Is patients' preferred involvement in health decisions related to outcomes for patients with HIV?

Beach, Mary Catherine; Duggan, Patrick S.; Moore, Richard O.; Moore, Richard D
August 2007
JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Aug2007, Vol. 22 Issue 8, p1119
Academic Journal
journal article
Background: Previous studies suggest that patients who are more involved in their medical care have better outcomes.Objectives: We sought to compare health care processes and outcomes for patients with HIV based on their preferred level of involvement in health decisions.Design: Cross-sectional analysis of audio computer-assisted interviews with patients at an urban HIV clinic.Patients: One thousand and twenty-seven patients awaiting an appointment with their primary care provider.Measures: Patients were asked how they preferred to be involved in decisions (doctor makes most or all decisions, doctor and patient share decisions, patient makes all decisions). We also asked patients to rate the quality of communication with their HIV provider, and their self-reported receipt of and adherence to HAART.Results: Overall, 23% patients preferred that their doctor make all or most decisions, 63% preferred to share decisions with their doctor, and 13% preferred to make all final decisions alone. Compared to patients who prefer to share decisions with their HIV provider, patients who prefer that their provider make all/most decisions were significantly less likely to adhere to HAART (OR [odds ratio] 0.57, 95% CI 0.38-0.86) and patients who preferred to make decisions alone were significantly less likely to receive HAART or to have undetectable HIV RNA in unadjusted analyses (OR 0.52, 95% CI 0.31-0.87 for receipt of HAART; OR 0.64, 95% CI 0.44-0.95 for undetectable HIV RNA). After controlling for potentially confounding patient characteristics and differences in patient ratings of communication quality, patients who preferred that their provider make all/most decisions remained significantly less likely to adhere to HAART (OR 0.58, 95% CI 0.38-0.89); however, the associations with receipt of HAART and undetectable HIV RNA were no longer significant (OR 0.60, 95% CI 0.34-1.05 for receipt of HAART; OR 0.80, 95% C.I 0.53-1.20 for undetectable HIV RNA).Conclusions: Although previous research suggests that more patient involvement in health care decisions is better, this benefit may be reduced when the patient wants to make decisions alone. Future research should explore the extent to which this preference is modifiable so as to improve outcomes.


Related Articles

  • Is the quality of the patient-provider relationship associated with better adherence and health outcomes for patients with HIV? Beach, Mary Catherine; Keruly, Jeanne; Moore, Richard D. // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jun2006, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p661 

    PURPOSE: Patient-centeredness, originally defined as understanding each patient as a unique person, is widely considered the standard for high-quality interpersonal care. The purpose of our study was to examine the association between patient perception of being ‘known as a person’...

  • Food insecurity is associated with poor virologic response among HIV-infected patients receiving antiretroviral medications. Wang, Emily A.; McGinnis, Kathleen A.; Fiellin, David A.; Goulet, Joseph L.; Bryant, Kendall; Gibert, Cynthia L.; Leaf, David A.; Mattocks, Kristin; Sullivan, Lynn E.; Vogenthaler, Nicholas; Justice, Amy C.; VACS Project Team // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Sep2011, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p1012 

    Background and Objective: Food insecurity negatively impacts HIV disease outcomes in international settings. No large scale U.S. studies have investigated the association between food insecurity and severity of HIV disease or the mechanism of this possible association. The objective...

  • Decision-making role preferences among patients with HIV: associations with patient and provider characteristics and communication behaviors. Kumar, Rashmi; Korthuis, P. Todd; Saha, Somnath; Chander, Geetanjali; Sharp, Victoria; Cohn, Jonathon; Moore, Richard; Beach, Mary Catherine // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jun2010, Vol. 25 Issue 6, p517 

    Background: A preference for shared decision-making among patients with HIV has been associated with better health outcomes. One possible explanation for this association is that patients who prefer a more active role in decision-making are more engaged in the communication process...

  • What are the essential elements to enable patient participation in medical decision making? Fraenkel, Liana; McGraw, Sarah // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;May2007, Vol. 22 Issue 5, p614 

    Background: Patient participation in shared decision making (SDM) results in increased patient knowledge, adherence, and improved outcomes. Despite the benefits of the SDM model, many patients do not attain the level of participation they desire.Objective: To gain a...

  • "We'll do this together": the role of the first person plural in fostering partnership in patient-physician relationships. Kinsman, Helen; Roter, Debra; Berkenblit, Gail; Saha, Somnath; Korthuis, P. Todd; Wilson, Ira; Eggly, Susan; Sankar, Andrea; Sharp, Victoria; Cohn, Jonathon; Moore, Richard D.; Beach, Mary Catherine // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Mar2010, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p186 

    Partnership is integral to therapeutic relationships, yet few studies have examined partnership-fostering communication behaviors in the clinic setting. We conducted this study to better understand how statements in which physicians use the first person plural might foster partnership between...

  • Cost-effectiveness of highly active antiretroviral therapy in South Africa. Badri, Motasim; Maartens, Gary; Mandalia, Sundhiya; Bekker, Linda-Gail; Penrod, John R.; Platt, Robert W.; Wood, Robin; Beck, Eduard J. // PLoS Medicine;Jan2006, Vol. 3 Issue 1, pe4 

    Background: Little information exists on the impact of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) on health-care provision in South Africa despite increasing scale-up of access to HAART and gradual reduction in HAART prices.Methods and Findings: Use and cost of...

  • Differences in patient-provider communication for Hispanic compared to non-Hispanic white patients in HIV care. Beach, Mary Catherine; Saha, Somnath; Korthuis, P. Todd; Sharp, Victoria; Cohn, Jonathon; Wilson, Ira B.; Eggly, Susan; Cooper, Lisa A.; Roter, Debra; Sankar, Andrea; Moore, Richard; Wilson, Ira // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jul2010, Vol. 25 Issue 7, p682 

    Background: Hispanic Americans with HIV/AIDS experience lower quality care and worse outcomes than non-Hispanic whites. While deficits in patient-provider communication may contribute to these disparities, no studies to date have used audio recordings to examine the communication...

  • Recognition of patient referral desires in an academic managed care plan frequency, determinants, and outcomes. Albertson, Gail A.; Lin, C. T.; Kutner, Jean; Schilling, Lisa M.; Anderson, Susan N.; Anderson, Robert J.; Albertson, G A; Kutner, J; Schilling, L M; Anderson, S N; Anderson, R J // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Apr2000, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p242 

    Objective: To determine the frequency and determinants of provider nonrecognition of patients' desires for specialist referral.Design: Prospective study.Setting: Internal medicine clinic in an academic medical center providing primary care to patients...

  • Variation in physician-patient discussion of breast reconstruction. Chen, Judy Y.; Malin, Jennifer; Ganz, Patricia A.; Ko, Clifford; Tisnado, Diana; May Lin Tao; Timmer, Martha; Adams, John L.; Kahn, Katherine L.; Tao, May Lin // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jan2009, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p99 

    Background: For women with early stage breast cancer, physician-patient discussion of breast reconstruction is an essential step in their participation in the decision-making process for their treatments. This study examines sociodemographic variation of physician-patient discussion...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics