Continuing the debate about measuring asthma in population studies

Peat, J. K.; Toelle, B. G.; Marks, G. B.; Mellis, C. M.
May 2001
Thorax;May2001, Vol. 56 Issue 5, p406
Academic Journal
journal article
The reasons for measuring atopy and airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) and the methods of validating measurements of asthma in population studies continue to be debated. The debate has centred around standards against which to validate asthma measurements but the absence of a "gold standard" makes the criterion validation of measurements difficult. Questionnaires will always be useful but cannot be validated against a doctor diagnosis because of self-selection and recall biases. In practice, measurements should be selected on the merits of what they measure rather than being regarded as validated or non-validated alternatives. The measurement of AHR is invaluable because it is reliable, not influenced by variations in symptom perception or diagnostic trends, and is closely related to the underlying mechanisms of asthma. The value of AHR lies in its high specificity (rate of true negatives) and low sensitivity (rate of false positives) against asthma symptoms which gives additional information about symptomatic subjects. Atopy is also a useful test and, in quantifying its association with asthma, we should not place any currency on ecological evidence. Atopy is a strong risk factor for asthma in the presence of regionally specific allergens and ecological analyses that ignore these effects are diversionary rather than productive. For preventing asthma, we need to identify the group at greatest risk of developing it, measure the risk factors with precision, and develop interventions that are effective in changing environmental exposures and homogeneous outcomes. This is the only approach that has the potential to lead to significant public health benefits.


Related Articles

  • Survey shows asthma still a significant problem.  // Pharmacy Today;Oct2004, Vol. 10 Issue 10, p43 

    The article discusses the findings of a survey Children and Asthma in America 2004, funded by GlaxoSmithKline for Asthma Action America. The survey suggests that the nationwide goals NIH established in 1997 for treating and managing the condition in the U.S. are still far from being met....

  • Effects of helium-oxygen on respiratory mechanics, gas exchange, and ventilation-perfusion relationships in a porcine model of stable methacholine-induced bronchospasm. Watremez, Christine; Liistro, Giuseppe; deKock, Marc; Roeseler, Jean; Clerbaux, Thierry; Detry, Bruno; Reynaert, Marc; Gianello, Pierre; Jolliet, Philippe // Intensive Care Medicine;Sep2003, Vol. 29 Issue 9, p1560 

    Objective: To explore the consequences of helium/oxygen (He/O(2)) inhalation on respiratory mechanics, gas exchange, and ventilation-perfusion (VA/Q) relationships in an animal model of severe induced bronchospasm during mechanical ventilation.Design: Prospective,...

  • Pediatric Asthma: Principles and Treatment. Donnell, Aaron T.; Kumar, Rajesh // Allergy & Asthma Proceedings;Jul/Aug2004, Vol. 25, pS23 

    The article presents information on the principles and treatment of pediatric Asthma. Most asthma management begins in childhood. Asthma is the most common chronic disease of childhood, and approximately one-half of children with asthma present with symptoms before 3 years of age. Between asthma...

  • PEF analysis requiring shorter records for occupational asthma diagnosis. Moore, Vicky C.; Jaakkola, Maritta S.; Burge, Cedd B. S. G.; Pantin, Charles F.; Robertson, Alastair S.; Vellore, Arun Dev; Burge, P. Sherwood // Occupational Medicine;Sep2009, Vol. 59 Issue 6, p413 

    Background The Oasys programme plots serial peak expiratory flow (PEF) measurements and produces scores of the likelihood that the recordings demonstrate occupational asthma. We have previously shown that the area between the mean workday and rest day PEF curves [the area between the curves...

  • Breathing life into asthma research. Sayburn, Anna // Update;5/19/2005, Vol. 70 Issue 5, p5 

    This article discusses about the papers on asthma. After years in which little seemed to change, the past month has seen two new research papers that offer different ways of thinking about the disease. It has been accepted in the Great Britain that regular use of inhaled corticosteroids is the...

  • Breathing dysfunction in asthma. Thomas, Mike // Update;5/19/2005, Vol. 70 Issue 5, p58 

    This article focuses on the breathing dysfunction in asthma. Not so easy to diagnose but treatable, dysfunctional breathing can produce distressing symptoms in asthma patients. As the symptoms of dysfunctional breathing overlap with those of asthma including chest tightness and dyspnoea, it is...

  • Double blind randomised controlled trial of two different breathing techniques in the management of asthma. Slader, C. A.; Reddel, H. K.; Spencer, L. M.; Belousova, E. G.; Armour, C. L.; Bosnic-Anticevich, S. Z.; Thien, F. C. K.; Jenkins, C. R. // Thorax;Aug2006, Vol. 61 Issue 8, p651 

    Background: Previous studies have shown that breathing techniques reduce short acting β2 agonist use and improve quality of life (QoL) in asthma. The primary aim of this double blind study was to compare the effects of breathing exercises focusing on shallow nasal breathing with those of...

  • Worldwide trends in the prevalence of asthma symptoms: phase III of the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC). Pearce, Neil; Aït-Khaled, Nadia; Beasley, Richard; Mallol, Javier; Keil, Ulrich; Mitchell, Ed; Robertson, Colin // Thorax;Sep2007, Vol. 62 Issue 9, p758 

    Background: Phase I of the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) was designed to allow worldwide comparisons of the prevalence of asthma symptoms. In phase III the phase I survey was repeated in order to assess changes over time. Methods: The phase I survey was...

  • Psychometric and utility-based measures of health status of asthmatic patients with different disease control level. Szende, Ágota; Svensson, Klas; Ståhl, Elisabeth; Mészáros, Ágnes; Berta, Gyula Y.; Szende, Agota; Ståhl, Elisabeth; Mészáros, Agnes // PharmacoEconomics;2004, Vol. 22 Issue 8, p537 

    Objective: To explore the relationship between asthma control level and health-related QOL (HR-QOL), and to understand the role of various psychometric and utility-based methods in studying this relationship.Methods: Two hundred and twenty-eight consecutive adult...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics