular Overdentures: Professional Time for Prosthodontic Maintenance During the First Year of Service Using Three Different Implant Systems. Watson, Gilbert K.; Payne, Alan G. T.; Purton, David G.; Thomson, W. Murray // International Journal of Prosthodontics;Jul/Aug2002, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p379 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the professional time required for the prosthodontic maintenance events of mandibular implant overdentures during the first year of service using three different implant systems (ITI, Steri-Oss, or Southern). Materials and Methods: Seventy-two...

  • The single midline implant in the edentulous mandible: a systematic review. Passia, Nicole; Kern, Matthias // Clinical Oral Investigations;Sep2014, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p1719 

    Objectives: The concept of a single midline implant retaining a complete mandibular denture is controversially discussed among experts. Studies are rare in the literature, and commonly accepted recommendations for this treatment options are not available. This systematic literature review was...

  • Three-Year Clinical Outcomes of Implant Treatments Provided at a Predoctoral Implant Program. Lee, Damian J.; Harlow, Rand F.; Yuan, Judy Chia-Chun; Sukotjo, Cortino; Knoernschild, Kent L.; Campbell, Stephen D. // International Journal of Prosthodontics;2011, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p71 

    Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcomes from a predoctoral implant clinic over 3 years. Materials and Methods: All patients who received implant-retained mandibular overdentures (IODs) or a single-tooth implant (STI) restoration in the Predoctoral Implant Program at...

  • Long-term Survival Rates of Implants Supporting Overdentures. Balaguer, José; Ata-Ali, Javier; Peñarrocha-Oltra, David; García, Berta; Peñarrocha-Diago, María // Journal of Oral Implantology;Apr2015, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p173 

    The study aims were to evaluate survival rates of dental implants in patients wearing maxillary and mandibular overdentures in relation to age, sex, smoking, implant splinting or non-splinting, the maxilla rehabilitated, and number of implants per dental arch. This was a prospective study of...

  • Two implant overdenture - the first alternative treatment for patients with complete edentulous mandible. Imre, M. Melescanu; Marin, M.; Preoteasa, E.; Tancu, A. M.; Preoteasa, C. T. // Journal of Medicine & Life;Apr-Jun2011, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p207 

    Given the increasing life expectancy in the coming years, dental practitioners, as other specialists from different medical fields, will encounter an increasing number of complete edentulous patients. These patients, with a longer active life and higher standards of life quality, will have...

  • The Influence of Bar Design (Round Versus Milled Bar) on Prosthodontic Maintenance of Mandibular Overdentures Supported by 4 Implants: A 5-Year Prospective Study. Krennmair, Gerald; Krainhöfner, Martin; Piehslinger, Eva // International Journal of Prosthodontics;2008, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p514 

    Purpose: The aim of the present study was to evaluate the prosthodontic maintenance required for mandibular overdentures supported by 4 implants and splinted with either a round bar and resilient overdenture anchorage or a milled bar with rigid anchorage over a 5-year period. Materials and...

  • Relationship Between Prosthodontic Evaluation and Patient Ratings of Mandibular Conventional and Implant Prostheses. Heydecke, Guido; Klemetti, Esa; Awad, Manal A.; Lund, James P.; Feine, Jocelyne S. // International Journal of Prosthodontics;May/Jun2003, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p307 

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare clinicians' ratings of the state of oral tissues and their satisfaction with treatment to edentulous patients' ratings of treatment success after provision of mandibular implant overdentures or conventional dentures. Materials and Methods: Sixty...


Other Topics