The role of gynecologists in providing primary care to elderly women

Fink, Kenneth S.; Baldwin, Laura-Mae; Lawson, Herschel W.; Chan, Leighton; Rosenblatt, Roger A.; Hart, L. Gary; Fink, K S; Baldwin, L M; Lawson, H W; Chan, L; Rosenblatt, R A; Hart, L G
February 2001
Journal of Family Practice;Feb2001, Vol. 50 Issue 2, p153
Academic Journal
journal article
Background: Federal legislation has recently been proposed to designate obstetrician-gynecologists (OBGs) as primary care physicians. The Institute of Medicine identifies care unrestricted by problem or organ system as an essential characteristic of primary care. We examined the degree to which OBGs in the state of Washington offer this aspect of primary care to their elderly patients by investigating the type and amount of nongynecologic care they provide. Methods: Using 1994 Part B Medicare claims data for Washington residents, we identified visits made by women aged 65 years and older to OBGs (N=10,522) and 9 other types of specialists. Diagnoses were classified as in or out of the domain of care traditionally provided by each specialty. Visit volumes, proportion of out of domain visits, and the frequency of diagnoses were reported. Results: Of the patient visits to obstetrician-gynecologists, 12.2% had nongynecologic diagnoses. The median percentage of nongynecologic visits for individual OBGs was 6.7%. Patients who saw OBGs received 15.4% of their overall health care from an OBG; patients who saw family physicians received 42.9% of their total health care from a family physician. Conclusions: In 1994, a small amount of the care that Washington OBGs provided to their elderly patients was for nongynecologic conditions. Studies are needed to evaluate how the practices of OBGs have changed since the 1996 implementation of a primary care requirement in obstetrics-gynecology residencies, and if adopted, how legislation designating OBGs as primary care physicians affects the health care received by elderly women.


Related Articles

  • The Effects of Physician Supply on the Early Detection of Colorectal Cancer. Roetzheim, Richard G.; Pal, Naazneen; Gonzalez, Eduardo C.; Ferrante, Jeanne M.; Van Durme, Daniel J.; Ayanian, John Z.; Krischer, Jeffrey P. // Journal of Family Practice;Nov1999, Vol. 48 Issue 11, p850 

    BACKGROUND. Policymakers question whether there is a relationship between the number and distribution of physicians and the outcomes for important health conditions. We hypothesized that increasing primary care physician supply would be related to earlier detection of colorectal cancer. METHODS....

  • TOP DOCS.  // Louisville Magazine;Jun2003, Vol. 54 Issue 6, p32 

    This article lists the best primary-care physicians in metro Louisville, Kentucky. The list includes 47 highly regarded family practitioners, internists, pediatricians and obstetrician-gynecologists that has been compiled by the team-members of the journal 'Louisville.' The magazines asked...

  • Congressional resolution defines OB-Gyns as primary care physicians.  // American Family Physician;11/15/1993, Vol. 48 Issue 7, p1217 

    Reports that John Chafee and Barbara Boxer have introduced a resolution at the US Congress in late October 1993 that would define obstetrician-gynecologists as primary care physicians. Objection of the American Academy of Family Physicians to the resolution.

  • How a Woman Selects Her Gynecologic Surgeon and Obstetrician and Which Factors Are Important to Her. Plunkett, Beth A.; Milad, Magdy P. // Journal of Gynecologic Surgery;Fall2000, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p107 

    Presents a study on the process used by patients to select an obstetrician or gynecologist. Physician attributes that are important for patients; Difference between obstetric and gynecologic surgery patients; Limitation of the study.

  • Primary And Preventive Healthcare in Obstetrics And Gynecology: A Study of Practice Patterns in The Mid-Atlantic Region. Stovall, Dale W.; Loveless, Meredith B.; Walden, Nikki A.; Karjane, Nicole; Cohen, Steve A. // Journal of Women's Health (15409996);Jan2007, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p134 

    Objectives: To assess the current perspective of regional obstetrician/gynecologists on providing primary/preventive healthcare, including their desire to provide primary care in their practices and whether or not they are adequately trained as primary care providers. Methods: A...

  • Study: Primary care residents ill-prepared to treat women of reproductive age.  // Primary Care Weekly;6/19/95, Vol. 1 Issue 11, p1 

    Reports on a study at the Cook County Hospital in Chicago, Illinois, showing that primary care residents are ill-prepared to provide adequate care to women of reproductive age. Findings on the importance of primary care interventions on pregnancy related outcomes; Arguments on the...

  • Oh, by the way, doctor... Platt, Frederic W.; Saunders, Carol S. // Patient Care;4/15/2000, Vol. 34 Issue 7, p234 

    Offers information on how primary care physicians can deal with `Oh, by the way doctor' syndrome, or the tendency of patients to not begin consultations with their most pressing problems. Need for physicians to pay attention to their own agendas and those of their patients'; Role of physicians...

  • Patient-physician concordance in problem identification in the primary care setting. Freidin, Ralph B.; Goldman, Lee; Cecil, Rosellen R.; Freidin, R B; Goldman, L; Cecil, R R // Annals of Internal Medicine;Sep80, Vol. 93 Issue 3, p490 

    We analyzed how often patients and physicians identified the same principal problem for 439 return primary care visits. Agreement between the patient and physician, called concordance, was scored as complete when both cited a problem in the same organ-system (208 visits; 47%); as partial when...

  • Your views: Friends and family. Benson, Tim // GP: General Practitioner;3/4/2013, p25 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Friends and family test for primary care" in the February 15, 2013 issue.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics